Four complaints, one patent

On November 19, 2026, XR Communications, LLC, doing business as Vivato Technologies, filed four complaints in the Marshall Division of the Eastern District of Texas: XR Communications, LLC v. Best Buy Stores, L.P., No. 2:26-cv-01045, against Best Buy Stores, L.P., BestBuy.com, LLC, and Best Buy Texas.com, LLC; XR Communications, LLC v. Walmart Inc., No. 2:26-cv-01046, against Walmart Inc., Wal-Mart Stores Texas, LLC, and Wal-Mart.com USA, LLC; XR Communications, LLC v. Sam's West, Inc., No. 2:26-cv-01047, against Sam's West, Inc. and Sam's East, Inc., each doing business as Sam's Club; and XR Communications, LLC v. Target Corporation, No. 2:26-cv-01048, against Target Corporation. Each demands a jury.

The Best Buy complaint describes XR Communications as a Delaware limited liability company with its principal place of business in Keller, Texas, and alleges that it is the sole owner by assignment of all right, title, and interest in U.S. Patent No. 8,289,939. Each complaint alleges, on information and belief, where the defendants are organized and where they have their principal places of business. The Best Buy complaint alleges, on information and belief, that Best Buy Stores, L.P., BestBuy.com, LLC, and Best Buy Texas.com, LLC are Virginia entities with a principal place of business in Richfield, Minnesota. The Walmart complaint alleges, on information and belief, that Walmart Inc. is a Delaware corporation, that Wal-Mart Stores Texas, LLC is a Delaware limited liability company, and that Wal-Mart.com USA, LLC is a California limited liability company, and that each has its principal place of business in Bentonville, Arkansas. The Sam's Club complaint alleges, on information and belief, that Sam's West, Inc. and Sam's East, Inc. are Arkansas corporations, each doing business as Sam's Club, with a principal place of business in Bentonville, Arkansas. The Target complaint alleges, on information and belief, that Target Corporation is a Minnesota corporation with its principal place of business in Minneapolis, Minnesota.

The complaints also plead the size of each retailer. The Best Buy and Walmart complaints each allege that the defendant is one of the largest retailers of consumer Wi-Fi networking equipment in the United States. The Best Buy complaint cites the defendants' parent company's annual report for the fiscal year ended January 31, 2026, as reporting 926 domestic stores, including 98 in Texas, and approximately 82,000 employees in the U.S. and Canada. The Walmart complaint alleges that Walmart operates 595 retail units and 22 supply chain facilities in Texas and employs approximately 178,823 associates in the state, and it quotes Walmart Inc.'s annual report as stating that Walmart U.S. operates 4,611 stores in the U.S. The Sam's Club complaint quotes Walmart Inc.'s annual report as stating that Sam's Club U.S. operates 601 clubs in 44 states in the U.S. and Puerto Rico, cites 82 Sam's Club locations in Texas, and alleges that Sam's East, Inc. operates twelve clubs in the District. The Target complaint alleges that Target operates 1,995 retail stores in the United States, including 159 in Texas, and that as of January 31, 2026, it employed approximately 415,000 people.

The patent and the claims the complaints name

Each complaint alleges that U.S. Patent No. 8,289,939, entitled "Signal Communication Coordination," was issued on October 16, 2012. The face of the patent lists that title and that issue date, and Application No. 10/700,342, filed November 3, 2003. Each complaint's opening paragraph says the patent generally relates to wireless communication technology and, in particular, to coordinating signal transmission and reception among multiple wireless access points.

Claim 30 recites an apparatus comprising a wireless input/output (I/O) unit that is configured to establish a plurality of access points, and signal transmission/reception coordination logic that is capable of ascertaining, by monitoring the plurality of access points for received signals, that a first access point is receiving a first signal on a first channel, and that is adapted to restrain at least a second access point from transmitting a second signal on a second channel different from the first channel, responsive to that ascertaining. Claim 33, which depends from claim 30, recites that the signal received by the access point comprises at least one uplinked packet. Claim 34 recites that the signal comprises at least a portion of an uplinked packet. Claim 35, which depends from claim 34, recites that the portion comprises at least part of a preamble of the uplinked packet.

