The decision
On November 17, 2026, the United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit decided Cocona, Inc. v. VF Outdoor, LLC, Nos. 2025-1458 and 2025-1462. The panel was Judges Lourie, Stoll, and Stark. Judge Stark wrote the opinion. The appeals are from the United States District Court for the District of Colorado in Nos. 1:16-cv-02703-CMA-SBP and 1:17-cv-01195-CMA-SBP, Judge Christine M. Arguello. The court's opinions-and-orders listing for No. 25-1458 marks the opinion precedential. The opinion states that Cocona, Inc. sued VF Outdoor, LLC d/b/a The North Face and Columbia Sportswear Company for infringing U.S. Patent No. 8,945,287. The court wrote: "The district court determined that the asserted claims are invalid due to indefiniteness and entered final judgment for VF Outdoor and Columbia. Cocona now appeals. We affirm." The conclusion states: "Because we agree with the district court's judgment that the asserted claims are invalid for indefiniteness, we affirm." The disposition is "AFFIRMED." The court wrote that it has jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. § 1295(a)(1).
The patent and the asserted claims
Cocona owns the '287 patent. The opinion states that it is entitled "Active Particle-Enhanced Membrane and Methods for Making and Using the Same," and that it claims a waterproof, breathable material. The opinion describes the patent as relating generally to a waterproof and breathable membrane designed for use in materials such as outdoor apparel. It states that the claims employ active particles, such as activated carbon, in a membrane so as to improve the vapor transfer through the membrane. In the district court, Cocona asserted claims 1, 38, and 39. The opinion states that every claim Cocona asserted includes a substantively identical limitation: "a moisture vapor transmission rate from about 600 g/m2/day to about 11000 g/m2/day."
Claim 1, as the opinion quotes it, recites a water-proof breathable membrane comprising a substantially liquid-impermeable cured base material solution comprising a first thickness, and a plurality of active particles in contact with that solution. The active particles are capable of improving the transmission of vapor through the solution and comprise a second thickness. The first thickness is at least 2.5 times larger than the second thickness but less than an order of magnitude larger than the second thickness. The claim recites at least one removable encapsulant in an amount effective to prevent at least a substantial portion of the plurality of active particles from being deactivated prior to removal of the removable encapsulant. The removable encapsulant is removable to reactivate at least a portion of the active particles to improve the transmission of vapor through the water-proof breathable membrane. The membrane comprises a moisture vapor transmission rate from about 600 g/m2/day to about 11000 g/m2/day.
Claim 38 is the composition of claim 27, and claim 39 is the composition of claim 38. As the opinion quotes claim 27, it recites a water-proof composition comprising a liquid-impermeable breathable cured base material comprising a first thickness, and a plurality of active particles in contact with that material and comprising a second thickness. The first thickness comprises a thickness at least 2.5 times larger than the second thickness but less than an order of magnitude larger than the second thickness. The active particles improve the moisture vapor transport capacity of the composition. A moisture vapor transmission rate of the water-proof composition comprises from about 600 g/m2/day to about 11000 g/m2/day. Claim 38 adds at least one removable encapsulant in an amount effective to prevent at least a substantial portion of the active particles from being deactivated prior to removal of the removable encapsulant, and the removable encapsulant is removable to reactivate at least a portion of the active particles to improve the moisture vapor transport capacity of the composition. Claim 39 requires that the at least one removable encapsulant is selected from the group consisting of water-soluble surfactants, surfactants, salts, polymer salts, polyvinyl alcohols, waxes, photo-reactive materials, degradable materials, bio-degradable materials, ethoxylated acetylenic diols, starches, lubricants, glycols, corn starch, mineral spirits, organic solvents, paraffinic solvents, and any suitable combination thereof.
The earlier inter partes review
The opinion states that Cocona filed suit in the District of Colorado, alleging that VF Outdoor and Columbia infringed the claims of the '287 patent. VF Outdoor then petitioned the Patent Trial and Appeal Board for inter partes review of claims 27-28, 30, 32-33, and 35-39. The Board instituted an inter partes review and issued a final written decision finding all challenged claims other than claims 38 and 39 unpatentable as obvious. The Federal Circuit affirmed that decision. The opinion cites the affirmance as Cocona, Inc. v. VF Outdoor, LLC, 838 F. App'x 566, 567 (Fed. Cir. 2021). The opinion states that the suit then continued in the district court, with Cocona asserting claims 1, 38, and 39.
