On November 13, 2026, the United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit issued two opinions in In re Netlist, Inc. The panel in each appeal was Judges Dyk, Linn, and Chen. Each opinion affirmed a Board determination of unpatentability, and each held that a live controversy regarding the patentability of Netlist's claims remains even though Samsung no longer participates and the Micron parties withdrew.

The precedential opinion

The precedential opinion in Nos. 2025-1286 and 2025-1296 is by Judge Dyk. The appeals are from inter partes reviews IPR2023-00454, IPR2023-00455, IPR2023-01141, and IPR2023-01142. The court affirmed Board decisions holding all claims of U.S. Patent Nos. 11,093,417 and 9,858,215 unpatentable as obvious over U.S. Patent No. 7,363,422 to Perego (Perego), in view of the DDR2 SDRAM specification JESD79-2 published by the Joint Electron Device Engineering Council (JEDEC). The court said it has jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. § 1295(a)(4)(A).

Both patents are titled Memory Module with Data Buffering. The '417 patent issued on August 17, 2021, and contains 15 claims. The '215 patent issued on January 2, 2018, and contains 29 claims. Each names Netlist, Inc. as assignee. The opinion says the specifications are substantially identical, and that the parties agree there are no material differences between the claims for purposes of this appeal. The court treated the '417 patent, and the inter partes review corresponding to it, as representative.

Representative claim 1 of the '417 patent, as the opinion sets it out, is a memory module operable in a computer system to communicate data with a memory controller over an N-bit wide memory bus in response to read or write commands. The module comprises a printed circuit board with edge connections for a module slot, logic that receives input address and control signals, including chip-select signals, and outputs registered address and control signals and data buffer control signals, and memory devices arranged in N-bit wide ranks that correspond to the registered chip-select signals. One rank, the one that receives the active registered chip-select signal, is configured to receive or output a burst of N-bit wide data. Circuitry between the data lines and the memory devices transfers that burst in response to the data buffer control signals and in accordance with an overall CAS latency of the module. Data transfers through the circuitry are registered for a time delay so that the module's overall CAS latency is greater than the actual operational CAS latency of each memory device.

The opinion describes that circuitry, in a module that uses chip-select signals, as a buffer between the memory devices and the computer's memory controller. It says the patent describes the buffer as isolating the ranks, which decreases the load on the computer system. The buffer may introduce a time delay, and the CAS latency limitation accounts for that delay. Netlist did not argue on appeal that the combination of Perego and JESD79-2 fails to satisfy the claim limitations.

Perego issued on April 22, 2008. The opinion says Perego discloses a buffer device disposed on a memory module that provides flexible system configurations. Perego disclosed address lines but did not specifically disclose chip-select signals. JESD79-2, published in September 2003, specifies timing, signal, and configuration requirements for DDR2 SDRAM chips, including chip-select signals for selecting which rank is written or read. The petitioners relied on Perego's buffer device as disclosing the circuitry that transfers the burst of data, and on JESD79-2 for chip-select signals. The opinion says the petitioners also relied on another JEDEC standard, JESD21-C, for timing limitations, and that this reference is not material to the appeal.

In a final written decision of July 30, 2024, the Board determined that the combination disclosed each limitation of claim 1. That determination was not challenged on appeal. The Board also determined that a person of ordinary skill would be motivated to combine Perego and JESD79-2, and it held that the combination rendered all challenged claims obvious. The Board did not reach the petitioners' other asserted obviousness grounds.

Operability and motivation to combine

Netlist argued that a person of ordinary skill would have lacked a motivation to combine the references. On Netlist's account, Perego disclosed only memory modules for a Rambus architecture, which did not use chip-select signals, and the combination would be inoperable for Perego's purpose of working with that architecture. Netlist pointed to the Board's conclusion that the proposed combination would make Perego's system non-functional for Rambus. Netlist also argued that conforming Perego to a JEDEC-compliant architecture would "cripple core functionalities described as benefits" in Perego, including flexibility to support new generations of memory devices while retaining backward compatibility with existing generations. Netlist did not assert that Perego teaches away from the chip-select signals used in JESD79-2.

