The complaint
AmTab Manufacturing Corporation v. Palmer Hamilton, LLC, No. 1:26-cv-14401, is a complaint for declaratory judgment filed in the Eastern Division of the Northern District of Illinois on November 18, 2026. It is Document 1 on the docket, and the complaint runs 17 pages. The complaint says this is an action under the Declaratory Judgment Act, 28 U.S.C. §§ 2201 and 2202, to declare that AmTab's mobile folding booths do not and cannot infringe U.S. Patent No. 9,615,665 under 35 U.S.C. § 100, et seq., at least because AmTab has an implied license to that patent for these booths. On November 19, 2026, the docket states that the case was assigned to the Honorable Matthew F. Kennelly. The complaint demands a jury trial under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 38(b).
The parties
The complaint says AmTab Manufacturing Corporation is an Illinois corporation with its principal place of business in Bensenville, Illinois. It says AmTab designs and manufactures furniture and signage, and that AmTab has expended significant time, effort, and resources to design, manufacture, and sell mobile folding booths. It says these booths are widely used in schools and cafeterias nationwide. It says that for nearly 70 years AmTab has designed and manufactured furniture in Illinois, and that it sells these products nationwide.
The complaint alleges, on information and belief, that Palmer Hamilton, LLC is a Wisconsin limited liability company with its principal place of business in Elkhorn, Wisconsin. It alleges, on information and belief, that Palmer Hamilton designs, manufactures, and sells furniture, including mobile folding booths, that compete with AmTab's products.
The patents
The declaratory judgment concerns U.S. Patent No. 9,615,665, which the complaint calls the '665 patent. The face of the patent is U.S. Patent No. 9,615,665 B2, titled "Foldable Mobile Restaurant Booth," issued April 11, 2017, from Application No. 15/180,536, filed June 13, 2016. The face names Palmer Hamilton, LLC, of Elkhorn, Wisconsin, as applicant and assignee. It states that the application is a continuation of Application No. 13/940,564, filed July 12, 2013, now U.S. Patent No. 9,370,265. The face of U.S. Patent No. 9,370,265 B2 shows the same title, an issue date of June 21, 2016, Application No. 13/940,564 filed July 12, 2013, and Palmer Hamilton, LLC, of Elkhorn, Wisconsin, as applicant and assignee. The face of the '665 patent states that it has 8 claims. The face of the '265 patent states that it has 18 claims.
The complaint calls the '665 patent the child and the '265 patent the parent, and says that, as a direct continuation, the two patents share the same disclosure. It says the continuation application that issued as the '665 patent was pending before the USPTO when the parties entered the 2016 settlement and the 2016 case was dismissed with prejudice. The complaint says that on July 21, 2016, the USPTO rejected as obvious some claims of the '665 application, including independent claim 1; that on December 21, 2016, Palmer Hamilton amended the claims, including independent claim 1, which the complaint says Palmer Hamilton now alleges in correspondence that AmTab infringes; that on February 1, 2017, the USPTO issued a notice of allowance; and that the '665 patent issued on April 11, 2017.
Claim 1
The complaint says Palmer Hamilton's draft complaint accuses AmTab's "Mobile Folding Booth Seating" products of infringing one or more claims of the '665 patent, including independent claim 1. Claim 1 covers a collapsible booth seating. It requires first and second laterally spaced seat back supports, and a generally vertically extending seat back having first and second end portions positionally supported by those supports. The seat back comprises an interior frame fixed to the seat back supports and an exterior covering. A seat portion located in front of the seat back has an interior frame and an exterior covering, a first, seating surface, a second surface disposed generally opposite the first surface, and first and second ends. First and second laterally spaced bases are disposed below and support at least one of the seat back and the seat portion on a round, and each base has wheels thereunder for supporting the booth seating on the ground. First and second vertical seat portion supports project upwardly from the respective bases at a location forwardly of the seat back supports, and each has a lower end supported on the respective base. A linkage arrangement is coupled to the seat portion so as to permit the seat portion to move from a first, operative position, in which the seat portion extends at least generally horizontally away from the seat back, to a second, folded position, in which the seat portion extends at an angle of no more than 45 degrees from vertical. First and second laterally spaced seat legs are coupled to the interior frame of the seat portion so as to permit the seat legs to automatically move, upon movement of the seat portion from the first position to the second, from a supporting position in which the seat legs extend at least substantially perpendicularly from the bottom surface of the seat portion, generally vertically downwardly, into a position in which a foot of each of the seat legs is in supporting engagement with the ground at a location in front of the seat portion supports, to a stowed position in which the foot of each of the seat legs is raised out of supporting engagement with the ground.
