The complaint
IoT Innovations LLC filed IoT Innovations LLC v. VTech Holdings Limited and VTech Telecommunications Limited, No. 2:26-cv-01030, in the Marshall Division of the Eastern District of Texas on November 13, 2026. IoT Innovations demands a jury.
IoT Innovations says it is a Texas limited liability company with a registered office in Austin, Texas. It says it acquired the asserted patents from a prior owner under a patent sale agreement dated July 27, 2022, that the assignments were recorded with the United States Patent and Trademark Office, and that it is the sole owner of each patent, including the right to sue for past, present, and future infringement and to collect damages.
The complaint alleges, on information and belief, that VTech Holdings Limited is a Bermuda corporation with its principal place of business in Tai Po, Hong Kong, and that it is the parent of controlled subsidiaries, including VTech Telecommunications Limited. It alleges, on information and belief, that VTech Telecommunications Limited is a Hong Kong corporation with its principal place of business in Tai Po, Hong Kong. It alleges, on information and belief, that the defendants own, operate, advertise, or control the websites vtech.com, leapfrog.com, and snom.com.
The complaint says the company's U.S. site describes VTech as a global leader in electronic learning products for children and a leading supplier of residential telecommunication products, and it names the brands VTech, LeapFrog, Snom, InnoTab, and Kidizoom. Citing the company's annual report, it alleges a global workforce of approximately 20,000 employees in 19 countries and regions, and United States sales in 2026 of approximately $2.03 billion.
The complaint pleads venue under 28 U.S.C. 1391(c)(3) on the ground that the defendants are not residents of the United States, and it cites In re HTC Corp., 889 F.3d 1349 (Fed. Cir. 2018). It alleges personal jurisdiction from business and accused sales in Texas and in the district, and it pleads personal jurisdiction under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 4(k)(2), in addition or in the alternative. It alleges that the accused products reach end users in the district through retail stores, including locations in Marshall, Tyler, and Longview, Texas, and through Amazon.com fulfillment centers servicing the Eastern District of Texas.
The six patents
The complaint asserts six patents. U.S. Patent 9,008,055, Automatic Remote Services Provided by a Home Relationship Between a Device and a Server, issued April 14, 2015, on application 10/903,931, filed July 29, 2004. U.S. Patent 7,346,340, Provision of User Policy to Terminal, issued March 18, 2008, on application 11/170,100, filed June 30, 2005. U.S. Patent 7,593,428, Apparatus, and Associated Method, for Forming, and Operating Upon, Multiple-Checksum-Protected Data Packet, issued September 22, 2009, on application 11/621,545, filed January 9, 2007. U.S. Patent 7,246,173, Method and Apparatus for Classifying IP Data, issued July 17, 2007, on application 09/834,918, filed April 16, 2001. U.S. Patent 7,756,073, Method for Updating a Routing Entry, issued July 13, 2010, on application 10/247,567, filed September 20, 2002. U.S. Patent 7,161,960 has the same title as the '428 patent and issued January 9, 2007, on application 10/106,468, filed March 26, 2002.
The accused products
The complaint defines the accused products as five groups, together with substantially similar products and services, including prior and later versions. The first is Wi-Fi IP cameras and baby monitors used with the MyVTech Cams mobile application and its camera account and remote-monitoring services, and the complaint names the VTech VC931 as an example. The second is LTE mobile phones offered through the Gigaset business, and the complaint names the Gigaset GL30 as an example. The third is IEEE 802.11n Wi-Fi video monitors, cameras, and devices, and the complaint names the VTech VM981 as an example, along with LeapFrog products including the LeapPad Ultimate. The fourth is IPv6-capable SIP telephones, and the complaint names the VTech VSP736 ErisTerminal IP phone, including as used with a paired VSP601 DECT cordless handset, along with other VTech, Gigaset, and Snom desksets. The fifth is mobile applications that use two-factor, one-time-passcode authentication: MyVTech Baby Plus, which the complaint says is used with RM- and VC-series baby monitors, MyVTech Baby Pro, and LeapFrog Baby Care.
