The complaint

VL Collective IP LLC v. International Business Machines Corporation, No. 2:26-cv-00986 (E.D. Tex., Marshall Division), is a 21-page complaint filed October 30, 2026, as ECF No. 1. The caption demands a jury trial, and the complaint demands a jury on all issues so triable under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 38.

The complaint describes VL Collective IP LLC, shortened to VL IP, as a Delaware limited liability company with its principal place of business in Palo Alto, California. It alleges, on information and belief, that International Business Machines Corporation, shortened to IBM, is a New York corporation with its principal place of business in Armonk, New York. It says IBM maintains regular and established places of business in the district, including in Carrollton, Texas, and Plano, Texas, and that IBM has a Texas registered agent for service in Dallas, Texas.

Ownership of the patents

The complaint says VL Collective IP was founded in 2019 as a subsidiary of the prior owner of the three patents, and that in January 2026 the prior owner assigned all right, title, and interest in the patents to VL Collective IP. It describes a 2024 acquisition of a cloud-computing patent portfolio of which the asserted patents are a subset, and it says that portfolio originated with a company that developed a platform for managing on-premises and cloud-based services. It says those technologies form a core offering of IBM's cloud services. It says the prior owner attempted to discuss a license to the asserted patents with IBM. It alleges that, despite those attempts, IBM knowingly continued to infringe and continues to do so.

The three patents

The complaint says VL Collective IP owns the entire right, title, and interest in U.S. Patent No. 8,514,868, titled "Cloud Computing Gateway, Cloud Computing Hypervisor, and Methods for Implementing Same," which issued on August 20, 2013, on Application No. 12/488,424, filed June 19, 2009. It says U.S. Patent No. 9,069,599, titled "System and Method for a Cloud Computing Abstraction Layer with Security Zone Facilities," issued on June 30, 2015, on Application No. 13/354,275, filed January 19, 2012. It says U.S. Patent No. 9,973,474, also titled "Cloud Computing Gateway, Cloud Computing Hypervisor, and Methods for Implementing Same," issued on May 15, 2018, on Application No. 15/452,032, filed March 7, 2017. It says copies of the patents are attached as Exhibits A, B, and C.

The complaint says the '868 patent covers a cloud gateway system, a cloud hypervisor system, and methods for implementing the same, and that the '474 patent covers the same kind of subject matter. It says the '599 patent covers a virtualization environment adapted for development and deployment of at least one software workload, with a metamodel framework that allows a policy to be associated with the workload when the workload is deployed. It quotes claim 5 of the '868 patent, claim 1 of the '599 patent, and claim 1 of the '474 patent, and each count alleges infringement of at least the quoted claim. Exhibits D, E, and F, which the counts cite for the direct infringement allegations, are not available.

The infringement counts

The complaint refers to Red Hat OpenShift Virtualization Service on IBM Cloud, IBM Cloud Virtual Private Cloud (VPC), IBM Cloud File Storage for VPC, IBM Cloud Kubernetes Service, and IBM Cloud VPN for VPC together as the IBM Cloud Products. Count 1 alleges infringement of the '868 patent, including at least claim 5, literally and/or under the doctrine of equivalents. It alleges direct infringement under 35 U.S.C. § 271(a) by making, using, offering for sale, selling in the United States, or importing Red Hat OpenShift Virtualization Service on IBM Cloud together with IBM Cloud VPC and IBM Cloud File Storage for VPC, which it calls IBM Cloud Virtualization Service. It alleges induced infringement under § 271(b) through websites and online tutorials that it says instruct customers, end users, and third parties, and contributory infringement under § 271(c). On that contributory theory, it alleges that the service is a material part of the claimed inventions, that IBM knows to be especially made or especially adapted for use in an infringement of the patent, and is not a staple article or commodity of commerce suitable for substantial noninfringing use. It says the service directly infringes claim 5 as set forth in Exhibit D.

On notice for the '868 patent, the complaint alleges that published application US-2010/0027552A1, which it says issued as the '868 patent, was cited by the examiner on April 24, 2013, during prosecution of IBM application No. 12/686,538, and that IBM has known of that application since at least that date. It alleges, on information and belief, that IBM has known of the '868 patent since issuance. It alleges notice by no later than filing and service of the complaint, and, in the alternative, willful blindness. It alleges that the infringement has been and continues to be willful, and that VL Collective IP is entitled to enhanced damages of up to three times under 35 U.S.C. § 284.

Count 2 alleges infringement of the '599 patent, including at least claim 1, by IBM Cloud Kubernetes Service, on the same direct, induced, and contributory theories, and it says that service directly infringes claim 1 as set forth in Exhibit E. It points to IBM Cloud Kubernetes documentation as the inducing instructions. On notice, it alleges that IBM listed the '599 patent on an information disclosure statement on September 21, 2016, during prosecution of IBM application No. 15/271,313, and that an examiner cited the patent on October 18, 2017, during prosecution of IBM application No. 14/852,653. It alleges, in the alternative, willful blindness, notice by no later than filing and service, willful infringement, and enhanced damages of up to three times under § 284.

