Open Text Inc. v. Intellectual Ventures I LLC, No. 1:26-cv-01465 (D. Del.), is a complaint for declaratory judgment of non-infringement filed November 13, 2026. The plaintiffs are Open Text Inc., a Delaware corporation, and Open Text US LLC, a Delaware limited liability company, both with their principal place of business in the United States in Provo, Utah. The complaint alleges, on information and belief, that Intellectual Ventures I LLC, Intellectual Ventures II LLC, Invention Investment Fund I, LP, and Invention Investment Fund II, LLC are Delaware entities based in Bellevue, Washington, and that OL Security Limited Liability Company (Dover, Delaware), Xenogenic Development LLC, and S. Aqua Semiconductor, LLC (both Wilmington, Delaware) are Delaware limited liability companies. It also alleges, on information and belief, that Intellectual Ventures I LLC is a wholly owned subsidiary of Invention Investment Fund I, LP and that Intellectual Ventures II LLC is a wholly owned subsidiary of Invention Investment Fund II, LLC. The complaint refers to the seven defendants together as IV. Jurisdiction is pleaded under 28 U.S.C. §§ 1331, 1338(a), 2201, and 2202, and venue under 28 U.S.C. § 1391(b)(1) and (c)(2). OpenText demands a jury trial.
The September 28 letter
According to the complaint, on September 28, 2026, IV, acting through a licensing agent, sent OpenText a letter that identified each patent, an "Example Claim" for each, and an "Example Product/Feature" that OpenText allegedly "makes, uses, sells, offers for sale, imports, and/or encourages its customers and partners to make, use, sell, offer to sell and/or import." The complaint says the letter stated that OpenText and its customers and partners lacked authorization to practice the patents without a license, that IV's "investigation of OpenText products and services is ongoing," and that IV offered to provide more detail under a nondisclosure agreement.
The complaint lists the pairings it says the letter made: claim 4 of the '562 patent against the use of Okta Single Sign-On software in OpenText MyPortal; claim 1 of the '081 patent against Apache Spark; claim 1 of the '367 patent against OpenText Functional Testing; claim 1 of the '948 patent against OpenText Core DNS Protection; claim 7 of the '844 patent against Docker; claim 1 of the '584 patent against Kubernetes; and claim 15 of the RE'894 patent against Apache Kafka. For the four open-source tools, the complaint quotes the letter as accusing "OpenText's privately managed implementations of [Apache] Spark, Docker, Kubernetes, and [Apache] Kafka, as well as non-licensed public cloud-based implementations of those technologies that OpenText uses to support its systems and services."
What the patents cover
U.S. Patent 7,596,562, titled System and Method for Managing Access Control List of Computer Systems, issued September 29, 2009. The complaint identifies Xenogenic Development LLC as its owner of record. Claim 4 covers a method in which a user account login request for an application system is received and validated, the user's access list is obtained from a database server and loaded temporarily in a management server, a user identification is created to show whether the user is online, access rights to the application system are granted according to the list, and access to another application system is granted if the list carries access rights to it.
U.S. Patent 7,669,081, titled Systems and Methods for Scheduling, Processing, and Monitoring Tasks, issued February 23, 2010. The complaint identifies OL Security Limited Liability Company as its owner of record. Claim 1 covers a computer-implemented method of performing a process made up of tasks and a scheduler rule, in which checkpoints are received that each carry checkpoint state data about the process and a checkpoint rule defining which tasks run and how they run, a first task is scheduled into a priority queue and a first checkpoint is chosen for it under the scheduler rule, and checkpoint state data for that checkpoint is created and saved.
U.S. Patent 8,127,367, titled Refreshing Software Licenses, issued February 28, 2012. The complaint identifies S. Aqua Semiconductor, LLC as its owner of record. Claim 1 covers a system with a license access agent on a client computer whose license manager receives a software license in response to a request to authorize use of a protected software product, and disables the product when the license expires unless it obtains a refreshed license.