The court concluded "that the relevant question is whether the combination is operable for the purposes of the claimed invention; that the Board properly concluded that it was; and that the Board's determination of motivation to combine was supported by substantial evidence." It affirmed. It relied on the rule that the motivation-to-combine inquiry asks whether a skilled artisan would have been motivated to combine the teachings of the prior art to achieve the claimed invention, not to meet requirements of the first reference that are not requirements of the claims. It repeated that in a motivation-to-combine analysis "the intended purpose of [the prior art] does not control." Compatibility with Rambus was not the purpose of the claimed invention, and backward compatibility was not an objective of the claimed invention. The claimed invention is directed to the ability to function in a JEDEC-compliant architecture. The court wrote that "[t]he fact that the combination was not compatible with Rambus and would not serve the backward-compatibility objectives of Perego is irrelevant."

The court described "limited circumstances where the purpose of the prior art device is pertinent." When a prior-art reference itself supplies the asserted motivation, the court said, it is logical to assume that the reference would not suggest a modification that contravenes its own contemplated purposes, as in In re Gordon. The petitioners did not rely on Perego's Rambus capabilities, or on backward compatibility with Rambus, to establish motivation to combine. The purpose of the prior art can also matter where that purpose is shared with the challenged claims, as in Polaris Industries, Inc. v. Arctic Cat, Inc., Medtronic, Inc. v. Teleflex Innovations S.à.r.l., and Chemours Co. FC, LLC v. Daikin Industries, Ltd. The court held this is not that situation. Netlist argued only that the combination is inoperable for Perego's intended purposes, not for the purposes of the claimed invention, and Netlist did not argue that Perego supplied the motivation to combine. The court held the Board did not err in finding a motivation to combine in which the combination was non-functional for Rambus but not for JEDEC, and in which the combination lost backward compatibility with Rambus memory devices.

Netlist also argued that the Board ignored the backward-compatibility argument, in violation of the Administrative Procedure Act. The court disagreed. It held that the Board addressed the point, including by quoting and discussing the portion of Perego that Netlist had identified.

On the affirmative motivation findings, the court held that substantial evidence supports the Board. The Board found that Perego itself suggested alternative embodiments compatible with JEDEC and not with Rambus: bussed topologies as an alternative to a point-to-point link; memory modules with a 64-bit data width, and the Board determined there was evidence that a 64-bit width was standard in JEDEC modules and wider than the 36-bit maximum used in the Rambus architecture; and row address strobe and column address strobe lines used in JEDEC architectures but not in Rambus. The court held that those disclosures are inconsistent with Netlist's contention that Perego was limited to Rambus, whether or not the signals uniquely signify a JEDEC-compliant architecture. The Board also relied on Perego's disclosure of a need for architectures that provide flexible upgrade capabilities, and on Perego's statement that its buffer may provide upgrade flexibility among a variety of possible module configurations. The Board found, from Netlist's expert testimony, that JEDEC-compliant modules were dominant in the market at the relevant time. Netlist did not contest that JEDEC had become dominant at the time of invention of the '417 patent, or that the combination was JEDEC capable.

The opinion's first footnote identifies the original petitioners as Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd., Micron Technology, Inc., Micron Semiconductor Products, Inc., and Micron Technology Texas, LLC. Before oral argument, Samsung settled with Netlist and filed a notice of nonparticipation (Dkt. No. 61). After oral argument, the Micron parties reached their own settlement with Netlist and withdrew (Dkt. Nos. 65 and 68). The United States Patent and Trademark Office declined to intervene (Dkt. No. 70). The court held that a live controversy regarding the patentability of Netlist's claims remains, citing In re Rambus, Inc., 753 F.3d 1253, 1254 (Fed. Cir. 2014).