Count 3 alleges infringement of the '474 patent, including at least claim 1, by IBM Cloud VPN for VPC, on the same direct, induced, and contributory theories, and it says that service directly infringes claim 1 as set forth in Exhibit F. It points to IBM Cloud VPC and VPN pages and tutorials as the inducing instructions. For this patent, the complaint alleges that IBM was willfully blind to the patent and to infringement, and that IBM has known of the patent, or was willfully blind to it, since before the complaint was filed, and in any event no later than filing and service. It alleges that the infringement has been and continues to be willful, and it seeks the same enhanced damages.

For each patent, the complaint alleges that before this suit the prior owner corresponded with IBM, proposed a nondisclosure agreement and patent licensing discussions, and that IBM declined. It alleges that by trial IBM will have known and intended, since notice, that continued conduct would induce or contribute to infringement. It alleges that IBM has continued without a good-faith basis to believe the patent is invalid or not infringed. It alleges damages of no less than a reasonable royalty, with interest and costs, and that VL Collective IP will be irreparably harmed unless the court permanently enjoins IBM and its agents, employees, representatives, affiliates, and others acting in concert with IBM.

Jurisdiction and venue

The complaint pleads a civil action for patent infringement under Title 35, including 35 U.S.C. § 271, and it invokes subject-matter jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. §§ 1331 and 1338(a). It alleges personal jurisdiction under due process and/or the Texas long-arm statute because IBM has committed and continues to commit acts of patent infringement in Texas and in the district, because IBM recruits Texas residents, directly or through an intermediary located in Texas, for employment inside or outside the state, for example in its Plano, Carrollton, and Dallas data centers and offices, and because IBM is registered to do business in Texas. It alleges that exercising jurisdiction would not offend traditional notions of fair play and substantial justice because IBM has established minimum contacts with the forum. It alleges, on information and belief, that IBM makes, uses, sells, offers for sale, or imports the IBM Cloud Products in the United States, including in the district, and that IBM conducts operations related to those products in Eastern District of Texas facilities. It alleges venue under 28 U.S.C. § 1400(b) because IBM has committed acts of infringement and has regular and established places of business in the district.

The complaint states that IBM operates and maintains its DAL13 IBM Cloud data center in Carrollton, Texas, and its DAL14 IBM Cloud data center in Plano, Texas. It says IBM identifies those data centers on ISO 27017:2015 Certificate No. US022539, issued August 11, 2026. It quotes an IBM announcement: "Today, IBM Cloud opened its 10th data center in Dallas, Texas, in support of their virtual private cloud (VPC) operations. DAL14, the new addition, is the fourth availability zone in the IBM Cloud area of Dallas, Texas." It alleges, on information and belief, that IBM employees or contractors acting at IBM's direction install and maintain the infrastructure and equipment at those data centers.

The complaint says 2026 Denton County records list IBM business personal property of $56,481,695 in Carrollton, Texas, $7,636 in Roanoke, Texas, and $50,899 and $46,757 in Lewisville, Texas. It states that IBM has approximately $56 million of business personal property in Denton County, including, on information and belief, data servers, at locations in Carrollton, Lewisville, and Roanoke. It says 2026 Collin County records list approximately $13.9 million of IBM business personal property at various locations in the county, approximately $13.4 million of that in Plano, and approximately $26.8 million, as of January 1, 2026, at the site of a former DAL07 data center in Plano that the complaint says IBM has decommissioned. It also states that IBM has over $68 million of property in Collin County, including data servers in Plano, and it says various-location accounts appear to report the same equipment to overlapping taxing units. It alleges, on information and belief, that IBM has several offices in Texas, including in Dallas.

The prayer

The prayer asks for judgment of direct infringement under § 271(a), literally and/or under the doctrine of equivalents; induced infringement under § 271(b); contributory infringement under § 271(c); and a judgment that infringement has been and continues to be willful. It asks for compensatory damages according to proof and in any event no less than a reasonable royalty, pre-judgment and post-judgment interest at the maximum rate allowed by law, and enhanced damages of up to three times under § 284. It asks for an order and judgment permanently enjoining IBM and its officers, directors, agents, servants, employees, affiliates, attorneys, and all others acting in privity or in concert with them, and their parents, subsidiaries, divisions, successors, and assigns, from further acts of infringement of the asserted patents. It asks for a judgment that the case is exceptional, awarding costs and reasonable attorneys' fees incurred in the action under 35 U.S.C. § 285, and for further relief the court finds just and proper.

An earlier suit on the same patents

VL Collective IP asserted the same three patents against another company in the same court in No. 2:26-cv-00346 (E.D. Tex.), filed April 29, 2026. The court accepted a joint stipulation of dismissal in that case in an order signed October 7, 2026, which states that the plaintiff's claims against the defendant and the defendant's claims against the plaintiff are dismissed with prejudice.

What to watch next

Watch for an answer or a Rule 12 motion. The case can end at any time, including by settlement or voluntary dismissal.