The lawsuit
On November 17, 2026, Judge Manish S. Shah signed a 15-page memorandum opinion and order in Hangzhou Jingyao Technology Co., Ltd. v. Luster Leaf Products, Inc., No. 1:26-cv-04926, in the Eastern Division of the Northern District of Illinois. The order is ECF No. 36. The docket lists the complaint as filed on April 29, 2026. The order states that Luster Leaf holds a patent on an electronic meter that measures the pH and moisture of soil, that Jingyao sold an electronic soil meter of its own on Amazon, and that Jingyao sued for a declaration that its meter does not infringe and that the patent is invalid.
The order states that Jingyao moved for a temporary restraining order and a preliminary injunction that would order Luster Leaf to withdraw its complaint to Amazon and bar it from filing another while the case is pending, citing docket entries 11 and 13. It states that Luster Leaf answered with a counterclaim for patent infringement and that Jingyao moved to dismiss the counterclaim. The docket lists entry 11 on May 21, 2026, the counterclaim as entry 16 on May 27, 2026, and a motion to dismiss for failure to state a claim as entry 18 on June 17, 2026. The November 17 order denies the preliminary injunction motion at entry 11 and the motion to dismiss at entry 18.
The '361 patent
The order states that Luster Leaf owns U.S. Patent No. 8,938,361, which the Patent Office issued to it in January 2015. The patent is titled "Electronic gardening tool and method of configuring the same" and was issued on January 20, 2015. Claim 1 is an apparatus for measuring a soil characteristic. It comprises a sensor circuit adapted to output an analog signal reflecting a measure of the soil characteristic, an analog-to-digital converter adapted to convert the analog signal to a digital value, a microcontroller receiving and processing the digital value, and a display panel for displaying the measure of the soil characteristic. The microcontroller is configured to "obtain a plurality of initial readings from the sensor circuit when the apparatus is powered on; obtain a nominal value by averaging the initial analog readings; and assign a zero reference associated with a neutral value of the soil characteristic to the nominal value derived by averaging the initial readings."
Claim 16 is an apparatus for measuring a soil characteristic. It comprises a sensor circuit adapted to output an analog signal reflecting a measure of the soil characteristic, a microcontroller coupled with the sensor circuit, wherein the microcontroller includes an analog-to-digital converter adapted to convert the analog signal to a digital value, a display panel for displaying the measure of the soil characteristic, and "a calibration circuit adapted to set a zero reference associated with a neutral value of the soil characteristic to a fixed reference voltage from the sensor circuit by averaging initial analog readings to obtain the neutral value." Claim 17 depends on claim 16 and adds that "the calibration circuit includes a variable resistor, and the calibration circuit is connected between the sensor circuit and the microcontroller."
The order states that in March 2014 the examiner rejected Luster Leaf's claims as anticipated by an earlier soil-tester patent the parties call Bjornsson. It states that Luster Leaf responded by amending the claims, adding the phrase "by averaging initial analog readings to obtain the neutral value" to claim 16 and the step "obtain a nominal value by averaging the initial analog readings" to claim 1, and by telling the examiner that Bjornsson did not disclose averaging. The order states that the claims were then allowed.
Jingyao's account of its meter
The order states that Jingyao sold a meter on Amazon that measures soil pH, moisture, temperature, and light. According to Jingyao, as the order recounts the complaint, the meter is calibrated once, at the factory. A technician uses a screwdriver to adjust four small variable resistors on the circuit board, one of them "until pH reads 7.0," and the resistors then stay where they were set. The order states that Jingyao says it has calibrated its meters that way since 2006. It states that when the meter is switched on, its firmware does not take a set of initial readings and average them. For each measurement during ordinary use, the firmware takes three readings and uses the middle one, the median.
The order states that Luster Leaf submitted a complaint to Amazon asserting that Jingyao's meter infringed the '361 patent, that Amazon removed the listing that day, and that Amazon warned Jingyao that its seller account could be suspended if the violation was not resolved. It states that Jingyao appealed through Amazon's internal process without success, that Amazon told Jingyao a court order or a retraction submitted by Luster Leaf was needed to reinstate the listing, that Jingyao emailed Luster Leaf demanding that it withdraw the complaint within 48 hours, and that Luster Leaf did not respond. The order states that the listing remains down and that 1,956 of Jingyao's meters sit unsold in Amazon's warehouses.
The preliminary injunction
The order states that Jingyao seeks declarations that its meter does not infringe the '361 patent and that the patent's independent claims are invalid as obvious and, for claim 16, for lack of an adequate written description. On the injunction, the order states that when a preliminary injunction prevents a patentee from communicating its patent rights, a court applies "federal patent law and precedent relating to the giving of notice of patent rights," citing Myco Indus., Inc. v. BlephEx, LLC, 955 F.3d 1, 10 (Fed. Cir. 2020). It states that "federal law requires a showing of bad faith in order to bar such communications," and that "a bad faith standard cannot be satisfied in the absence of a showing that the claims asserted were objectively baseless," quoting GP Indus., Inc. v. Eran Indus., Inc., 500 F.3d 1369, 1373-74 (Fed. Cir. 2007). It quotes the preliminary-injunction standard as a showing "that it is likely to succeed on the merits, that it is likely to suffer irreparable harm in the absence of preliminary relief, that the balance of equities tips in its favor, and that an injunction is in the public interest," citing Socket Sols., LLC v. Imp. Glob., LLC, 185 F.4th 1150, 1154 (Fed. Cir. 2026) (quoting Luminara Worldwide, LLC v. Liown Elecs. Co., 814 F.3d 1343, 1352 (Fed. Cir. 2016)); see also Winter v. Nat. Res. Def. Council, Inc., 555 U.S. 7, 20 (2008). It states that an infringement assertion is objectively baseless only if "no reasonable litigant could realistically expect success on the merits," quoting GP Indus., 500 F.3d at 1374 (quoting Pro. Real Est. Invs., Inc. v. Columbia Pictures Indus., Inc., 508 U.S. 49, 60 (1993)).
