Oterra A/S and Oterra, LLC v. Wild Flavors, Inc. and Archer-Daniels-Midland Co., No. 1:23-cv-01376 (D. Del.), is a declaratory-judgment action over U.S. Patent RE46,695. On November 12, 2026, Judge Joel H. Slomsky approved and adopted a special master's report and recommendation (Doc. No. 336) and overruled all seven of Oterra's objections. The order, filed November 13, 2026, denies Oterra's motion for summary judgment (Doc. No. 229), grants the defendants' motion for summary judgment of infringement of the patent (Doc. No. 233), and grants the defendants' conditional motion to shift the burden of proof under 35 U.S.C. § 295 (Doc. No. 305).

The complaint and the patent

Oterra A/S and Oterra, LLC filed the complaint on December 4, 2023. It seeks a declaratory judgment of non-infringement and invalidity of claims 45 to 62. The complaint says Oterra A/S is a private company organized under the laws of Denmark, with its principal place of business in Hoersholm, Denmark, and that Oterra, LLC is a private company organized under the laws of Wisconsin, with its principal place of business in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. It alleges, on information and belief, that Wild Flavors, Inc. is a Delaware corporation with a principal place of business in Erlanger, Kentucky, that Archer-Daniels-Midland Co. is a Delaware company with a principal place of business in Chicago, Illinois, and that Wild Flavors, Inc. is a wholly owned subsidiary of Archer-Daniels-Midland Co. It alleges, on information and belief, that RE46,695 is currently assigned to Wild Flavors, Inc.

The November 12 order states that the patent provides a method for preparing blue dye. The patent is titled Stable Natural Color Process, Products and Use Thereof. It is a reissue patent dated February 6, 2018, on application No. 14/881,790, filed October 13, 2015. It is a reissue of U.S. Patent 8,557,319, issued October 15, 2013, from application No. 12/399,223, filed March 6, 2009. It identifies provisional application No. 61/040,208, filed March 28, 2008. The complaint says the original patent issued with 21 claims, of which only claim 1 was independent, that claims 1 to 4 of that patent were amended in the reissue proceeding, that claims 22 to 64 were newly added, and that RE46,695 issued with three independent claims, claims 1, 22, and 45.

Claim 45 recites a method of preparing stable, natural colors that results in a color having an increased -b value on the CIE LAB scale when the mixture in step (a) is compared with the processed mixture in step (c). The method includes forming a mixture of Genipa americana fruit juice and other juice or material from a suitable food-grade source that contains at least one component capable of providing the desired color when combined with that juice, and the food-grade source comprises an amino acid. The mixture is then processed, stabilized by a heat treatment, and dried. Claim 52 is the method of claim 45 wherein the color is blue. Claims 46 to 62 refer back to claim 45, directly or through an intermediate claim. Claim 53 is a stable natural juice-based colorant made according to the method of claim 45.

The complaint describes a Colombian company as a partner that produces a blue colorant from juice of Genipa americana fruit, also called jagua fruit, made in Colombia. It says that company submitted a petition to the Food and Drug Administration on July 31, 2020, Docket No. FDA-2020-C-2131, proposing that the color additive regulations be amended to provide for the safe use of jagua (genipin-glycine) blue. It says the agency published a notice at 88 Fed. Reg. 75,490 (Nov. 3, 2023) that the regulations are being amended to permit that use, and that the rule would be effective December 4, 2023. It says Oterra was ready to import the Colombian company's jagua blue colorant, and to offer it for sale and sell it, once that rule went into effect.

The complaint describes two letters from Archer-Daniels-Midland Co. to Oterra A/S, then named Chr. Hansen Natural Colors A/S. A February 5, 2020 letter stated that the patents identified appear relevant to the Colombian company's natural color technology and that Wild Flavors desires to protect its patent rights. A December 3, 2020 letter, copying the Colombian company, stated that RE46,695 covers a process relevant to that company's FDA petition and that "we plan to vigorously pursue protection of our patent claims in the US." The complaint describes a February 2, 2021 response stating that the claims do not cover what the responding company would be doing with the Colombian company's huito technology, and a February 21, 2023 letter to the Colombian company stating that the sender represents Archer-Daniels-Midland Co. and its wholly owned subsidiary Wild Flavors, Inc., and asking for information on the process used to make the blue colorant. The complaint says those communications created a controversy of sufficient immediacy to warrant a declaratory judgment.

