The order

Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd. v. CM HK, Ltd., No. 4:24-cv-06567-JST, is a declaratory judgment action in the Northern District of California. Judge Jon S. Tigar, United States District Judge, signed the 16-page order on November 9, 2026, and it was filed on the docket on November 17, 2026, as ECF No. 220. The order grants CM HK's motion to dismiss, terminates as moot a motion for reconsideration and a motion to stay pending inter partes review, and denies an administrative motion.

The plaintiffs are Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd. ("Samsung Korea") and Samsung Electronics America, Inc. ("Samsung USA") (collectively, "Samsung"). The defendant is CM HK, Ltd. ("CM HK"). The order describes Samsung Korea as a Korean corporation with its principal place of business in Korea, Samsung USA as a New York corporation with its principal place of business in New Jersey, and CM HK as a Chinese corporation with its principal place of business in Hong Kong. It refers to CyWee Group Ltd. ("CyWee") as a non-party and describes CyWee as a British Virgin Islands corporation with its principal place of business in Taipei. The order cites ECF No. 177, paragraphs 5 through 7 and paragraph 81, for those descriptions.

What Samsung filed

On September 18, 2024, Samsung filed this suit against CM HK and CyWee, seeking a declaratory judgment of non-infringement of U.S. Patent Nos. 10,275,038, 10,817,072, 10,852,846, and 11,698,687. The order calls those four patents the Asserted Patents and cites the complaint, ECF No. 1. It states, citing the complaint, that the Asserted Patents are in the same patent family as previously asserted U.S. Patent Nos. 8,441,438 and 8,552,978.

U.S. Patent Nos. 10,275,038 and 10,817,072 are each titled "Method and apparatus for performing motion recognition using motion sensor fusion, and associated computer program product." U.S. Patent Nos. 10,852,846 and 11,698,687 are each titled "Electronic device for use in motion detection and method for obtaining resultant deviation thereof."

On January 28, 2025, CM HK and CyWee moved to dismiss Samsung's complaint, at ECF Nos. 51 and 52. On February 20, 2025, Samsung filed a notice of voluntary dismissal as to CyWee based on representations made in CyWee's reply brief regarding CyWee's rights to the Asserted Patents. The order cites ECF No. 64 at 2 for that notice.

Other suits the order describes

The order states that in February 2017, CyWee filed suit against Samsung in the Eastern District of Texas, No. 2:17-cv-00140-RSW-RSP, accusing Samsung of infringing U.S. Patent Nos. 8,441,438 and 8,552,978. It states that CyWee also asserted those two patents against another company in this District, Case No. 4:14-cv-01853, and against two other companies in the Southern District of California, Case Nos. 3:17-cv-01102 and 3:17-cv-02130. The order states that CyWee Group filed the suit in this District before CM HK's formation, and that these suits asserted only claims for infringing the '438 and '978 patents.

The order states that CyWee Group still owns the '438 and '978 patents. It states that on March 1, 2017, CyWee Group and the defendant in the earlier suit in this District reached a settlement under which CyWee agreed to license its patents, citing ECF No. 194-42. It states that CM HK was an affiliate or subsidiary of another CyWee company as those terms were defined in the settlement agreement, and that at some point thereafter the patents were transferred to CM HK.

On October 31, 2024, the order states, CM HK filed suit against Samsung in the Eastern District of Texas, accusing Samsung of infringing the '846 and '687 patents. The order cites ECF No. 50, paragraph 1, for that suit.

The May 15, 2025 dismissal

On May 15, 2025, the court granted CM HK's earlier motion to dismiss for lack of personal jurisdiction. That order is ECF No. 73. This order quotes it: "CM HK's contacts with California are not sufficient to confer specific jurisdiction over CM HK." It states that alter ego jurisdiction was not appropriate because "Samsung has not shown that CyWee controls CM HK 'to such a degree as to render [CM HK] the mere instrumentality of [CyWee].'" The court found that Samsung had presented a "colorable basis" to believe there may be a commingling or manipulation of assets between CM HK and CyWee that would render CM HK the alter ego of CyWee, and it granted jurisdictional discovery.