The nonprecedential opinion

No. 2024-2304 is a nonprecedential opinion by Judge Chen. The appeal is from IPR2022-00615 and IPR2023-00203. The court affirmed the Board's final written decision holding claim 16 of U.S. Patent No. 7,619,912 unpatentable under 35 U.S.C. § 103. The opinion cites that decision as Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd. v. Netlist, Inc., No. IPR2022-00615, 2024 WL 1661650 (P.T.A.B. Apr. 17, 2024). The court wrote: "Because the Board did not err in its claim construction, and substantial evidence supports the Board's findings on priority and obviousness, we affirm."

U.S. Patent No. 7,619,912 is titled Memory Module Decoder and issued on November 17, 2009. It names Netlist, Inc. as assignee. The opinion says the patent relates to devices and methods for improving the performance, the memory capacity, or both, of memory modules in a computer system. Memory devices, for example dynamic random-access memory devices, are mounted on a circuit board that includes a logic element, and the devices are arranged in rows called ranks. The opinion describes the claimed arrangement as using plural lower-capacity memory devices to emulate fewer higher-capacity devices, by increasing the number of devices per rank, the number of ranks, or both. The parties call the operation of intercepting control signals, creating a new set, and transmitting the new signals to the ranks rank multiplication. The computer system also sends command signals, such as read and write.

Claim 16 depends from independent claim 15. As the opinion quotes the claim, the module is connectable to a computer system and comprises a printed circuit board, a plurality of double-data-rate memory devices arranged in a first number of ranks, and a circuit with a logic element and a register. The logic element receives input signals from the computer system, including at least one row/column address signal, bank address signals, and at least one chip-select signal. Those input signals are configured to control a second, smaller number of double-data-rate memory devices arranged in a second, smaller number of ranks. The circuit generates output signals configured to control the larger set, and it responds to a command signal by selecting one or two ranks and transmitting the command signal to at least one memory device of the selected rank or ranks. A phase-lock loop device is coupled to the printed circuit board and operatively coupled to the memory devices, the logic element, and the register. Claim 16 adds that the command signal is transmitted to only one double-data-rate memory device at a time.

Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd. filed the inter partes review. The petition argued that claim 16 was unpatentable under 35 U.S.C. § 103 in view of U.S. Patent Application Publication No. 2006/0277355 (Ellsberry). The Board instituted review and later joined Micron Technology, Inc., Micron Semiconductor Products, Inc., and Micron Technology Texas, LLC as an additional petitioner in Samsung's already-instituted review. The Board determined that claim 16 was unpatentable under § 103(a) in view of Ellsberry. It construed rank to allow as few as one memory device per rank. It concluded that the '912 patent was not entitled to the earlier priority dates of U.S. Patent No. 7,286,436 or of U.S. Provisional 60/588/244, both filed before Ellsberry, because those applications lack written-description support for claim 16. The '912 patent is a continuation-in-part of application No. 11/075,395, filed March 7, 2005, which issued as the '436 patent. The Board also concluded that Ellsberry discloses ranks having a single memory device and therefore teaches or suggests transmitting a command signal to only one double-data-rate memory device at a time.

The court adopted the Board's construction: rank need not include a plurality of memory devices, and a rank can contain as few as one. The plain language of claim 16 does not impose a minimum number of memory devices in a rank. The court agreed that column 8 of the patent, which says a command signal is passed through to both associated ranks and is sent to both memory devices, describes embodiments with two memory devices, one in each of two ranks, and that Figure 6B illustrates memory devices of different ranks with no other memory devices shown on either rank. The court did not need to consider two further examples in the specification, Verilog code for field-effect transistor switches, because column 8 and Figure 6B were enough.