The moisture vapor transmission rate
The opinion states that moisture vapor transmission rate, which the opinion calls MVTR, measures "the rate at which moisture permeates" a material and is "generally measured in grams per square meter per day (g/m2/day)." The specification identifies three potential methods for measuring MVTR: the Mocon method, the upright method, and the inverted method. A footnote states that the patent says "Mocan" method, which the parties agree is a typographical error. The upright method is used to measure "low moisture contact (indirect liquid contact with the membrane)," and the inverted method is used to measure "high moisture contact (direct liquid contact with the membrane)." The opinion describes both as cup methods, run with water in a test dish that is either upright, with an air gap above the water, or inverted, with water resting directly on the material.
The opinion states that the parties agree ASTM E96-94 is a standardized testing protocol for measuring MVTR, and that the standard itself permits variability in testing conditions. For instance, it allows for testing at temperatures ranging from 23 to 38 degrees Centigrade and requires relative humidity "at 50 ± 2 %" or "90 ± 2 %," depending on "the desired application of the material to be tested." It directs that the test conditions selected should be those "that most closely approach the conditions of use" and warns that a material's MVTR measured "under one set of test conditions may not indicate the value under a different set of conditions."
The specification discusses only a single specific embodiment, labeled Example 1. As to that embodiment, the specification states: "MVTR by cup method may be measured according to Water method of ASTM E96-94 at 40 degrees Centigrade and 20% relative humidity over a 24 hour period. The cups typically have a 25 cm2 area opening. For the upright cup test, approximately 10 g of purified water is placed in the cup, while for the inverted cup, 20 g of purified water is used. The water used is typically ultrapure and deionized."
During claim construction, Cocona asked the district court to construe the MVTR limitation as "a moisture vapor transmission rate from about 600 g/m2/day to about 11000 g/m2/day determined according to ASTM E96 MVTR cup water test method at 40 degrees Centigrade and 20% relative humidity over a 24 hour period using the upright method for low moisture contact and the inverted method for high moisture contact." The district court rejected this proposal and instead determined that the three asserted claims were invalid as indefinite based on the MVTR limitation. After the district court entered judgment for VF Outdoor and Columbia, Cocona filed this timely appeal. The district court docket shows a February 5, 2025 order entering judgment in favor of VF Outdoor, LLC and Columbia Sportswear Company "pursuant to the Amended Order on Claim Construction" and "only on the asserted claims in these matters."
The intrinsic evidence
The opinion states the standard of review in these words: "Indefiniteness is a question of law that we review de novo." It cites Teva Pharms. USA, Inc. v. Sandoz, Inc., 789 F.3d 1335, 1341 (Fed. Cir. 2015). The court also reviews the district court's evaluation of the intrinsic evidence de novo, while "any factual findings about extrinsic evidence relevant to the question . . . are reviewed for clear error." It cites BASF Corp. v. Johnson Matthey Inc., 875 F.3d 1360, 1365 (Fed. Cir. 2017). While the ultimate question of indefiniteness is one of law, a party challenging a claim as indefinite must prove any fact critical to the finding of indefiniteness by clear and convincing evidence. The opinion cites Grace Instrument Indus. v. Chandler Instruments Co., 57 F.4th 1001, 1008 (Fed. Cir. 2023).
The sole issue presented, the opinion states, is whether the asserted claims, which all recite the same MVTR limitation, are invalid as indefinite under 35 U.S.C. § 112. The opinion quotes Nautilus, Inc. v. Biosig Instruments, Inc., 572 U.S. 898, 901 (2014): "[A] patent is invalid for indefiniteness if its claims, read in light of the specification delineating the patent, and the prosecution history, fail to inform, with reasonable certainty, those skilled in the art about the scope of the invention." Applying that standard, the court reached the same conclusion as the district court. It wrote: "the asserted claims are indefinite. Because the '287 patent lacks the "required guidance" as to how to measure MVTR in the context of the patent, clear and convincing evidence establishes that a person of ordinary skill in the art would not have reasonable certainty about the scope of the MVTR limitation and the asserted claims." It cites Dow Chem. Co. v. Nova Chems. Corp. (Can.), 803 F.3d 620, 634 (Fed. Cir. 2015).
On the claim language, the opinion states that a skilled artisan would understand that, for a product to practice the patent, it must have an MVTR falling within a specific range: about 600 g/m2/day to about 11,000 g/m2/day, and would also recognize that the claims provide no guidance whatsoever on how to measure MVTR. The court wrote that the claims "give no clue as to whether to use the upright or inverted cup method, or both, or what temperature and humidity conditions to set for whichever test one performs." It agreed with the district court that "the claim language itself recites a range of MVTRs without any details about how that MVTR must be calculated."
