This page is the campaign hub for suits by Minotaur Systems LLC on U.S. Patent 9,652,023. From July 2023 through October 2026, Minotaur filed the nine suits listed here, eight in the Eastern District of Texas, Marshall Division, and one in the Northern District of Texas, Fort Worth Division. Its 2023 complaint describes Minotaur as a Texas limited liability company with its principal place of business in Marshall, Texas; its 2026 complaints describe it as a corporation organized under the laws of Delaware with its principal place of business in New York, New York.

The patent

U.S. Patent 9,652,023, titled Power Management System, issued May 16, 2017, from Application No. 12/508,789, filed July 24, 2009, and claims the benefit of a provisional application filed July 24, 2008. The USPTO copy lists Otman A. Basir, William Ben Miners, and Vladimir Filippov as inventors and shows 24 claims.

Claim 1 recites a vehicle communication system with a mobile communication device and a control unit in a vehicle that has an OFF state, an ON state, and a LOW POWER state. The control unit includes a wireless communication module that communicates wirelessly with the mobile communication device, and a power management module that commands the control unit to enter the ON state in response to each of a vehicle ignition event, a vehicle running condition, an incoming wireless command signal, and environmental stimuli.

The 2023 AT&T suit

Minotaur Systems LLC v. AT&T Inc., No. 2:23-cv-00344 (E.D. Tex.), filed July 24, 2023, against AT&T Inc., AT&T Mobility LLC, and AT&T Services Inc., pleads three counts: infringement of U.S. Patent 7,386,376, titled Vehicle Visual and Non-Visual Data Recording System; U.S. Patent 9,237,242, titled Roadside and Emergency Assistance System; and the '023 patent. It alleges that AT&T infringes by making, using, and selling fleet-management and monitoring solutions. Count III alleges direct infringement of at least claim 1 of the '023 patent by vehicle communication products such as the AT&T In-Car Wi-Fi, including by using and testing them, and induced infringement by AT&T customers and end users. The prayer asks for a permanent injunction under 35 U.S.C. 283, damages of no less than a reasonable royalty, and attorneys' fees under 35 U.S.C. 285. These are Minotaur's allegations.

The 2025 and 2026 suits

Minotaur's later complaints, against Stellantis in 2025 and against Avis Budget Group, Inc., CarMax, Inc., Enterprise Holdings, Inc., AutoNation, Inc., Hertz Car Sales LLC, Sixt SE, and DriveTime Automotive Group Inc. in 2026, are 5-page complaints that each plead the same single count on the '023 patent. Each alleges direct infringement, literally or under the doctrine of equivalents, by the products identified in claim charts attached as Exhibit 2, including through internal testing and use by the defendant's employees, and alleges, on information and belief, that numerous other infringing devices have been made, used, sold, imported, and offered for sale by the defendant and/or its customers. Each says that service of the complaint and charts gives the defendant actual knowledge of infringement and alleges induced infringement at least since service.

Each of these complaints except the Sixt complaint pleads venue under 28 U.S.C. 1400(b) on the ground that the defendant has an established place of business in the district; the Sixt complaint pleads venue under 28 U.S.C. 1391(c) on the ground that Sixt SE is a foreign corporation. Each asks for a judgment of infringement, damages under 35 U.S.C. 284, an accounting, and, if necessary to adequately compensate Minotaur, an exceptional-case finding and attorneys' fees under 35 U.S.C. 285. The Stellantis complaint describes Stellantis as a corporation organized under the laws of the Netherlands, and the Sixt complaint describes Sixt SE as a corporation organized under the laws of Germany. These are Minotaur's allegations.

The proceedings

The table lists each suit on this page in order of filing, with the status each docket shows through November 13, 2026. Patents appear by their last three digits; the full numbers are above.

No.CourtFiledDefendantsPatentsStatus on the docket
2:23-cv-00344E.D. Tex.July 24, 2023AT&T Inc., AT&T Mobility LLC, and AT&T Services Inc.'376, '242, '023Joint motion to stay all deadlines and notice of resolution filed November 3, 2023; Minotaur's notice of voluntary dismissal filed December 1; order dismissing all claims with prejudice, ECF No. 15, signed December 4 and entered December 5, 2023.
2:25-cv-00640E.D. Tex.June 16, 2025Stellantis'023Notice of voluntary dismissal filed June 1, 2026; order dismissing the case, ECF No. 7, entered June 3, 2026.
2:26-cv-00478E.D. Tex.June 17, 2026Avis Budget Group, Inc.'023Answer and counterclaim filed July 7, 2026; stipulation of dismissal filed July 10; order dismissing the case, ECF No. 11, entered July 14, 2026.
2:26-cv-00479E.D. Tex.June 17, 2026CarMax, Inc.'023Order dismissing the case, ECF No. 12, entered October 15, 2026.
2:26-cv-00480E.D. Tex.June 17, 2026Enterprise Holdings, Inc.'023Notices of voluntary dismissal filed August 28 and October 13, 2026; order dismissing the case, ECF No. 18, entered October 15, 2026.
2:26-cv-00908E.D. Tex.October 6, 2026AutoNation, Inc.'023Complaint, with the patent and claim charts as exhibits, filed October 6, 2026.
2:26-cv-00909E.D. Tex.October 6, 2026Hertz Car Sales LLC'023Complaint filed October 6, 2026.
2:26-cv-00944E.D. Tex.October 20, 2026Sixt SE'023Complaint filed October 20, 2026.
4:26-cv-01344N.D. Tex.October 20, 2026DriveTime Automotive Group Inc.'023Complaint filed October 20, 2026.

What to watch next

Watch for answers or other responses from AutoNation, Inc. in No. 2:26-cv-00908, Hertz Car Sales LLC in No. 2:26-cv-00909, Sixt SE in No. 2:26-cv-00944, and DriveTime Automotive Group Inc. in No. 4:26-cv-01344. Any of these cases can end at any time, including by settlement or voluntary dismissal.