The decision

On November 16, 2026, the United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit decided Traxcell Technologies, LLC v. Cellco Partnership, Nos. 2025-1496 and 2025-1683. The panel was Judges Dyk, Chen, and Stoll. Judge Dyk wrote the opinion. The appeals are from the United States District Court for the Western District of Texas in No. 6:24-mc-00613-ADA, Judge Alan D. Albright. The court's opinions-and-orders listing marks the opinion precedential. The court wrote: "We conclude that we have appellate jurisdiction. But because we determine the District Court for the Western District of Texas did not have jurisdiction, we vacate the judgment and remand with instructions to dismiss for lack of jurisdiction." The conclusion states: "We conclude that we have appellate jurisdiction over Traxcell's case because it arises under federal patent law. However, we conclude the district court did not have jurisdiction over Traxcell's independent action. Accordingly, we vacate the district court's judgment and remand with instructions to dismiss the case for want of jurisdiction." The disposition is "VACATED AND REMANDED." The opinion awards "Costs to Verizon."

The fee judgment

The opinion states that Traxcell Technologies, LLC, the owner of U.S. Patent Nos. 8,977,284, 9,510,320, 9,642,024, and 9,549,388, filed suit on October 31, 2017, in the Eastern District of Texas, alleging that Verizon Wireless Personal Communications, LP infringed those patents. The '284 patent, titled Machine for providing a dynamic data base of geographic location information for a plurality of wireless devices and process for making same, issued on March 10, 2015. The '320 patent, titled Machine for providing a dynamic database of geographic location information for a plurality of wireless devices and process for making same, issued on November 29, 2016. The '024 patent, titled Mobile wireless communications system and method with corrective action responsive to communications fault detection, issued on May 2, 2017. The '388 patent, titled Mobile wireless device providing off-line and on-line geographic navigation information, issued on January 17, 2017. The opinion's footnote states that the appellee here is Cellco Partnership, dba Verizon Wireless, and that the opinion refers collectively to that appellee and to the defendant in the 2017 case as "Verizon."

A January 30, 2025 order in the Western District states that the 2017 suit was Traxcell Technologies, LLC v. Verizon Commc'ns et al., No. 2:17-cv-00721 (E.D. Tex.), and that it was consolidated with three other cases that Traxcell filed the same day against other telecommunications companies, under No. 2:17-cv-00718 (E.D. Tex.). The November 16 opinion cites the Federal Circuit's October 12, 2021 decision as Traxcell Technologies, LLC v. Sprint Communications Co. (Traxcell I), 15 F.4th 1121 (Fed. Cir. 2021). That decision is the opinion in Nos. 2020-1852 and 2020-1854, an appeal from No. 2:17-cv-00718-RWS-RSP, Judge Robert Schroeder, III. It describes the four patents as related to self-optimizing wireless networks and to navigation technology, and states that all four share a specification and a 2001 priority date. The November 16 opinion states that Traxcell I affirmed the judgment of indefiniteness and noninfringement. The November 16 opinion states that, at claim construction, the Eastern District held some asserted claims indefinite, and that on April 15, 2020, the district court granted summary judgment of noninfringement to Verizon on the remaining claims. The January 30 order states that on April 15, 2020, Judge Schroeder adopted a magistrate judge's recommendation to grant summary judgment of noninfringement and, the same day, entered final judgment dismissing Traxcell's claims against Verizon with prejudice.

The November 16 opinion states that on December 22, 2022, the Eastern District awarded attorneys' fees to Verizon under 35 U.S.C. § 285 and ordered Traxcell to pay within thirty days. The January 30 order states that Judge Schroeder agreed the case was exceptional because "Traxcell continued to pursue theories that it knew or should have known were baseless." Traxcell appealed, contending that the district court improperly found that Traxcell knew or should have known its infringement theories were baseless, and not arguing that the court lacked jurisdiction to award fees. The Federal Circuit affirmed in a Rule 36 judgment, Traxcell Technologies, LLC v. AT&T Inc. (Traxcell II), No. 23-1246, 2023 WL 4503520 (Fed. Cir. July 13, 2023). The January 30 order states that Traxcell petitioned for rehearing en banc, that the Federal Circuit denied that petition, and that the Supreme Court denied certiorari on January 8, 2024. The November 16 opinion states that Traxcell then filed an emergency motion for relief from judgment in the Eastern District, arguing for the first time that the Traxcell I mandate prohibited a later fee award, and that the motion is still pending. The January 30 order states that the emergency motion was filed on September 6, 2024, under Rule 60(b)(4), in No. 2:17-cv-00718.