The 2016 case and the settlement
The complaint says that on July 22, 2016, Palmer Hamilton filed a patent infringement lawsuit in the United States District Court for the Western District of Wisconsin, Palmer Hamilton, LLC v. AmTab Mfg. Corp., No. 3:16-cv-00522, accusing AmTab's mobile folding booths of infringing the '265 patent. It says that less than five months later the parties resolved that case through a written settlement agreement effective December 8, 2016. It says the agreement required Palmer Hamilton to file a stipulated motion dismissing with prejudice all claims asserted in that case, and that the case was dismissed with prejudice.
The complaint quotes the agreement. It says Palmer Hamilton fully and finally released AmTab, its affiliates, officers, directors, shareholders, employees, agents, consultants, and attorneys from claims, demands, causes of action, and liabilities relating to the '265 patent arising out of or related to claims that were asserted or could have been asserted in that case. It says Palmer Hamilton acknowledged that the mobile booth product AmTab offered for sale as of the effective date, shown in Exhibit A to the agreement, "is not covered by any claim of the '265 patent," and covenanted not to sue AmTab for infringement of the '265 patent "by any product substantially in the form of such currently-offered mobile booth product."
The complaint says Exhibit A lists Mobile Folding Booth models MFBS244 and MFBS245 and Mobile Folding Booth Seating Package models MFBSP244, MFBSP245, MFBSP304, and MFBSP305, and that it includes images of those products. The complaint says the agreement does not identify, mention, or discuss the '665 patent or the then-pending application from which the '665 patent issued, and does not exclude that application from the rights granted.
The 2026 correspondence
The complaint says that on July 27, 2026, Palmer Hamilton sent a letter asserting rights in the '665 patent for a foldable mobile restaurant booth. It says the letter specifically accused model MFBSP244, and that Palmer Hamilton stated that it had "come to our attention" that AmTab was selling mobile folding booths that "likely infringe[d]" the '665 patent, identifying the same model numbers listed in Exhibit A to the settlement. The complaint says the letter attached the '265 patent, not the '665 patent, and made no mention of the 2016 case or the settlement. It says Palmer Hamilton did not compare the products to any claims of the '665 patent, and demanded that AmTab "immediately cease manufacturing, importation, selling, and offering for sale or otherwise promoting the mobile folding booth seating and the mobile folding booth seating package with the detached table in question and any other product having the features as described above."
The complaint describes further letters: AmTab's August 6, 2026 response; Palmer Hamilton's August 26, 2026 reply and first claim chart; AmTab's September 10, 2026 response; and Palmer Hamilton's October 23, 2026 reply, with a draft complaint. It says none of Palmer Hamilton's letters mentioned the 2016 case or the settlement. It says the October 23 letter stated that Palmer Hamilton had "physically inspect[ed] the relevant AmTab product," attached a draft complaint captioned for this court, and said that if AmTab did not cooperate in discussions Palmer Hamilton would initiate a lawsuit for patent infringement. The complaint quotes the letter as treating a lack of response by October 30, 2026, as an indication that AmTab was not interested in resolving the matter.
The complaint says the draft complaint accuses AmTab's Mobile Folding Booth Seating products of infringing one or more claims of the '665 patent, including independent claim 1; asserts that AmTab, together with its affiliates, agents, suppliers, and customers, infringes under 35 U.S.C. § 271(a); asserts that AmTab infringes under 35 U.S.C. § 271(b); and seeks enhanced damages and preliminary and permanent injunctive relief. It says the draft complaint does not mention the 2016 case or the settlement.
