The appeal
On November 18, 2026, the United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit decided Edge Systems LLC v. Cartessa Aesthetics, LLC, Nos. 2025-1119 and 2025-1190, Document 62. The opinion states: "NOTE: This disposition is nonprecedential." The panel was Judges Prost, Hughes, and Cunningham. Judge Prost wrote the opinion. The appeals are from the United States District Court for the Eastern District of New York in No. 2:20-cv-06082-GRB-ST, Judge Gary R. Brown. Edge Systems LLC is the plaintiff-appellant. Cartessa Aesthetics, LLC is the defendant-cross-appellant. The opinion states that the court has jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. § 1295(a)(1).
The '052 patent and the suit
The opinion states that Edge sued Cartessa in the Eastern District of New York in December 2020, alleging that Cartessa infringed U.S. Patent No. 9,550,052 (the '052 patent) via the accused Skinwave system. The '052 patent is titled Console system for the treatment of skin, and it was granted on January 24, 2017. The opinion states that the '052 patent concerns a system for skin treatment. It treats claim 1 as representative and quotes these elements: "a console including a manifold, the manifold being in fluid communication with a first fluid container and at least a second fluid container ... configured to contain a treatment material for a skin treatment procedure, wherein the treatment material comprises a liquid"; "wherein the manifold is configured to control a flow of treatment material from the first fluid container and at least the second fluid container through the supply conduit"; and "wherein the system is configured to permit a user to select the treatment material from the first fluid container or the at least second fluid container to be delivered through the supply conduit to the handpiece assembly."
The opinion states that Edge also brought infringement claims as to other patents, and that those claims were later dismissed in accordance with a joint stipulation of the parties.
Summary judgment and the final judgment
The district court granted summary judgment of noninfringement and of no invalidity. Edge Sys. LLC v. Cartessa Aesthetics, LLC, No. 20-CV-6082, 2023 WL 3847138 (E.D.N.Y. June 6, 2023). On noninfringement, the court concluded that, "however one might construe the functions of a manifold, Edge cannot prove that the Skinwave device contains one." The opinion states that the district court reproduced Edge's annotated image of the Skinwave system, with a white box labeled as the manifold, and that the district court observed that Edge did not meaningfully dispute Cartessa's argument that Edge's expert "remained unaware of [the white box's] internal structure and composition, did not detach [it] from the console, did no destructive testing and could not remember even touching [it]."
The opinion states that the district court entered final judgment in accordance with a stipulation of the parties. The docket records a stipulation of dismissal and request to enter final judgment, entered October 11, 2024, and a judgment ordered by Judge Gary R. Brown on October 15, 2024. That judgment states that judgment is entered in favor of Edge and against Cartessa that claim 1 of U.S. Patent No. 9,550,052 is not invalid; that judgment is entered in favor of Cartessa and against Edge as to the claims of infringement of claims 1-17 of U.S. Patent No. 9,550,052 as set forth in Edge's complaint; that judgment is entered in favor of Edge of no unclean hands as to U.S. Patent Nos. 6,641,591, 8,066,716, 8,337,513, 9,775,646, and 9,550,052; that Edge's claims against Cartessa alleging infringement of U.S. Patent No. 9,775,646 are dismissed with prejudice; that Edge's claims against Cartessa alleging infringement of U.S. Patent Nos. 6,641,591, 8,066,716, and 8,337,513 are dismissed without prejudice; and that each party will bear its own attorneys' fees and costs. The entry states that no claims are remaining and directs the clerk to enter that final judgment pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 58.
Edge's notice of appeal, entered October 18, 2024, and Cartessa's notice of cross-appeal, entered November 12, 2024, are each taken from the judgment and the summary-judgment order. The opinion states that Edge appeals as to noninfringement, and that if the court were to disturb that judgment, Cartessa cross-appeals as to no invalidity.
Noninfringement
The opinion states that the parties had agreed that "manifold" did not require construction and should be given its plain and ordinary meaning, and that the summary-judgment briefing exposed a disagreement over that meaning. Cartessa argued that the claimed manifold must be able to "combin[e] multiple sources into a single outlet," that is, draw fluid from multiple containers simultaneously so that they are "intermix[ed] during use." Under that view, the opinion states, it is undisputed that the Skinwave system does not satisfy the elements of claim 1. Edge argued that the claimed manifold was "a component with one outlet and several inlets, for connecting with other pipes."