The specification, the opinion states, identifies the Mocon method, the upright cup method, and the inverted cup method. The opinion also cites a description of the specification as providing "a (non-exhaustive) list of recognized testing methods designed to test MVTR through a barrier film or sheet." The only direction the specification gives as to when to use each method is that the upright cup method is used for "low moisture contact" and the inverted cup method is used for "high moisture contact." The patent provides no indication of how to distinguish between "low" and "high" moisture contact. In describing Example 1, the specification identifies both the upright and inverted cup methods and points to optional temperature and humidity settings that "may be" used. The opinion quotes the district court: "the specification offers one set of test conditions that 'may be' used[] but . . . does not teach a [skilled artisan] to stick to those test conditions, and the claim language itself does not condition its claim to MVTR results obtained exclusively under those test conditions."
The opinion states that the parties dispute whether Mocon is a separate method or instead refers to test equipment used in the upright and inverted cup methods. The court wrote that it discerns no clear error in the district court's finding that Mocon is a third method, and that "our conclusion that the claims are indefinite would be the same even if only two different methods were identified in the patent, given the totality of the intrinsic (and extrinsic) evidence." The court wrote that it is not holding, as Cocona feared, that "because more than one method of measuring MVTR is contemplated by the '287 Patent, the MVTR Limitation is per se indefinite." The holding, the court wrote, is that "in the specific context of the '287 patent, the intrinsic evidence as a whole demonstrates, to a clear and convincing level, that a skilled artisan would be unable to determine with reasonable certainty the scope of the asserted claims."
Figure 2 and the provisional application
The opinion states that a skilled artisan would discover in the specification that the measured value of MVTR for any specific material may vary dramatically depending on whether the upright cup method or the inverted cup method is used. Figure 2, which the opinion reproduces, shows the results of using both methods on eight sample materials. The opinion states that the figure reports results that can differ by an order of magnitude, for the control and samples 1, 2, and 4, depending on whether the upright or inverted method is used.
Because the claimed range is so broad, about 600 to about 11,000 g/m2/day, the opinion states that none of the seven tested samples with active particles listed in Figure 2 are shown as having an MVTR that is simultaneously within that range using one method while also falling outside of that range using the other. The control sample, which the opinion describes as one lacking active particles, is shown to have an MVTR outside the claimed range, 470 g/m2/day, when measured by the upright cup method, yet an MVTR within the claimed range, 6,356 g/m2/day, when measured by the inverted cup method. The opinion states that these data would do nothing to reassure a skilled artisan as to how to discern the scope of the MVTR limitation.
The opinion then turns to the provisional patent application incorporated by reference in the specification. The patent, as the opinion quotes it, states: "This application claims the benefit under 35 U.S.C. § 119(e) of U.S. Provisional Application No. 60/799,426 filed May 9, 2006, which is hereby incorporated herein by reference in its entirety." The opinion states that a version of Figure 2, called Table 2, shows a tested sample containing activated carbon for which the upright and inverted cup methods lead to findings that a particular material both does and does not come within the claimed MVTR range. Table 2 includes sample 41-6-4, which is reported to have an MVTR of 1,394 g/m2/day, within the claimed range, using the inverted cup method, but just 223 g/m2/day, outside the claimed range, using the upright cup method.
The opinion states that Table 2 would leave a person of ordinary skill in the art lacking reasonable certainty as to the scope of the asserted claims. The results reported there show, in the opinion's quotation of Dow Chem. Co. v. Nova Chems. Corp. (Can.), that "the method chosen for calculating [MVTR] could affect whether or not a given product infringes the claims." The opinion states the rule in these words: "the existence of multiple methods leading to different results without guidance in the patent or the prosecution history as to which method should be used renders the claims indefinite." It also cites Teva Pharms. USA, Inc. v. Sandoz, Inc. for holding that "molecular weight" is indefinite where the intrinsic evidence did not teach which one of three known measurements was to be used and each could yield materially different results. The court wrote: "The claims at issue here then, based on all the evidence, are indefinite and, thus, invalid."
