The notice

On November 16, 2026, John A. Squires, Under Secretary of Commerce for Intellectual Property and Director of the United States Patent and Trademark Office, issued a two-page Notice of Decisions on Institution. The same notice is entered as Paper 14 in each of IPR2026-00377, IPR2026-00378, IPR2026-00379, IPR2026-00380, IPR2026-00381, and IPR2026-00382. It is captioned before the Director, and it decides institution in all six proceedings by listing them under each outcome. The notice states that, pursuant to 35 U.S.C. 314(a), "after review of the merits," the petitioner has failed to show a reasonable likelihood of prevailing with respect to at least one of the claims challenged in the petition. It states that institution of inter partes review is denied in IPR2026-00378 and IPR2026-00380. The notice states that, pursuant to 35 U.S.C. 314(a), "after review of the merits," the petitioner has shown a reasonable likelihood of prevailing with respect to at least one of the claims challenged in the petition, and that no other non-discretionary considerations warrant denial of institution. It states that institution of inter partes review is granted in IPR2026-00377, IPR2026-00379, IPR2026-00381, and IPR2026-00382.

35 U.S.C. 314(a) provides that the Director may not authorize an inter partes review to be instituted unless the Director determines that the information presented in the petition filed under section 311 and any response filed under section 313 shows that there is a reasonable likelihood that the petitioner would prevail with respect to at least 1 of the claims challenged in the petition.

The six proceedings

Tesla, Inc. is the petitioner, and ChargeLogic LLC is the patent owner. IPR2026-00377 challenges U.S. Patent 10,090,567, and institution of inter partes review is granted. IPR2026-00378 challenges U.S. Patent 11,258,107, and institution of inter partes review is denied. IPR2026-00379 challenges U.S. Patent 11,508,996, and institution of inter partes review is granted. IPR2026-00380 challenges U.S. Patent 11,721,844, and institution of inter partes review is denied. IPR2026-00381 challenges U.S. Patent 11,909,010, and institution of inter partes review is granted. IPR2026-00382 challenges U.S. Patent 11,909,011, and institution of inter partes review is granted.

The patents

U.S. Patent 10,090,567 issued on October 2, 2018, and is titled Vehicular Battery Charger, Charging System, and Method. It contains 20 claims. Claim 1 is a vehicle charger for charging a battery of a vehicle. The charger is adapted for communication with a first controller remote from the vehicle and for wireless communication with a second controller associated with a computer. It includes an electrical power cord releasably attachable to at least one of the vehicle and a source of power, a third controller, and at least one of a transmitter and a receiver. The third controller is responsive to at least one signal from the first controller by automatically changing a charging state of the vehicle charger at a time associated with a cost of power to the battery reaching a threshold cost of power.

U.S. Patent 11,258,107 issued on February 22, 2022, and is titled Vehicular Battery Charger, Charging System, and Method for Transmitting Battery Charge Threshold Information. It contains 14 claims. Claim 1 is a system for charging a battery of a vehicle. A controller receives, via a user-manipulatable control, data indicative of a predetermined threshold level of charge that is less than a full charge, compares a level of charge of the battery to that threshold during charging, and, before charging is complete, sends at least one signal as an alert via a transmitter. A portable controller remote from the vehicle generates a notification to a user indicating that threshold.

U.S. Patent 11,508,996 issued on November 22, 2022, and is titled Vehicular Battery Charger, Charging System, and Method. It contains 20 claims. Claim 1 is a vehicle alignment system for an inductive vehicular battery charger having a first core movable with respect to a second core to charge a battery of a vehicle. The system includes a controller and a display mounted within the vehicle, oriented for view by a user seated in the vehicle. The controller disables a user control on the display usable to control the inductive charging of the battery when it detects a misalignment of the first core with respect to the second core, and enables that control when it detects alignment after the vehicle moves.

U.S. Patent 11,721,844 issued on August 8, 2023, and is titled Vehicular Battery Charger, Charging System, and Method for Transmitting Battery Charge Threshold Information. It contains 20 claims. Claim 1 is a system for charging a battery of a vehicle. A controller electrically coupled to a battery charger compares, during charging, a level of charge of the battery to a predetermined threshold level of charge and, before charging is complete, wirelessly sends at least one signal via a transmitter indicative of that threshold.