Count I seeks a declaration that Oterra's importation, offers for sale, or sales of the Colombian company's jagua blue colorant, or of any product containing it, do not infringe claims 45 to 62 under 35 U.S.C. § 271. The complaint says, as an example, that the Colombian company's process occurs outside the United States and does not practice the mixture step of claim 45 as the patentee defined that step during prosecution of the original patent, because the colorant uses pure glycine. Count II seeks a declaration that claims 45 to 62 are invalid under 35 U.S.C. §§ 101, 102, 103, and/or 112. The examples pleaded include invalidity if the claim language covers pure chemicals such as pure glycine, indefiniteness, lack of written description or enablement, and ineligibility on the ground that the claimed process encompasses production of natural colors that inherently occur in nature. The complaint demands a jury trial. The prayer asks for a declaration that Oterra has not infringed and will not infringe claims 45 to 62, directly or indirectly; a declaration that those claims are invalid; an injunction against assertion of the patent against Oterra or its customers or suppliers; and a declaration that the case is exceptional, with costs, expenses, and reasonable attorneys' fees under 35 U.S.C. § 285.

The counterclaim

A May 16, 2025 opinion by Judge Slomsky states that the defendants filed a counterclaim on April 26, 2024, alleging that Oterra is infringing RE46,695, and an amended counterclaim on September 3, 2024. The court's August 29, 2025 claim construction opinion, filed September 5, 2025, states that the September 3, 2024 answer and amended counterclaim is the operative responsive pleading and that the counterclaim alleges Oterra is infringing the patent. The May 16 opinion, describing the amended counterclaim, states that the amended counterclaim alleges Oterra partnered with the Colombian company to manufacture and sell a blue food colorant made from the same fruit, that the defendants argue the process used to manufacture the colorant infringes at least claim 45, and that they allege the colorant infringes at least claim 53. Citing the amended counterclaim, the claim construction opinion describes Wild Flavors as a wholly owned subsidiary of Archer-Daniels-Midland Co. and describes Wild Flavors' own blue colorant, which the opinion says Wild Flavors calls Huito blue, as covered by the patent. The opinion states that the Colombian company is not a party.

Claim construction

The August 29, 2025 opinion construed disputed terms in the patent. For claim 45, the court construed "other juice or material" and "a suitable food-grade source that contains at least one component capable of providing the desired color when combined with the Genipa americana fruit juice defined in (a)(i), wherein the food-grade source comprises an amino acid" to have their plain and ordinary meaning. The opinion states that the patentee did not clearly and unmistakably disclaim the use of pure chemicals, including isolated amino acids, in step (a)(ii), and that Oterra had not met the standard for prosecution disclaimer. The November 12 order states that this construction rejected Oterra's argument that "suitable food-grade source" excludes synthetic chemicals, including isolated amino acids. The order also states that the opinion quoted Oterra's expert for the point that food-grade is understood to mean non-toxic and safe for consumption.

The November 2, 2026 order

On November 2, 2026, Judge Slomsky approved and adopted a special master's report and recommendation dated October 19, 2026 (Doc. No. 308), to which no objections were filed. The order denies Oterra's motion for leave to supplement its final invalidity contentions (Doc. No. 227). It denies Oterra's summary judgment motion (Doc. No. 229) in part as to all invalidity theories that were not disclosed in Oterra's final invalidity contentions (Doc. No. 142). The theories it lists include recapture theories under 35 U.S.C. § 251 based on pH, indefiniteness theories under 35 U.S.C. § 112 based on the term "about," enablement challenges under § 112 based on pH, obviousness theories under 35 U.S.C. § 103 based on previously undisclosed prior art, and an "original patent" theory under § 251. It denies as moot the defendants' motion to strike those theories from the summary judgment motion (Doc. No. 250).

The November 12 order

The November 12 order was entered on the report issued November 4, 2026, Oterra's objections filed November 9, 2026 (Doc. No. 340), and the defendants' response filed November 10, 2026 (Doc. No. 342). The order states that objections to the special master's findings of fact and conclusions of law are reviewed de novo under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 53(f)(3) and (4). After that review, the court overruled all seven objections, approved and adopted the report, and entered the rulings below. In the order, "Oterra" means both plaintiffs, and "Wild Flavors" means both defendants.

Plaintiffs' motion for summary judgment (Doc. No. 229) is denied. On the objection that Oterra was entitled to summary judgment that claim 52 is not enabled, the court held that a genuine dispute of material fact remains and that whether claim 52 is enabled will proceed to trial. The order states that Oterra's expert opines that variables in claim 52, including heating times, temperatures, and co-processing materials, require undue experimentation before a person of ordinary skill can achieve the blue color the claim contemplates, and that Wild Flavors' expert provided opinions that claim 52 is enabled. The court agreed with the special master's application of the In re Wands factors, stating that the Federal Circuit has recognized that those factors still control enablement claims. On enablement of claim 45, the order states that Oterra is not entitled to summary judgment. The objection that the special master had improperly resolved enablement for the remaining claims was overruled.