Extrinsic evidence
The opinion states that the intrinsic evidence already proves by clear and convincing evidence that the asserted claims are indefinite, and that the extrinsic evidence confirms this conclusion. The district court evaluated competing declarations from the expert for VF Outdoor and Columbia and from Cocona's expert. It was persuaded by the expert for VF Outdoor and Columbia, who opined that the '287 patent provides inadequate guidance to a skilled artisan as to which method and what temperature and humidity conditions to use when measuring MVTR. It dismissed Cocona's expert's competing testimony as "quintessentially conclusory" because the testimony contained no explanation as to how a skilled artisan would infer specific testing requirements from the patent's permissive language about how MVTR "may be measured." The Federal Circuit wrote that it finds no clear error in these findings, which bolster its conclusion that the asserted claims are indefinite.
Cocona argued that the district court should not have credited that declaration because it purportedly contradicts a declaration the same expert had previously given in the related inter partes review, where the expert opined that certain claims of the '287 patent were obvious. The opinion states that Cocona has failed to show that the district court clearly erred in relying on the declaration. In the inter partes review, the expert testified that particular prior art membranes exhibited MVTR values within the claimed range, and offered no testimony regarding how a skilled artisan looking at the '287 patent would understand the methods and conditions that should be used to measure MVTR. The opinion cites Intel Corp. v. Qualcomm Inc., 21 F.4th 801, 813 (Fed. Cir. 2021): "Importantly, it is not always impossible to adjudicate a prior-art challenge, one way or the other, just because some aspect of a claim renders the claim indefinite."
Arguments the court rejected
Cocona argued that the test results reported in Figure 2 of the patent and Table 2 of the provisional are irrelevant because the control sample and sample 41-6-4 do not practice the asserted claims. The opinion states that, even assuming those premises are correct, the court disagreed with Cocona's conclusion. Where a patent fails to specify the appropriate method of measurement to use, and different methods could result in the same item both meeting and not meeting a claim limitation, that fact is relevant to indefiniteness, even if the item being tested may not fully embody all limitations of the claim. A footnote states that VF Outdoor and Columbia contend that sample 41-6-4 does practice the claims.
The opinion rejects Cocona's reliance on Presidio Components, Inc. v. American Technical Ceramics Corp., 875 F.3d 1369 (Fed. Cir. 2017), and Ethicon Endo-Surgery, Inc. v. Covidien, Inc., 796 F.3d 1312 (Fed. Cir. 2015). In those cases, the court wrote, it rejected indefiniteness challenges because the patent-in-suit presented a single, established measurement method for insertion loss, or because the specification provided sufficient guidance as to which of several methods for measuring clamping pressure was to be used. The opinion states that the situation here is materially different. The '287 patent, the court wrote, provides no reasonable certainty as to which of its multiple disclosed methods is to be used or what testing conditions are to be employed under whichever method is chosen. Neither Presidio nor Ethicon, the court wrote, suggests that claims like these should survive an indefiniteness challenge.
Cocona argued that the district court's findings based on the ASTM E96-94 standard are clearly erroneous because they contradict the '287 patent's disclosures. On Cocona's account, the patent specifies that MVTR is to be measured at a temperature of 40 degrees Centigrade and relative humidity of 20%, so any different values that may be permitted by the ASTM E96-94 standard are irrelevant. The opinion states that this argument fails. The patent discloses 40 degrees Centigrade and relative humidity of 20% as non-mandatory examples of testing conditions. The opinion states that the '287 patent does not require, nor even suggest, that one must always test at 40 degrees Centigrade and relative humidity of 20% to evaluate whether the claimed MVTR range is met.
Cocona also argued that the district court applied the wrong legal standard for indefiniteness, and that the claims were held indefinite only because they do not contain "mandatory guidelines" or "imperative language." The opinion states that Cocona is correct that patents containing permissive language and discretionary words may survive indefiniteness challenges. It cites Akamai Techs., Inc. v. MediaPointe, Inc., 159 F.4th 1370, 1378 (Fed. Cir. 2025): "Language of degree . . . is indefinite unless, when read in light of the specification and the prosecution history, it provides objective boundaries for those of skill in the art." The opinion states that the district court articulated the proper legal standard for indefiniteness and applied it to the totality of the evidence. The Federal Circuit was not persuaded that the district court's references to "mandatory guidelines" and "imperative language" demonstrate that the district court held the patent to too stringent of a standard for definiteness. The opinion states that the court again discerns no error. The opinion states that Cocona's remaining arguments are unpersuasive. Because the court agrees with the district court's judgment that the asserted claims are invalid for indefiniteness, it affirms.
What to watch next
Watch for any petition for rehearing and for issuance of the mandate in Nos. 2025-1458 and 2025-1462. The case can end at any time, including by settlement or voluntary dismissal.