After that discovery, CM HK again moved to dismiss, at ECF No. 182. Samsung opposed, at ECF No. 195, and the reply is ECF No. 198. The court took the motion under submission without a hearing, at ECF No. 204. The order states that the parties do not dispute that CM HK's contacts, standing alone, are insufficient to support a finding of specific jurisdiction, and that nothing about the present motion changes the earlier holding on CM HK's own contacts.

The standard the order applies

The order states that a defendant may move to dismiss a complaint for lack of personal jurisdiction under Rule 12(b)(2) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure. It states that, on that motion in a patent case, the court applies Federal Circuit law "because the jurisdictional issue is intimately involved with the substance of the patent laws." For a declaratory judgment of noninfringement, the order states that the relevant inquiry is "to what extent has the defendant patentee purposefully directed such enforcement activities at residents of the forum and the extent to which the declaratory judgment claim arises out of or relates to those activities." It states that "only those activities of the patentee that relate to the enforcement or defense of the patent can give rise to specific personal jurisdiction for such an action." It states that, when the plaintiff has received jurisdictional discovery and the facts are not in dispute, plaintiff must establish personal jurisdiction by a preponderance of the evidence. Separately, the order states: "The Court has subject matter jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. § 1331."

The 2017 settlement agreement

Samsung argued that the court has personal jurisdiction over CM HK because CM HK was a party to, and submitted to the court's jurisdiction in, the 2017 settlement agreement, and because CM HK "purposefully availed itself of this forum through its enforcement activities in this state." The order cites ECF No. 195 at 17 for that argument. The order states that the court agrees CM HK is a "party" to the settlement agreement according to the agreement's explicit terms. It nonetheless concludes that the settlement agreement is not an enforcement activity by CM HK. The order describes examples of activities that support specific jurisdiction as "initiating judicial or extra-judicial patent enforcement within the forum, or entering into an exclusive license agreement or other undertaking which imposes enforcement obligations with a party residing or regularly doing business in the forum," and it states that CM HK did not do those things. It states that CM HK "was added to a Settlement Agreement by another party that itself 'initiated judicial patent enforcement within the forum.'" The court finds that CM HK's inclusion in the settlement agreement does not constitute "intentional conduct by the defendant" directed at California, and that CM HK's connection to the earlier litigation in this District is "simply too attenuated to count as relevant enforcement activity."

Alter ego

Samsung argued that CM HK and the entities the order calls the "CyWee Entities" "operate as a single entity," and that it would be unjust not to treat them as a single entity for personal jurisdiction purposes. The heading in the order is "CM HK is Not the Alter Ego of the CyWee Entities."

CM HK argued that the internal affairs doctrine requires the court to apply Hong Kong law to determine whether CM HK is the alter ego of any other CyWee Entity. The court finds that argument unpersuasive. It states: "This is not a lawsuit about 'the internal affairs of the corporation'; rather, this lawsuit very much pertains to the rights of third parties external to the corporation." The order states that the court need not decide that question definitively, because it concludes that even under California law, Samsung's jurisdictional arguments fail.

The order quotes the alter ego showing as two parts: "(1) that there is such unity of interest and ownership that the separate personalities [of the two entities] no longer exist and (2) that failure to disregard [their separate identities] would result in fraud or injustice." It states that both factors must be met. The court concludes that Samsung has failed to demonstrate either "(1) that there is such unity of interest and ownership that the separate personalities CM HK and another CyWee Entity no longer exist or (2) that failure to disregard their separate identities would result in fraud or injustice."

On unity of interest, the order states that most of Samsung's commingling examples involve only entities other than CM HK, and that the two transfers involving CM HK are insubstantial. On corporate formalities, it states that the only evidence specifically concerning CM HK is a payment of travel expenses for a deposition on behalf of CyWee Group, and that this single payment does not establish a "disregard of corporate formalities and failure to maintain an arm's length relationship." On assuming debts, the order states that neither of the transactions it discusses actually involved CM HK, and that there is no reference to CM HK concerning that factor. It states that Samsung describes the common management and shared offices of various CyWee Entities, but not CM HK, and that Samsung does not allege that CM HK is inadequately capitalized.