The counts
After a count on notice and willfulness, the complaint pleads one infringement count for each patent. Each count uses one claim as an example and alleges direct infringement, literally or under the doctrine of equivalents.
For the '055 patent, the example is claim 1. The complaint alleges direct infringement that is continuing, by using, providing, supplying, or distributing the accused products. It names the VC931, the MyVTech Cams application, the associated remote-monitoring services, and other Wi-Fi camera and monitor models in that count. As the complaint describes claim 1, a server of a home network receives information that was stored in a mobile device when the relationship was established, once the device connects to the Internet through a local network that is separate and remote from the home network; establishing the relationship includes allowing the user to set preferences that identify at least one service performed automatically between the device and the server; and if the device is recognized, the server automatically activates at least one function to initiate a data transfer through the local network. The complaint alleges that MyVTech Cams transmits account login information and camera-related security identifiers to VTech's cloud service when the user's mobile device connects from a separate network. It says marking under 35 U.S.C. 287(a) does not apply because the asserted claim is a method, and it alleges irreparable harm.
For the '340 patent, the example is claim 24. The complaint alleges past direct infringement by the Gigaset GL30 and other Gigaset mobile phones named in that count. As the complaint describes claim 24, the user terminal authenticates into a visited network that is distinct from its home network, receives an authentication success message that includes a user policy based at least in part on a local policy of the visited network, and applies that policy to uplink packets. The complaint alleges that the GL30 operates in an LTE network that distinguishes a home network from a visited network. It says IoT Innovations or its predecessors satisfied the statutory obligations required to collect pre-filing damages, and it seeks damages for the enforceable period ending on the expiration date of the patent.
For the '428 patent, the example is claim 14. The complaint ties that example to the VM981 operating under IEEE 802.11n and to other Wi-Fi monitors and LeapFrog products named in that count, including the LeapPad Ultimate. As the complaint describes claim 14, a transceiver station receives data and, under programmed instructions, selects two portions of the data, calculates a checksum on each, and formats a packet that contains both portions and indicia of both calculations. The complaint alleges that the VM981 practices those steps through the IEEE 802.11n A-MPDU aggregation and subframe-delimiter scheme, protecting MPDU delimiter fields and the MPDU frame check sequence. It says marking does not apply because the asserted claim is a method, and it seeks damages for the enforceable period ending on the expiration date of the patent.
For the '173 patent, the example is claim 1. The complaint ties that example to the VSP736 and to other SIP phones named in that count, including Gigaset and Snom models. As the complaint describes claim 1, a first node receives Internet Protocol data whose header lists at least one intermediate node, and classifies the data based on an entry in that header. The complaint alleges that the VSP736 is a native IPv6 endpoint, configured by the defendants' firmware and Administrator and Provisioning Manual to assign Differentiated Services code point (DSCP) values that separate voice packets from call-control packets. It says marking does not apply because the asserted claim is a method, and it seeks damages for the enforceable period ending on the expiration date of the patent.
For the '073 patent, the example is claim 1, and the complaint alleges direct infringement that is continuing, by the MyVTech Baby Plus, MyVTech Baby Pro, and LeapFrog Baby Care applications. As the complaint describes claim 1, a first network node sends a routing-entry update request to a second node, the request carries an identification of the update, verification information tied to that identification is submitted to a routing node, the second node asks the routing node to verify the update, and the verification information is then retrieved. The complaint's example is a sign-in or a password change in MyVTech Baby Plus: the application sends a request to an authentication server, and the verification information is a one-time passcode sent to the user's registered email. It says marking does not apply because the asserted claim is a method. The count alleges damages for the enforceable period ending on the expiration date of the patent, and it also alleges continuing infringement and irreparable harm.