The court wrote: "We disagree that construing 'manifold' was unnecessary." Under Edge's construction, "a closed space with several inlet pipes and one outlet," the court wrote that it believed a reasonable jury could find the relevant claim element or elements satisfied, at least with reference to an image from the district court's order. The opinion states that the precise phrasing of Edge's proposed construction has not been entirely uniform throughout this litigation, and that the court deems any differences among the relevant proposals immaterial for purposes of resolving this appeal. Under Cartessa's construction, the opinion states, Edge concedes that the Skinwave system does not satisfy the elements of claim 1.
The court vacated the summary judgment of noninfringement and remanded for the district court to resolve the claim-construction dispute in the first instance, citing UTTO Inc. v. Metrotech Corp., 119 F.4th 984, 995-96 (Fed. Cir. 2024). It rejected Cartessa's argument that Edge waived or forfeited a preferred construction by failing to raise it during claim construction. The opinion states that, as Edge recounts and as Cartessa does not meaningfully or persuasively dispute, the divergence between the parties' understanding of "manifold" became apparent only as of the deposition of Cartessa's expert, which came after claim construction but before summary-judgment proceedings, and that Edge then raised the issue in its summary-judgment filings. The court cited GE Lighting Sols., LLC v. AgiLight, Inc., 750 F.3d 1304, 1310 (Fed. Cir. 2014).
The court declined to take up, in the first instance, two of the other grounds Cartessa urged for affirmance: that the Skinwave system also lacks the claimed "fluid communication," and that Cartessa is not a direct infringer because, in Cartessa's view, the '052 patent's claims do not cover the Skinwave system "as sold by Cartessa; rather, they claim a system that is only completed and brought into existence, if at all," by an end user. The opinion states that on remand the district court may consider whether and how to resolve those arguments. In remanding, the court noted two principles that may become relevant. First, a court is not bound to accept either party's preferred construction, citing Bancorp Servs., L.L.C. v. Sun Life Assurance Co. of Can. (U.S.), 687 F.3d 1266, 1274 (Fed. Cir. 2012); the court compared Vivid Techs., Inc. v. Am. Sci. & Eng'g, Inc., 200 F.3d 795, 803 (Fed. Cir. 1999), which observed that claim terms need be construed "only to the extent necessary to resolve the controversy." Second, the court wrote: "to whatever extent the proper construction of 'manifold' requires knowledge of internal structure or functionality (as opposed to something externally observable or provable), Edge's evidentiary limitations will likely be that much more relevant."
No invalidity
The court affirmed the summary judgment of no invalidity. It wrote that no reasonable jury could find by clear and convincing evidence that Shadduck discloses a system configured to let a user "select the treatment material [comprising a liquid] from the first fluid container or the at least second fluid container," as claim 1 of the '052 patent requires. Shadduck is U.S. Patent No. 6,162,232. The opinion states that it is unclear whether the district court's order relied on this ground, and that Edge believes the district court did not reach it. The court wrote that it may affirm a summary judgment "on a ground supported in the record but not addressed by the district court" if the court concludes that there is no genuine issue as to a material fact, citing Aqua-Tex Indus., Inc. v. Techniche Sols., 479 F.3d 1320, 1328 (Fed. Cir. 2007).
The opinion states that Cartessa relies primarily on Shadduck's trigger mechanism. As the court describes that disclosure, the trigger lets a user select between gas and gas-plus-liquid. Claim 1's selectable element, the court wrote, requires letting a user select between "liquid" and "liquid" treatment materials. The court concluded that no reasonable jury could find by clear and convincing evidence that Shadduck discloses claim 1's selectable element, and it affirmed the summary judgment of no invalidity.
The disposition
The conclusion states that the court vacates the summary judgment of noninfringement and remands for further proceedings, and that it affirms the summary judgment of no invalidity. The disposition line is "VACATED-IN-PART, AFFIRMED-IN-PART, AND REMANDED." The opinion awards costs to Edge.
What to watch next
The November 18, 2026 opinion remands for the district court to resolve the claim-construction dispute over "manifold" in the first instance. On remand, the district court may also consider whether and how to resolve Cartessa's "fluid communication" and direct-infringement arguments. The case can end at any time, including by settlement or voluntary dismissal.