Claim 15 recites an apparatus with a wireless input/output unit configured to establish a plurality of access points, and coordination logic capable of ascertaining that a first access point is receiving a first signal on a first channel and that a second access point is receiving a second signal that is ongoing on a second channel, and adapted to restrain at least a third access point from transmitting a third signal on a third channel, responsive to that ascertaining. The claim recites that the restraining prevents degradation to the first and second signals. Claim 17, which depends from claim 15, recites that the prevented degradation comprises interference. The Best Buy, Walmart, and Target complaints say the charts attached as Exhibit 2 compare independent claim 30, together with dependent claims 33-35 and claims 15 and 17, to representative accused products. The Sam's Club complaint says its charts compare independent claim 30, together with dependent claims 33-35.

What each complaint accuses

Each complaint uses "Accused Products" for Wi-Fi 7 wireless routers, mesh Wi-Fi systems, access points, gateways, and range extenders that support multi-link operation, which the complaints abbreviate as MLO. The Best Buy complaint alleges that Best Buy sells, offers to sell, and uses those products in its stores and through its website and mobile applications. As examples of products it says Best Buy sells as the seller of record, the complaint names TP-Link Archer and Deco Wi-Fi 7 routers and mesh systems. It alleges that Best Buy offers Cudy and GL.iNet Wi-Fi 7 models through the Best Buy Marketplace and, on information and belief, sells them. The complaint also alleges that, through its Geek Squad services, Best Buy sets up, configures, and operates accused products in customers' homes and remotely, and that in performing those services Best Buy uses the products and instructs its customers to do the same.

The Walmart complaint alleges that Walmart sells, offers to sell, and uses accused products in its stores and through its website and mobile application. As examples of products it says Walmart sells as the seller of record, the complaint names TP-Link Archer and Deco Wi-Fi 7 routers and mesh systems. It names MSI Roamii and EnGenius Wi-Fi 7 products that Walmart offers through the Walmart Marketplace, and it alleges, on information and belief, that Walmart sells those Marketplace products. The complaint also alleges that Walmart sells a "Remote Router Setup" service as an add-on on its product pages for accused products, delivered by a service provider, and that through that service Walmart causes the products to be configured and operated in the infringing manner and instructs its customers to do the same. The complaint states that the accused products in that action do not include products sold through Sam's Club clubs or the Sam's Club website.

The Sam's Club complaint alleges that Sam's Club sells, offers to sell, and uses accused products in its clubs and through its website and mobile application. As examples, it names the TP-Link Archer BE4600 dual-band Wi-Fi 7 router and the TP-Link Deco BE4600 dual-band mesh Wi-Fi 7 system, in a 3-pack, that it says Sam's Club sells to its members and stocks for in-club pickup. It alleges that Sam's Club markets and sells Wi-Fi device installation services alongside the accused products.

The Target complaint alleges that Target sells, offers to sell, and uses accused products in its stores and through its website and mobile applications. It names the TP-Link Archer BE3600 dual-band Wi-Fi 7 router, which it says Target lists as the Archer BE3600 Pro and sells from its own inventory. It also names products it says Target offers through its Target Plus marketplace, including an Acer Predator Connect T7 mesh router, Cudy WR11000 and WR6500H routers, and manufacturer-refurbished TP-Link routers, a mesh system, an outdoor mesh unit, an access point, and range extenders. The complaint alleges, on information and belief, that Target has also offered for sale through Target Plus a manufacturer-refurbished TP-Link RE235BE range extender, which it says Target's website listed at a stated price but showed as out of stock on November 17, 2026.

The count and the relief sought

Each complaint pleads one count, Count I, Infringement of U.S. Patent No. 8,289,939. Each alleges direct infringement of one or more claims, including at least claim 30, literally and/or under the doctrine of equivalents, under 35 U.S.C. 271(a), by making, using, offering to sell, selling, and/or importing the accused products. Each alleges induced infringement under 35 U.S.C. 271(b) and contributory infringement under 35 U.S.C. 271(c), including at least claim 30. Each alleges that the accused products satisfy all limitations of at least claim 30. Each alleges that continued sales after notice of the patent and of the infringement identified in Exhibit 2 are willful, and each alleges that notice dates from at least the filing and service of the complaint.