For the '960 patent, the example is claim 16. The complaint ties that example to the VM981 and to Wi-Fi monitors and LeapFrog products named in that count. As the complaint describes claim 16, the method communicates a packet that has a header and a payload, and the claimed improvement selects two portions of the data, calculates a checksum on each, and formats the packet so that it identifies each portion and the indicia of its checksum. The complaint alleges that the VM981, operating under IEEE 802.11n, did this in an A-MPDU subframe, using an MPDU delimiter CRC and an MPDU frame check sequence. It says marking does not apply because the asserted claim is a method, and it seeks damages for the enforceable period ending on the expiration date of the patent.
The September 18 notice letter
The complaint alleges that on September 18, 2026, IoT Innovations sent a written notice letter to VTech Holdings Limited at its principal place of business in Tai Po, Hong Kong, addressed to the company secretary. It says the letter identified each of the six patents and placed VTech Holdings on actual notice of its potential infringement under 35 U.S.C. 287(a). It alleges that VTech Holdings received the letter, that delivery was confirmed, and that both defendants continued to make, use, sell, offer to sell, and import the accused products in the United States, including in the district, without taking a license, redesigning the products, or providing a substantive response. It alleges that infringement of each asserted patent that remained unexpired as of September 18, 2026 has been willful, and it reserves the right to prove additional post-complaint willful infringement supporting enhanced damages up to treble under 35 U.S.C. 284.
Indirect infringement and the prayer
For the '055 and '073 patents, the complaint alleges, on information and belief, induced infringement and contributory infringement. It alleges that if a user performs a claimed step, the defendants are still liable for direct infringement because they direct and control that step, by conditioning use of the product on the step and setting the manner or timing of it, and liable for inducement as well. It alleges, on information and belief, that the defendants have a policy or practice of not reviewing the patents of others. It alleges knowledge of each of those two patents at least as of September 18, 2026, and it alleges that direct infringement of them is willful. The '073 count also alleges, as a basis for inducement, knowledge of that patent no later than VTech Holdings' receipt of the September 18 letter, and in any event by the filing of the complaint.
The prayer asks for a judgment that one or more claims of each asserted patent has been infringed, either literally or under the doctrine of equivalents; a permanent injunction against infringement of the '055 and '073 patents, or, in the alternative, a reasonable ongoing royalty for future infringement of those two patents; an accounting and payment of damages and costs; a finding that infringement of the '055 and '073 patents was willful, and treble damages under 35 U.S.C. 284 for that period; pre-judgment and post-judgment interest; and a declaration that the case is exceptional, with fees and costs under 35 U.S.C. 285.
Other suits on the same patents
IoT Innovations has asserted several of the same patents in other suits. Its complaints that include a count on the '055 patent include Nos. 2:26-cv-00334, 2:26-cv-00758, 2:26-cv-00826, and 2:26-cv-00987 (E.D. Tex.), No. 1:26-cv-10653 (N.D. Ill.), and the first consolidated complaint in No. 1:23-cv-10352 (D. Mass.). Its complaints that include a count on the '428 patent include Nos. 2:25-cv-00033, 2:25-cv-00239, 2:25-cv-01009, 2:26-cv-00334, 2:26-cv-00736, 2:26-cv-00758, 2:26-cv-00826, and 2:26-cv-00987 (E.D. Tex.) and the first consolidated complaint in No. 1:23-cv-10352 (D. Mass.). Its complaints that include a count on the '173 patent include Nos. 2:25-cv-00239, 2:25-cv-00333, 2:25-cv-00352, 2:25-cv-01009, and 2:26-cv-00736 (E.D. Tex.), No. 0:25-cv-60483 (S.D. Fla.), and No. 1:26-cv-10653 (N.D. Ill.), and the No. 1:26-cv-10653 complaint also includes a count on the '960 patent. Its complaint in No. 2:26-cv-00758 (E.D. Tex.) includes a count on the '340 patent, and its complaint in No. 2:25-cv-01217 (E.D. Tex.) and the first consolidated complaint in No. 1:23-cv-10352 (D. Mass.) include a count on the '073 patent.
What to watch next
The complaint was filed on November 13, 2026. Watch for the defendants' response to the complaint. The case can end at any time, including by settlement or voluntary dismissal.