The defendants' conditional motion to shift the burden of proof under 35 U.S.C. § 295 (Doc. No. 305) is granted. The order states that, pursuant to section 295, the accused products shall be presumed to have been made by the process claimed in claims 45 to 62 of the patent, and the plaintiffs shall bear the burden of establishing that the accused products were not made by that process. Section 295 provides that, in an action alleging infringement of a process patent based on the importation, sale, offer for sale, or use of a product made from a process patented in the United States, if the court finds that a substantial likelihood exists that the product was made by the patented process, and that the plaintiff made a reasonable effort to determine the process actually used and was unable to determine it, the product shall be presumed to have been so made, and the burden of establishing that it was not is on the party asserting that it was not so made. The order states that the parties do not dispute the first finding. On the second, it recounts that Oterra's objections acknowledged Oterra had opposed discovery directly from the Colombian company by deposition and/or by site inspection. The court overruled the objection that shifting the burden at this stage was an abuse of discretion. It stated that Oterra cannot provide incomplete discovery and then argue it is entitled to summary judgment because of that incomplete discovery.

The defendants' motion for summary judgment of infringement of RE46,695 (Doc. No. 233) is granted. The overruled objection argued that whether glycine is within the plain and ordinary meaning of "suitable food-grade source" should go to a jury, and that glycine is permitted within step (a)(ii) of claim 45 but is not required. The order states that summary judgment of infringement for Wild Flavors is proper because the court has already construed "suitable food-grade source" as encompassing glycine. It states that, on the summary judgment record, it is undisputed that glycine is non-toxic and safe for consumption, albeit in small quantities, and that this meets the construed meaning. The order states that the distinction Oterra drew between "food-grade source" and "food-grade quality" is not legally significant under the claim construction opinion.

The defendants' motion for summary judgment on the plaintiffs' invalidity defenses (Doc. No. 236) is granted in part and denied in part. The plaintiffs' invalidity defense of improper recapture is dismissed. The order agrees with the special master that the recapture rule does not apply to material falling outside the original patent's enumerated list, to milk, or to liquified material, and it overrules Oterra's recapture objection. The lack-of-enablement defense is dismissed except as to lack-of-enablement theories concerning claim 52. The plaintiffs' claim that the patent is not entitled to the filing date of its March 28, 2008 provisional application because of lack of enablement is dismissed except as to lack-of-enablement theories concerning claim 52. The plaintiffs' claim that the patent is not entitled to that filing date because of lack of written description is dismissed. On the priority-date objection, the court held that the special master's findings are not inconsistent: a genuine dispute remains on the priority date for claim 52 because that claim may present enablement issues, and claim 45 does not present similar enablement issues.

The defendants' motion to exclude certain opinions and testimony of Oterra's expert (Doc. No. 238) is granted in part, as to that expert's lack-of-enablement opinions regarding "different" blue colors and "desired colors," at paragraphs 63 and 83 to 89 of the expert report (Doc. No. 241-30). The order states that Oterra does not contest the special master's recommendation that its expert's testimony be excluded as inconsistent with the claim construction opinion. It overrules the argument that the defendants' expert's testimony, without Oterra's expert, was enough to take enablement of the remaining claims to a jury.

Oterra's objection to exclusion of a statement from a European Patent Office proceeding, and to the denial of summary judgment based on that statement, is overruled. The order states that the statement is excluded. The grounds stated in the order are that Oterra had not disclosed a "natural colors" invalidity theory in its interrogatory responses, that the statement is hearsay within hearsay, that patent law and examination differ from country to country, and that the risk of undue prejudice substantially outweighs the statement's probative value under Federal Rule of Evidence 403. Plaintiffs' motions in limine Nos. 2 and 4 (Doc. No. 303) are denied. The defendants' motion in limine No. 3 (Doc. No. 304) is denied as moot. The defendants' motion in limine No. 4 (Doc. No. 304) is granted. The European Patent Office opposition decision (Doc. No. 232-2) and European Patent Application No. EP 4 245 151 (Doc. No. 283-2) are excluded.

What the order leaves open

The November 12 order states that whether claim 52 is enabled will proceed to trial, and it does not dismiss the enablement-based challenge to the March 28, 2008 provisional filing date as to claim 52. It grants summary judgment of infringement and places on Oterra the burden of establishing that the accused products were not made by the process of claims 45 to 62. The docket also shows a special master report and recommendation filed November 13, 2026, and objections filed November 16, 2026. Watch for rulings on those filings. The case can end at any time, including by settlement or voluntary dismissal.