The court rejected Netlist's arguments for a minimum of more than one memory device per rank. Claim 55's recitation that each rank comprises a plurality of chip packages shows, the court held, that the drafter knew how to require a minimum number when that was desired. The court was not persuaded that column 8 and Figure 6B are only partial views of a larger circuit. Netlist argued that the Board departed from a construction adopted in an earlier reexamination, in which claim 16 survived and the examiner discussed transmitting a command signal to only one memory device at a time when a rank contains a plurality of memory devices. The court held that the examiner's statement was not a claim construction. It was an explanation of a shortcoming in the requester's argument about a prior-art reference whose ranks contained a plurality of memory devices. The Board upheld that reexamination, and the Federal Circuit affirmed in a 2020 per curiam decision. The court also was not persuaded that a skilled artisan would read rank in light of JEDEC standards as requiring multiple memory devices per rank. The claims define DDR as the abbreviation for double-data-rate, and a JEDEC-based reading would be inconsistent with the specification's examples of a rank that contains a single memory device.

On priority, the court held that substantial evidence supports the Board's findings that neither the '436 patent nor the '244 provisional contains written-description support for claim 16. The '436 patent never mentions a register. Netlist argued that the '436 patent discloses a programmable logic device that performs sequential logic, which a skilled artisan would understand to require a register. The Board found that a storage role could be filled by a device other than a register, and the court held that the Board could reasonably so find because both experts agreed that what is inherent in the '436 patent's disclosure is a storage element that would not necessarily need to be a register. The opinion notes that the Board cited a website the parties had not brought to its attention. The court said that reliance might give it pause if the court had to consider the website, including because the Board's 2024 review of that website does not necessarily show what a skilled artisan would have known at the '436 patent's filing date, and because Netlist had no opportunity to attempt to disqualify the website as a reference. Micron did not defend the Board's reliance on the website on appeal, and the opinion quotes Micron's counsel at argument as saying it has "agreed that that was improper, but it was not essential to the Board's analysis." The court also did not reach Netlist's separate arguments about whether a register inside the logic element would satisfy the claim, or about whether Netlist had to show written-description support for every limitation of claim 16.

The '244 provisional does not mention bank address signals. The Board found that a skilled artisan would need several consecutive inferences to treat those signals as inherently disclosed: that the provisional pertains to double-data-rate modules even though it never mentions them; that such devices use bank address signals under JEDEC standards; that the unmentioned signals are included among control signals the provisional does mention, even though other address signals are set out separately; and that the bank address signals are used for rank multiplication. The Board called that chain too long and speculative. The court held that this was reasonable, because Netlist had not adequately explained why a skilled artisan would infer that the bank address signals are received by the logic element in particular. The court rejected the argument that the provisional should be read in light of JEDEC standards on that point. As with the '912 patent, the provisional does not limit itself to JEDEC compliance.

On obviousness, the court held that substantial evidence supports the finding that Ellsberry discloses transmitting a command signal to only one double-data-rate memory device at a time. The Board determined that Ellsberry's Figure 12 depicts a complete memory module with two ranks that each have one memory device. Ellsberry states that its Figures 10 through 13 illustrate different configurations of memory modules, and it does not describe those figures as partial configurations. The court rejected Netlist's argument that a single memory device per rank would defeat Ellsberry's purpose of expanding capacity. The '912 patent teaches that capacity may be increased by increasing the number of memory devices per rank or by increasing the number of ranks. The court added that even if a single device per rank would render Ellsberry incompatible with JEDEC standards, "that cannot overcome Ellsberry's express depiction of such a rank in FIG. 12."

On August 18, 2026, Samsung notified the court that it would not participate in this appeal (ECF No. 88). After oral argument, Micron moved to withdraw in view of a settlement agreement with Netlist (ECF No. 92), and the court granted the motion (ECF No. 94). The United States Patent and Trademark Office declined to intervene (ECF No. 96). The court held that a live controversy regarding the patentability of Netlist's claims remains, citing In re Rambus, Inc., 753 F.3d 1253, 1254 (Fed. Cir. 2014). The court considered Netlist's remaining arguments and found them unpersuasive, and it affirmed.

What to watch next

Watch for any petition for rehearing and for issuance of the mandate in Nos. 2025-1286, 2025-1296, and 2024-2304.