The Western District action

The opinion states that Traxcell filed an independent action in the Western District of Texas, an equitable cause of action preserved under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 60(d)(1), making substantially the same arguments as in its emergency motion in the Eastern District. On December 2, 2024, Traxcell moved for a temporary restraining order and a preliminary injunction. An order filed December 5, 2024 denied that motion. The order holds that the temporary-restraining-order request did not satisfy Rule 65(b) and that the preliminary-injunction request was premature because the defendant had not been served. The January 30, 2025 order, signed by Judge Alan D. Albright, denies the motion filed December 5, 2024, ECF No. 9, which sought to enjoin Cellco Partnership, dba Verizon Wireless, from enforcing the Eastern District fee order. The January 30 order states: "In sum, the Court finds Traxcell has not made a showing that it is substantially likely to prevail on the merits of the case or that it will suffer irreparable harm in the absence of an injunction." It also states: "Traxcell has no reasonable likelihood of prevailing in this case because the Verizon Fee Order is not void under Rule 60(b)(4)." The November 16 opinion quotes that finding as "Traxcell has no reasonable likelihood of prevailing in this case because the Verizon [fee award] is not void."

On February 24, 2025, the parties filed a joint stipulation for final judgment. It asks the court to enter final judgment against Traxcell's sole cause of action under Rule 60(d)(1), with prejudice, subject to Traxcell's right to appeal, with Traxcell to take nothing and Verizon as the prevailing party. The stipulation uses Verizon to mean Cellco Partnership. The docket lists a judgment filed February 26, 2025, and a notice of appeal filed the same day. The opinion states that the Western District entered judgment denying Traxcell's requested relief on the merits, that the parties stipulated to final judgment against the independent-action claim, subject to Traxcell's right to appeal, and that Traxcell timely appealed.

Appellate jurisdiction

Verizon argued that the Federal Circuit lacked jurisdiction because Traxcell's right to relief depends only on non-patent issues, and because the appeal requires only application of the mandate rule, not resolution of a substantial question of federal patent law. The court disagreed. It quoted 28 U.S.C. § 1295(a)(1), covering an appeal from a final decision of a district court "in any civil action arising under . . . any Act of Congress relating to patents or plant variety protection." The court wrote: "Traxcell's action is, on its face, an action to set aside a judgment for attorneys' fees under 35 U.S.C. § 285, a provision of the Patent Act." It treated the Western District action as similar to a declaratory judgment that Traxcell is not liable for attorneys' fees, and it wrote: "We would have jurisdiction over a declaratory judgment action challenging a fee award under § 285. This case is akin to a declaratory judgment action of no liability."

The Western District lacked jurisdiction

The opinion states that relief under Rule 60(d) is a question of Fifth Circuit law, and that the court had to consider the Western District's jurisdiction although the parties had not raised it. Quoting United States v. Beggerly, the opinion states that "an independent action should be available only to prevent a grave miscarriage of justice." The court wrote: "We conclude first that the Western District of Texas lacked jurisdiction." It wrote that Traxcell's motion "does not come close to presenting a case that qualifies as a permissible independent action under Beggerly." It wrote that a district court may consider attorneys' fees separately after a final judgment on the merits, that the Federal Circuit routinely reviews fee awards under § 285 after a merits decision, and that "The frivolous theory that the Eastern District of Texas lacked jurisdiction to award attorneys' fees does not come close to satisfying the grave-miscarriage-of-justice standard." The court stated the rule in these words: "Under Beggerly, a district court lacks jurisdiction over an independent action if the allegations of the complaint fail to meet the high standard for an independent action." It also wrote that Traxcell did not raise a jurisdictional argument in its earlier fees proceeding, and it quoted the rule that "A party that has had an opportunity to litigate the question of subject-matter jurisdiction may not . . . reopen that question in a collateral attack upon an adverse judgment."

The court stated a second ground in these words: "We also conclude that the Western District of Texas lacked jurisdiction in this case because one district court may not entertain an independent action to set aside another district court's judgment that has been affirmed on appeal, whether or not the Beggerly standard is satisfied." The opinion states that an independent action filed in the court that rendered the judgment is ancillary to that judgment, and that the Supreme Court declined to decide whether an independent action may be brought in a different court. It then wrote: "Even if the jurisdiction of the second federal court exists, it cannot extend to this case." Traxcell's action, the court wrote, "seeks to countermand a judgment already affirmed by this court." The court added: "A district court has no jurisdiction over an independent action or Rule 60 cause of action seeking to overturn an order of a court of appeals."

What to watch next

Watch for any petition for rehearing and for issuance of the mandate in Nos. 2025-1496 and 2025-1683, and for the Western District of Texas to dismiss the case for want of jurisdiction, as the opinion instructs. The opinion states that Traxcell's emergency motion in the Eastern District is still pending. The case can end at any time, including by settlement or voluntary dismissal.