On fraud or injustice, the order states that the court need not resolve whether CM HK must have been formed for the purpose of wrongdoing. It states that, regardless of the reason CM HK was formed, "acknowledging its separate existence will not work a fraud on Samsung." The order states that CM HK is its corporate group's intellectual property holding company and was assigned the group's patent portfolio on March 31, 2017, citing ECF No. 198 at 12 and ECF No. 182 at 12. It states that "CM HK did not do anything fraudulent at the time of its incorporation or subsequently." It states that Samsung identifies no sham restructuring, no newly formed entity, no California-directed licensing campaign, and no enforcement activity targeting California. The order states, "This case is not comparable to Google," referring to Google Inc. v. Rockstar Consortium U.S. L.P., which it cites as No. 13-CV-5933 CW, 2014 WL 1571807 (N.D. Cal. Apr. 17, 2014). It states: "CM HK was not formed under suspicious circumstances, and the transfer of patents did not occur in connection with the present dispute."

The court rejects Samsung's alter ego arguments for an additional reason. The order states that Samsung "does not limit its arguments to CM HK and its parent," and instead "sweeps in all the CyWee Entities." It quotes the statement that, "[g]enerally, alter ego liability is reserved for the parent-subsidiary relationship." It states that Samsung cites no authority for its group alter ego argument, and that the court "declines to fashion such a doctrine from whole cloth."

Samsung's final argument was that CM HK is in a joint venture with CyWee Group involving the enforcement of a patent portfolio, which Samsung argued gives the court specific jurisdiction over CM HK. The court finds that "Samsung has failed to show CM HK was in a joint venture with CyWee Group." It states that the shareholder agreement distributes profits between CyWee Group and another company, not CM HK. It states that the agreement refers to group subsidiaries set out in a schedule, but that the version submitted to the court does not contain that schedule, so "there is no way to know whether (1) CM HK is a party or (2) how many other entities are also parties." It states that, even assuming CM HK receives a share of profits from the agreement, Samsung identifies no evidence that CM HK and CyWee Group jointly control any patent enforcement decisions.

The order then states: "Samsung has failed to show after jurisdictional discovery that the Court has personal jurisdiction over CM HK. Accordingly, the Court grants CM HK's motion to dismiss."

The other motions

CM HK filed a motion for administrative relief, ECF No. 202, asking the court to take judicial notice of Samsung's change of principal place of business from Texas to New Jersey. The court denies the motion because that fact is irrelevant to the decision.

Samsung moved to stay the case pending inter partes review, at ECF No. 184. The order quotes CM HK: it "does not oppose a stay of merits proceedings pending the IPRs, provided the Court first resolves CM HK's pending motion to dismiss for lack of personal jurisdiction." The order states that, having resolved the motion to dismiss and finding that the court does not have personal jurisdiction, the court terminates the motion to stay pending inter partes review as moot.

The order also terminates as moot the motion for reconsideration at ECF No. 122.

The disposition

The conclusion states: "Because the Court has already granted both leave to amend and jurisdictional discovery, the Court concludes that amendment would be futile and grants the motion to dismiss with prejudice." The order cites Metzler Inv. GMBH v. Corinthian Colleges, Inc., 540 F.3d 1049, 1072 (9th Cir. 2008), for the quoted explanation that "the district court's discretion to deny leave to amend is particularly broad where plaintiff has previously amended the complaint." The next sentence states: "The Clerk shall enter judgment and close the file." A footnote states that, in light of the conclusions in the order, the court declines to reach CM HK's argument that the court lacks subject matter jurisdiction over the '038 and '072 patent claims.

The judgment entry

The docket lists entries dated November 9, 2026, the date the order was signed, including entry 216, labeled "Document Restricted to Applicable Parties AND Order Dismissing Case," and entry 218, labeled "Judgment - Clerk."

What to watch next

The order directs the clerk to enter judgment and close the file, and the docket lists an entry labeled "Judgment - Clerk" dated November 9, 2026. Watch for any notice of appeal.