The case and the parties

The case is House of Joppa, LLC v. The Little Catholic, LLC and Priscilla Huerta a/k/a Priscilla Durant, No. 2:26-cv-14342 (E.D. Mich., Southern Division). House of Joppa, LLC filed the complaint on November 16, 2026, and demanded a jury. The complaint says House of Joppa is a Michigan limited liability company with its principal place of business in Plymouth, Michigan. It says the company was founded in 2019 and describes it as a family-owned online gift shop in Southeastern Michigan that sells Christian-themed gifts and religious jewelry. It alleges, upon information and belief, that The Little Catholic, LLC is a California limited liability company with its principal place of business in Laguna Hills, California, and that Priscilla Huerta is its sole owner. It alleges, upon information and belief, that Priscilla Huerta a/k/a Priscilla Durant is a resident of Laguna Hills, California. It alleges, on information and belief, that The Little Catholic, LLC is an online retailer based in California that designs, manufactures, and sells Catholic merchandise and jewelry.

The complaint pleads a declaratory judgment action. It asks for a declaration that House of Joppa does not infringe any valid or enforceable claim of U.S. Design Patents D1,012,750 and D1,043,407 under 35 U.S.C. 271, or, in the alternative, that those patents are invalid, and a declaration that House of Joppa does not infringe copyright registrations VA0002209979 and VAu001510355. It also pleads commercial disparagement and false advertising under section 43(a)(1)(B) of the Lanham Act, 15 U.S.C. 1125(a)(1)(B), and a claim under the Michigan Consumer Protection Act, MCL 445.901 et seq.

The complaint pleads original subject-matter jurisdiction over Counts I through VII under the Declaratory Judgment Act, 28 U.S.C. 2201 and 2202, 28 U.S.C. 1331 and 1338(a), the patent laws, the copyright laws, and the Lanham Act, 15 U.S.C. 1121 et seq. It pleads supplemental jurisdiction over Count VIII under 28 U.S.C. 1367(a). It alleges, on information and belief, that the court has personal jurisdiction because the defendants market, sell, and offer products for sale in the district through their website and purposefully directed communications, including the demand letter, and published online statements into Michigan. It pleads venue under 28 U.S.C. 1391(b) and (c).

The necklace and the demand letter

The complaint says that on or about October 2026 House of Joppa introduced a necklace it calls the HOJ Necklace, with three hearts arranged in an arc and inspired by Hearts of the Holy Family iconography. It says the Immaculate Heart of Mary is on the viewer's left, the Sacred Heart of Jesus is in the center, and the Chaste Heart of St. Joseph is on the right. It says the necklace has flames on all three hearts, with a different flame pattern on each; that the bottom point of the center heart sits lower than the other two; a sword hilt on the Mary heart with a twisted grip, a straight crossbar guard, and a knob-shaped pommel, which do not touch the heart and stand atop the sword shaft, which is visible above the heart, and four roses with leaves; interlacing thorny vines with 11 thorns on the Jesus heart; a lily with five petals and a closed bud on the Joseph heart; and chain attachment loops mounted on small posts and turned perpendicular to the wearer so the open loop faces up. It says House of Joppa sold fewer than 50 units before removing the necklace from the market.

The complaint says that, for centuries, the Hearts of the Holy Family have been depicted with the Sacred Heart of Jesus with thorns, the Immaculate Heart of Mary with a sword and roses, and the Chaste Heart of St. Joseph with lilies, each topped with flames. It says a three-dimensional arrangement of those hearts in a row on jewelry has been in the public domain for over a century, and it points to a medallion of the Archconfraternity of the Holy Family, which it says was founded in 1844, with the three hearts in a horizontal row, left to right Mary, Jesus, and Joseph. It says the demand letter dated on or about October 26, 2026, acknowledged that the individual Sacred Hearts "have been depicted for centuries in traditional two-dimensional Catholic artwork."