The order holds: "At a minimum, Luster Leaf's position on Claim 17 is not objectively baseless." It states that claim 16 calls for a calibration circuit adapted to set a zero reference associated with a neutral value of the soil characteristic to a fixed reference voltage from the sensor circuit, and that claim 17 specifies that the circuit "includes a variable resistor" and "is connected between the sensor circuit and the microcontroller." It states that Jingyao's own account is that variable resistors on the circuit board are adjusted at the factory until the meter reads a pH of 7.0 and are then left alone, and that the sensor's signal "is biased and conditioned by the passive potentiometer network before reaching the microcontroller's ADC input." The order states: "On its face, Claim 17 covers a zero-reference preset in that way."
The order states: "The crux of the parties' dispute lies in the patent's use of the term 'averaging.'" Claim 16 requires "averaging initial analog readings," and claim 17 carries that requirement. The order states that, for each measurement, Jingyao's firmware takes three readings and uses the middle one, that Luster Leaf contends that practice "is the same as averaging," and that to Jingyao "averaging" means "computing the arithmetic mean of a set of values," with a median a different operation. The order states that a mean and a median are both ways of reducing a set of readings to one representative value, and that the claims say "averaging," not "calculating the mean." It states that which sense a person skilled in the art would give the term is a question for claim construction, and that "[a] reasonable litigant could expect to prevail on the reading that includes taking a median as averaging."
The order states that Jingyao's invalidity theories do not make Luster Leaf's infringement assertion baseless either. It states that a patent is "presumed valid," 35 U.S.C. 282(a), and that an invalidity defense must be proven by clear and convincing evidence, citing Microsoft Corp. v. i4i Ltd. P'ship, 564 U.S. 91, 95 (2011). It states that Jingyao's obviousness argument relies on a reference published in July 2010, which counts as prior art only if Luster Leaf's December 2009 provisional application fails to support the averaging limitation. The order states that the provisional says that when the meter is switched on it "does a very fast series of reads to set the neutral value," and that readings are "averaged with the previous display value" to steady the display. It states that whether a person skilled in the art would understand those passages to disclose averaging the initial reads is a question of fact that the present record does not answer. Having decided that claim 16 suffices to establish a good faith basis, the order states, the court does not reach whether the assertion of claim 1 clears the bar. Jingyao seeks an injunction against asserting the '361 patent at all, and the order states that an assertion with a reasonable basis as to one claim is not made baseless by a weaker position on another.
The order states that Jingyao's remaining points go to Luster Leaf's state of mind: Luster Leaf did not have the firmware when it complained to Amazon, and it ignored Jingyao's demand letter. The order quotes the rule that "[s]ubjective considerations of bad faith are irrelevant if the assertions are not objectively baseless." It states that claim construction has not begun and that the infringement and validity questions both turn on it. The order then states: "Because Jingyao has not shown objective baselessness, I do not decide whether it is likely to succeed on its claims for declaratory relief, and I do not reach irreparable harm, the balance of equities, the public interest, or bond."
The counterclaim
The order states: "The counterclaim is thin, but it states a claim for infringement of the '361 patent." It describes the counterclaim as identifying the '361 patent and attaching a copy, reproducing claims 1 and 16, identifying the accused meter by its Amazon listing, and alleging that Jingyao makes, imports, and sells that meter and so infringes the patent "either literally and/or under the doctrine of equivalents." The order states that dismissal would accomplish nothing because the counterclaim is compulsory, quoting Polymer Indus. Prods. Co. v. Bridgestone/Firestone, Inc., 347 F.3d 935, 938 (Fed. Cir. 2003): "Rule 13(a) makes an infringement counterclaim to a declaratory judgment action for noninfringement compulsory." It states that N.D. Ill. Local Patent Rule 2.2(c) already requires "a chart identifying specifically where each element of each asserted claim is found within each Accused Instrumentality," and that Luster Leaf has served one.
The order states that Jingyao's remaining arguments aim at parts of the counterclaim: the assertion that Jingyao infringes "all claims" of the patent, the doctrine of equivalents, a prayer for an injunction against inducing and contributing to infringement, and an allegation of willfulness. It quotes BBL, Inc. v. City of Angola, 809 F.3d 317, 325 (7th Cir. 2015): "A motion to dismiss under Rule 12(b)(6) doesn't permit piecemeal dismissals of parts of claims." The order states: "Luster Leaf has one claim: that Jingyao infringes the '361 patent." It states that literal infringement and infringement by equivalents are two ways of proving it, and that willfulness is not a claim but the predicate for treble damages under 35 U.S.C. 284. Because the infringement claim survives, the order states, the court does not look further at this stage.
What the order requires next
The order concludes: "Jingyao's motion for a preliminary injunction, [11], and motion to dismiss Luster Leaf's counterclaim, [18], are denied. Jingyao shall answer the counterclaim by 12/8/26. The case schedule otherwise remains as set. The parties' next discovery progress report is due 12/9/26." The answer date in that paragraph is December 8, 2026, and the progress-report date is December 9, 2026. The order is signed by Manish S. Shah, United States District Judge, and dated November 17, 2026.
What to watch next
Watch for Jingyao's answer to the counterclaim, which the order sets for December 8, 2026. The case can end at any time, including by settlement or voluntary dismissal.