U.S. Patent 11,909,010 issued on February 20, 2024, and is titled Vehicular Battery Charger, Charging System, and Method with In-Vehicle Display of Charge Time. It contains 20 claims. Claim 1 is a vehicle charger for charging a battery of a vehicle, with a display mounted within the vehicle and a controller onboard the vehicle. The controller begins an active charging session based on a programmed manner of charge and at least one condition, calculates an amount of time required to charge the battery, displays that amount of time on the display, and repeatedly updates it.

U.S. Patent 11,909,011 issued on February 20, 2024, and is titled Vehicular Battery Charger, Charging System, and Method Displaying Charge Information. It contains 20 claims. Claim 1 is a system for charging a battery of a vehicle with a vehicular battery charger. A controller establishes wireless communication with a portable controller of a user remote from the vehicle and, responsive to a wireless signal from that portable controller, supplies electricity from a source of power to the battery. During charging, the controller repeatedly estimates an amount of time remaining to charge the battery and repeatedly displays, on a display mounted within the vehicle and within view of a user seated in the vehicle, information indicative of that amount of time and information indicative of the level of charge.

How the patents connect

The later patents identify continuation chains that return to the application issued as U.S. Patent 10,090,567. That patent issued from U.S. Application 12/737,803, filed as PCT/US2009/054174 on August 18, 2009, and it claims the benefit of provisional application 61/189,353, filed August 18, 2008. U.S. Patent 11,258,107 is a continuation of application 16/056,041, filed August 6, 2018, now abandoned, which is a continuation of application 12/737,803. U.S. Patent 11,508,996 is a continuation of application 16/056,059, filed August 6, 2018, now abandoned, which is a continuation of application 12/737,803. U.S. Patent 11,721,844 and U.S. Patent 11,909,010 are each continuations of application 17/188,269, filed March 1, 2021, now U.S. Patent 11,508,996, and from there the chain runs through abandoned application 16/056,059 to application 12/737,803. U.S. Patent 11,909,011 is a continuation of application 16/249,028, filed January 16, 2019, now U.S. Patent 11,489,207, which is a continuation of abandoned application 16/056,041, which is a continuation of application 12/737,803.

The district court case

On March 23, 2026, ChargeLogic LLC filed a complaint against Tesla, Inc. in the Western District of Texas, Midland-Odessa Division, ChargeLogic LLC v. Tesla, Inc., No. 7:26-cv-00100. The complaint demands a jury trial. It states that ChargeLogic makes its allegations "on personal knowledge as to their own acts, and on information and belief as to all others based on investigation." It asserts the six patents and alleges direct, induced, and joint infringement. It alleges that ChargeLogic is the sole and exclusive owner of all rights, title, and interest in the patents. The complaint describes ChargeLogic as a Texas limited liability company with its principal place of business in Midland, Texas, and it describes Tesla as a Texas corporation that maintains its headquarters in Austin, Texas. The complaint identifies accused products that include the Tesla Model 3, Model Y, Model S, Model X, Cybertruck, and Semi, which it calls the Accused Tesla Vehicles, and also Cybercabs and devices or equipment that connect with them. The complaint alleges that Tesla employs tens of thousands of employees at its headquarters and other locations within the Western District of Texas, and that, as of Tesla's most recent report to Travis County, Tesla employed 21,191 individuals in the Austin metro area in 2024. It also alleges that, in Travis County alone, Tesla maintains billions in appraised value of commercial property and other assets.

What to watch next

Watch for a scheduling order in IPR2026-00377, IPR2026-00379, IPR2026-00381, and IPR2026-00382, and for any request for rehearing in IPR2026-00378 and IPR2026-00380. In No. 7:26-cv-00100, the docket shows an entry labeled "Scheduling Order" on October 14, 2026 (ECF No. 52). The case can end at any time, including by settlement or voluntary dismissal.