The complaint says that on or about October 26, 2026, the defendants sent House of Joppa a letter regarding an immediate cease and desist for design patent and copyright infringement. It says the letter accused the necklace of infringing the patents and the copyright registrations, alleged that the infringement was willful, demanded $75,000, and directed House of Joppa to stop manufacturing or selling the necklace or face an infringement action. It says the letter used subheadings for design patent infringement, copyright infringement, and willful and intentional infringement, and stated that "House of Joppa has appropriated TLC's specific patented designs, and its unauthorized manufacture, marketing, distribution, and sale of Infringing Jewelry constitute design patent infringement." It says the letter made generalized conclusory statements, did not identify the elements of either patent claim or of the copyrighted works on which the accusations rested, and did not support the $75,000 demand. It says that on November 5, 2026, House of Joppa's counsel contacted the defendants' counsel and the matter was not resolved.

The complaint alleges, on information and belief, that The Little Catholic, LLC has a history of pursuing litigation and making unreasonable demands, including statutory damages under the Copyright Act in connection with registrations VA0002209979 and VAu001510355. It points to No. 24-01239 (C.D. Cal.). It says that in that case The Little Catholic, LLC sought $150,000 in statutory damages for willful copyright infringement after an entry of default, and that an August 9, 2024 order found evidence of only one sale for $25, held that the demand was "vastly disproportionate to the documented harm suffered," held that "an award of $150,000 in damages here is unreasonable," and awarded $2,000.

What the design patents cover

U.S. Design Patent D1,012,750, titled Jewelry Article, issued on January 30, 2024, from Application No. 29/788,404, filed May 17, 2021. It names Priscilla Huerta, of Laguna Hills, California, as inventor, and The Little Catholic, LLC as applicant and assignee. The single claim covers the ornamental design for a jewelry article, as shown and described. The patent states that it has one claim and six drawing sheets. FIG. 1 is a front perspective view of three heart forms side by side, with roses on the left heart and a hilt above it, thorny branches across the center heart and a cross above it, and a flowering stem on the right heart. The description says FIG. 8 is another front perspective view in a state of use, and that the broken lines in FIG. 8 represent environmental subject matter only and form no part of the claimed design.

U.S. Design Patent D1,043,407, also titled Jewelry Article, issued on September 24, 2024, from Application No. 29/876,587, filed May 24, 2023. The patent states that it is a division of Application No. 29/788,404, filed May 17, 2021, now Design Patent D1,012,750. It names the same inventor, applicant, and assignee. Its single claim covers the ornamental design for a jewelry article, as shown and described. The patent states that it has one claim and five drawing sheets. FIG. 1 and FIG. 2 show two heart forms, with roses on the left heart and a hilt above it, and thorny branches across the right heart and a cross above it. FIG. 8 is a front perspective view in a position of use as a pendant. The description says the broken lines depict environmental structure and form no part of the claimed design.

The complaint alleges, on information and belief, that Priscilla Huerta is the named inventor and that The Little Catholic, LLC is the applicant and owner of both patents. It says The Little Catholic, LLC claims to be the owner and assignee of all rights, title and interest in each patent. It says the '750 patent places the Heart of Mary on the left, the Heart of Jesus in the center, and the Heart of Joseph on the right, with flames only on the Joseph heart and nine separate flame peaks, hearts whose top lobes and bottom points are level, a sword with five horizontal non-twisting grooves, a curved guard, and no pommel, eleven rose blooms without leaves on the Mary heart, fifteen thorns on the Jesus heart, a rose stem with a blooming rose, two rosebuds, and six leaves on the Joseph heart, and chain loops merged with the outer hearts and oriented parallel to the wearer. It says the necklace differs from that design: flames on all three hearts, a lower center heart, a twisted grip and a pommel that stand off the Mary heart, four roses with leaves, 11 thorns, a lily on the Joseph heart, and loops turned perpendicular to the wearer. It says that, while the '750 patent was being obtained, a defendant requested an amendment to expand the design, the examiner rejected the amendment for lack of support, and the examiner stated that "there is no basis in the original disclosure for the following matter." It says a defendant failed to disclose examples of the Hearts of the Holy Family iconography, including the Archconfraternity medal, as material prior art. It says the '407 patent discloses two hearts, the necklace has three, and the necklace is not substantially the same as that design.