U.S. Patent 8,290,948, titled Method and Apparatus for Content Filtering, issued October 16, 2012. The complaint identifies Intellectual Ventures I LLC as its owner of record. Claim 1 covers a content filtering method that routes requests for review of content items to reviewing resources, each with a network-connected terminal that presents content to a human reviewer, associates each item with a classification after human review, and provides the classifications to local filtering agents to allow a determination of whether items are presented to end users who each have an associated access level.
U.S. Patent 8,332,844, titled Root Image Caching and Indexing for Block-Level Distributed Application Management, issued December 11, 2012. The complaint identifies Intellectual Ventures II LLC as its owner of record. Claim 7 covers a method of providing data to compute nodes by storing blocks of a root image on a first storage unit, storing for each node a leaf image that holds only new data blocks and that node's changes to root image blocks, without the unchanged root image blocks, and caching root image blocks that a node has accessed.
U.S. Patent 8,352,584, titled System for Hosting Customized Computing Clusters, issued January 8, 2013. The complaint identifies Intellectual Ventures II LLC as its owner of record. Claim 1 covers a computer system with a private network linked to a public network, two high performance clusters in differing configurations that provide environments for different client tasks, each linked to the private network through its own gateway, isolated communications between the two clusters, and a monitoring system that watches both clusters for communications problems.
U.S. Patent RE48,894, titled Disaggregated Resources and Access Methods, reissued January 11, 2022. The complaint says it is a reissue of U.S. Patent 8,819,092 and identifies Intellectual Ventures I LLC as its owner of record. Claim 15 depends from claim 8, which covers a method in which a resource consumer device receives node names for resource nodes, determines from those names whether the nodes have a parallel or a serial organizational structure for access to a data set, generates a resource map based on that structure, and messages resource nodes about the data set based on the map. Claim 15 adds that the node names indicate a group type for the resource nodes.
The claims for relief
The complaint pleads seven claims for relief, each a declaratory judgment that OpenText does not infringe one patent: the '562, '081, '367, '948, '844, '584, and RE'894 patents, in that order. For each, OpenText says it does not perform or encourage performance of the identified claim and gives a non-limiting example. It says OpenText MyPortal does not grant access to another application system on the access-list condition of claim 4 of the '562 patent; that OpenText does not provide a checkpoint as claim 1 of the '081 patent requires; that OpenText Functional Testing has no license manager configured to disable the product unless it obtains a refreshed license; that OpenText Core DNS Protection does not associate content items with classifications provided after review by a human reviewer; that use of Docker does not include leaf images holding only new data blocks and changes to root image blocks; that use of Kubernetes does not include the first and second gateways of claim 1 of the '584 patent; and that use of Apache Kafka does not include determining an organizational structure of resource nodes based on received node names.
The prayer asks for a declaration that OpenText has not infringed and does not infringe, directly or indirectly, literally or under the doctrine of equivalents, any claim of each of the seven patents; an order enjoining the defendants and their respective officers, agents, servants, employees, attorneys, and persons acting on their behalf or in active concert with them from charging or threatening infringement of the patents against OpenText under any subsection of 35 U.S.C. § 271; a finding that the case is exceptional under 35 U.S.C. § 285; reasonable attorneys' fees, expenses, and costs; and other relief the court deems just and proper.
Other suits on these patents
The complaint says IV has asserted the '844 and/or '584 patents in at least 12 other complaints for patent infringement, based on those defendants' alleged use of Docker and/or Kubernetes, and lists them, including No. 1:26-cv-01421 (D. Del.), filed November 4, 2026. It also says at least ten declaratory judgment complaints involving one or more of the same patents have been filed based on IV's allegations, in pre-suit letters, of infringing use of Apache Spark, Apache Kafka, Docker, or Kubernetes, and it lists ten, eight of them in the District of Delaware, and says IV asserted infringement counterclaims in response to each of them. It cites counterclaims filed July 28, 2026 in Nos. 1:26-cv-00466 and 1:26-cv-00461 (D. Del.) and June 26, 2026 in No. 1:26-cv-11633 (D. Mass.).
What to watch
Watch for the defendants' answers or any Rule 12 motion, and for any infringement counterclaims like those the complaint describes in the earlier declaratory judgment actions. The case can end at any time, including by settlement or voluntary dismissal.