The complaint says that in the pre-suit correspondence AmTab identified the settlement and asserted that it contains an implied license to the '665 patent. It says Palmer Hamilton's November 6, 2026 letter denied an implied license. The complaint says Palmer Hamilton asserted, and the complaint calls the assertion inaccurate, that "an implied license of a continuation patent only arises when a party expressly licenses the parent patent." It says Palmer Hamilton further argued that the 2016 agreement "did not contain any express, or even implied, license under the '265 patent," that it "merely stipulated that the proposed design was not covered by the '265 patent," and that in the absence of a license under the '265 patent there is no implied license to the '665 patent and legal estoppel is inapplicable. The complaint says that position is incorrect. It says the Federal Circuit has held that a covenant not to sue is not substantively different from a license, and it quotes TransCore, LP v. Elec. Transaction Consultants Corp. for the statement that both are properly viewed as "authorizations." The complaint cites that decision, Gen. Protecht Grp., Inc. v. Leviton Mfg. Co., Endo Pharms. Inc. v. Actavis, Inc., and Cheetah Omni LLC v. AT&T Servs., Inc., and it quotes the rule that a license or a covenant not to sue enumerating specific patents may legally estop the patentee from asserting continuations of the licensed patents in the absence of mutual intent to the contrary.
The complaint says the November 6 letter stated that the "design we photographed appears to be at least similar to the design presented to us in 2016." It says Palmer Hamilton threatened that "[i]n the event that AmTab fails to cooperate and/or take actions to engage in discussions toward amicably resolving this dispute by November 20, 2026, we will have no choice but to file and serve the complaint." The complaint says AmTab currently makes and sells the booths identified in Exhibit A to the settlement, including MFBS244 and MFBSP244, among others, and intends to continue to do so. It says there is a substantial controversy between parties having adverse legal interests, of sufficient immediacy and reality to warrant a declaratory judgment.
Count I
Count I is headed declaratory judgment of non-infringement of the '665 patent. The complaint incorporates paragraphs 1 through 65. It says AmTab does not infringe any claim of the '665 patent because the settlement extends an implied license for the mobile folding booths identified in the agreement and for substantially similar products; because Palmer Hamilton is legally estopped from asserting the '665 patent against those booths and substantially similar products; and, in the alternative, because Palmer Hamilton cannot carry its burden of proving that the accused booths satisfy all the limitations of any claim of the '665 patent. The complaint says an actual controversy exists on whether the settlement extends an implied license, on whether Palmer Hamilton can carry that burden, and on whether Palmer Hamilton is legally estopped. It says AmTab is entitled to a declaratory judgment that it does not infringe any claim of the '665 patent because of the implied license, because Palmer Hamilton is legally estopped, and, alternatively, because Palmer Hamilton cannot carry its burden of proving that the accused booths satisfy all the limitations of any claim.
Jurisdiction and venue
The complaint says AmTab seeks a declaratory judgment that it does not infringe any claim of the '665 patent, and that the court has subject matter jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. §§ 1331, 1338(a), 2201, and 2202, because the action presents a federal question arising under the patent laws, including 35 U.S.C. § 271. It says the court has personal jurisdiction because, since July 2026, Palmer Hamilton has repeatedly sent correspondence into Illinois asserting that AmTab, an Illinois corporation located in this district, infringes the '665 patent; has demanded that AmTab cease all commercial activities related to the mobile folding booths; and has threatened to sue AmTab in this district if AmTab does not comply, including by sending a draft complaint captioned for this court. It says Palmer Hamilton also signed the settlement agreement with AmTab. It says venue is proper under 28 U.S.C. § 1391(b) because a substantial part of the events giving rise to the claim occurred in this district: the booths covered by the settlement are designed and manufactured in, and sold from, the district; the communications alleging infringement and threatening litigation were directed to and received in the district; and the settlement identifies AmTab as an Illinois entity.
The prayer for relief
The prayer asks for a declaration and declaratory judgment, under 28 U.S.C. §§ 2201 and 2202, that AmTab and its customers, officers, directors, shareholders, members, managers, employees, subsidiaries, and affiliates, past, present, and future, have an implied license to the '665 patent, arising from the settlement effective December 8, 2016, to import, use, make, offer for sale, or sell AmTab's mobile folding booths and substantially similar products, and that the license is a complete defense to any future allegations or assertions of Palmer Hamilton's claims of patent infringement of the '665 patent against those products. It asks for a declaration and declaratory judgment, under the same statutes, that AmTab does not infringe and has not infringed any claim of the '665 patent by making, using, offering for sale, selling, or importing those booths and substantially similar products, and that Palmer Hamilton is legally estopped from asserting the '665 patent against those products. It asks for an order declaring the case exceptional under 35 U.S.C. § 285 and awarding AmTab its attorney fees, litigation expenses, and costs. It asks for such equitable or other further relief as the court deems just and proper.
What to watch next
Watch for an answer or a Rule 12 motion. The case can end at any time, including by settlement or voluntary dismissal.