Copyright registrations and a trade dress application

The complaint says that on June 2, 2020, Priscilla Huerta filed a copyright application, and that the Copyright Office issued registration VA0002209979 for a work entitled Holy Family Hearts. It says that on November 3, 2023, Priscilla Huerta filed an application for a work entitled Holy Family Hearts: Jesus, Joseph, Mary and 3 other Unpublished Works, and that the Office issued registration VAu001510355 for Holy Family Hearts: Jesus, Joseph, Mary and 3 Other Unpublished Works. It alleges, on information and belief, that Priscilla Huerta is the author and copyright claimant for both. It says the work in the '979 registration is substantially similar to what is depicted in the '750 patent claim. It says the '355 registration claims permutations of the hearts arranged as Jesus, Joseph, Mary; Jesus, Mary, Joseph; Joseph, Mary, Jesus; and Mary, Joseph, Jesus, and that those works put the Heart of Joseph or the Heart of Mary in the center rather than the Heart of Jesus. It says the necklace has the Heart of Jesus in the center, does not copy either work, and is not substantially similar to either. It says the traditional iconography, including hearts arranged in a row on jewelry, flames, swords, roses, lilies, and thorns, is centuries old and in the public domain, and that, excluding those elements, the necklace is not substantially similar to protectable expression in either registration.

The complaint says that on or about April 30, 2024, The Little Catholic, LLC filed an application to register a Hearts of the Holy Family necklace design as trade dress, U.S. Serial No. 98/526200. It says the examiner refused registration because the applied-for mark "consists of a nondistinctive product design or nondistinctive features of a product design that is not registerable on the Principal Register without sufficient proof of distinctiveness," and that the applicant did not respond and the application was marked abandoned. The USPTO status record for serial number 98526200 lists a filing date of April 30, 2024, for jewelry in class 014. Its status is abandoned because the applicant failed to respond or filed a late response, with a date abandoned of May 22, 2025, and a status date of July 1, 2025.

The counts

Count I, brought by House of Joppa against the defendants, seeks a declaration that House of Joppa has not infringed and is not infringing U.S. Design Patent D1,012,750, directly or indirectly, literally or under the doctrine of equivalents, and has not willfully infringed it, by marketing, using, selling, offering to sell, or importing the necklace. Count II seeks the same declaration for U.S. Design Patent D1,043,407. The complaint says the defendants have accused House of Joppa of infringing each patent.

Count III seeks a declaration that the claim of the '750 patent is invalid because it fails to satisfy one or more conditions for patentability in Title 35, including 35 U.S.C. 101, 102, 103, 112, and/or 171, and 37 C.F.R. 1.56. It says the claimed design is anticipated or rendered obvious by prior art, including the Archconfraternity medal described above. Count IV seeks the same declaration for the claim of the '407 patent, on the same statutory grounds and the same prior art. The complaint says The Little Catholic, LLC contends that each patent is valid.

Count V seeks a declaration that House of Joppa has not infringed and is not infringing, directly or indirectly, and has not willfully infringed, any copyright identified in registration VA0002209979. Count VI seeks the same declaration for registration VAu001510355.