The Best Buy, Walmart, and Sam's Club prayers ask the court to enter a judgment that the defendants have infringed, directly and indirectly, either literally and/or under the doctrine of equivalents, and that the asserted claims are valid, enforceable, and patent-eligible; to award damages, costs, expenses, and pre-judgment and post-judgment interest in an amount no less than a reasonable royalty; to require an accounting and supplemental damages, including interest, and an ongoing royalty for post-judgment infringement; to enter a judgment that the infringement has been willful and award enhanced damages under 35 U.S.C. 284; to enter a judgment and order finding the case exceptional under 35 U.S.C. 285 and awarding reasonable attorneys' fees and costs; to award injunctive and/or equitable relief, including ongoing royalties; and to award other relief the court deems appropriate. The Target prayer asks for the same relief and uses "Defendant" for Target.

Other suits on the '939 patent

XR Communications has asserted the '939 patent in earlier suits as well. Its complaints in Nos. 2:25-cv-00697, 2:25-cv-00698, and 2:25-cv-00699 (E.D. Tex.), all filed July 8, 2025, each plead three counts, one of them on the '939 patent. Its complaints in No. 2:25-cv-01253 (E.D. Tex.) and Nos. 7:25-cv-00590 and 7:25-cv-00591 (W.D. Tex.), all filed December 24, 2025, each plead two counts, one on the '939 patent and one on U.S. Patent No. 10,594,376. Its complaint in No. 2:26-cv-00001 (E.D. Tex.), filed January 5, 2026, pleads one count, on the '939 patent.

An earlier construction of the same patent

On November 14, 2024, Magistrate Judge Roy S. Payne signed a claim construction order, Document 99, in No. 2:23-cv-00202 (E.D. Tex.) and member cases Nos. 2:23-cv-00203 and 2:23-cv-00204. The order describes those three consolidated cases as alleging infringement of four patents, including the '939 patent, by the defendants in each case, and it notes that two other companies intervened. The order's chart gives "wireless input/output (I/O) unit," in claims 15 and 30 of the '939 patent, its plain and ordinary meaning, and the order holds that the term is not a means-plus-function term. The chart holds that "signal transmission/reception coordination logic," in claims 15 and 30, is governed by 35 U.S.C. 112, paragraph 6. The order identifies the corresponding structure as a general purpose processor programmed to accept multiple receive indicators from multiple BB units, determine whether an affirmative signal-reception indicator is detected, and provide instructions to the associated MACs to restrain signal transmission, and equivalents. The chart gives the "restrain ... responsive to the ascertaining" phrases in claims 15 and 30 their plain and ordinary meaning. The chart holds "the access point," in claims 20 and 21, indefinite. The order states that the Central District of California treated the logic term as a means-plus-function term and found sufficient corresponding structure to avoid a holding of indefiniteness, and that the Western District of Texas concluded the term is not a means-plus-function term.

An amended report of mediation filed November 4, 2025, Document 295 in No. 2:23-cv-00202, states that mediation between XR Communications and one of the intervenors ended in a suspended session and that, after continued discussions, a settlement has been reached. An order filed January 8, 2026, Document 299, captioned in that lead case and in Nos. 2:23-cv-00203 and 2:23-cv-00204, and signed by District Judge Rodney Gilstrap, granted a joint motion by XR Communications and the defendants in those cases. The order states that the parties represented that the cases had been resolved and requested dismissal with prejudice. It dismisses with prejudice all claims asserted by XR Communications against the defendants and other parties in those cases, dismisses counterclaims without prejudice, and directs the clerk to close the cases.

What to watch next

Watch for an answer or a Rule 12 motion in each of the four new suits. Any of these cases can end at any time, including by settlement or voluntary dismissal.