Count VII is a claim by House of Joppa against the defendants for commercial disparagement and false advertising under 15 U.S.C. 1125(a)(1)(B). The complaint alleges that the defendants made false or misleading statements of fact in commercial advertising or promotion about the nature, characteristics, and qualities of House of Joppa's goods and commercial activities. It alleges, on information and belief, that the day after the demand letter the defendants began a public campaign of online statements about House of Joppa and the necklace, and that they own or control the content posted on three Instagram accounts. It alleges, on information and belief, that posts on those accounts accused House of Joppa of taking the design and criticized the quality of the necklace, that one such statement drew hundreds of likes and many comments and reposts and remained published when the complaint was filed, and that a defendant solicited further reports about House of Joppa. It alleges, on information and belief, that users responded publicly by saying they had stopped following House of Joppa or were glad they had not bought from it. The complaint alleges that the statements were made in bad faith, that they deceived or had a tendency to deceive a substantial segment of the audience into believing House of Joppa engages in intellectual property theft and sells unauthorized, low-quality counterfeit goods, that they were material, that publishing them on the internet and social media caused them to enter interstate commerce, and that House of Joppa has suffered lost sales, loss of audience, and damage to reputation and goodwill. It states that the campaign had an immediate, negative impact on House of Joppa's business and reputation.

Count VIII is a claim by House of Joppa against the defendants under the Michigan Consumer Protection Act. The complaint says the defendants are engaged in trade or commerce under MCL 445.902(1)(g), that the jewelry is goods advertised, offered, and sold primarily for personal, family, or household purposes, and that the defendants violated MCL 445.903(1), and specifically MCL 445.903(1)(f), by disparaging House of Joppa's goods, services, business, or reputation by false or misleading representations of fact. It says the defendants' online statements about House of Joppa, their descriptions of the necklace, and their solicitation of reports about House of Joppa's business practices were calculated to unfairly damage its business and reputation. It says that, to the extent the statements referred to patent or copyright rights, the public misrepresentations were objectively baseless, made in subjective bad faith, and were affirmative false statements of theft directed to consumers rather than a good-faith notice of intellectual property rights. It says House of Joppa seeks declaratory and injunctive relief, actual damages, and reasonable attorneys' fees under MCL 445.911.

Relief sought

The prayer asks for a declaratory judgment under 28 U.S.C. 2201 that House of Joppa has not infringed and does not infringe any valid and enforceable claim of U.S. Design Patent D1,012,750 or U.S. Design Patent D1,043,407; a declaratory judgment that each claim of both patents is invalid; and a declaratory judgment that House of Joppa has not infringed and does not infringe copyright registration VA0002209979 or copyright registration VAu001510355. It asks for an injunction barring the defendants and persons in active concert with them from asserting the patents or copyrights against House of Joppa, its customers, distributors, or suppliers; from publishing or disseminating false or misleading statements about the quality or authenticity of House of Joppa's products, including statements that House of Joppa stole the jewelry designs, sells infringing products, or engages in intellectual property theft; from filing further intellectual property takedown notices, strikes, or complaints with third-party platforms about the necklace while the litigation is pending; and from contacting House of Joppa's manufacturers, suppliers, distributors, or customers about alleged infringement of the necklace. It asks for an order, under 15 U.S.C. 1116, requiring the defendants to remove the social-media posts about House of Joppa that the complaint calls false and disparaging and to publish corrective notices and retractions on their social-media platforms and to any third-party businesses they contacted, and an order requiring them to preserve digital evidence, including public and hidden social-media comments, direct messages, and archived stories relating to House of Joppa, the necklace, or the statements. It asks for the defendants' profits, House of Joppa's actual damages, treble damages, costs, and reasonable attorneys' fees under 15 U.S.C. 1117(a); actual damages or statutory damages of $250, whichever is greater, plus injunctive relief and reasonable attorneys' fees under MCL 445.911; restitution, including disgorgement of wrongfully obtained profits, and any other appropriate equitable relief; a declaration that the case is exceptional under 35 U.S.C. 285 and 15 U.S.C. 1117(a), and fees and costs under 35 U.S.C. 285, 17 U.S.C. 505, and 15 U.S.C. 1117(a); an order that the defendants, jointly and severally, pay the costs of the action; and such other relief as the court deems just and proper.

What to watch next

Watch for an answer or a Rule 12 motion, and for a scheduling order. The case can end at any time, including by settlement or voluntary dismissal.