The decision
On November 17, 2026, the Patent Trial and Appeal Board entered Paper 48 in Straumann USA, LLC v. Smart Denture Conversions, LLC, IPR2025-00956, a final written decision on U.S. Patent 11,937,992 B1. Administrative Patent Judges Michael J. Fitzpatrick, Eric C. Jeschke, and Ryan H. Flax sat on the panel, and Judge Flax wrote the decision. The caption describes the paper as a judgment and final written decision determining all challenged claims unpatentable and granting the petitioner's motion to exclude, and it cites 35 U.S.C. 318(a) and 37 C.F.R. 42.64 and 42.71.
The order states that, on inter partes review of claims 1-12 of the '992 patent, the challenged claims are unpatentable. It directs parties seeking judicial review to comply with the notice and service requirements of 37 C.F.R. 90.2. It grants the motion to exclude, and it excludes from evidence Exhibits 2010 and 2021 and the items identified as "Voices from the Bench" and "Product Talk." The conclusion states that all challenged claims are unpatentable under 35 U.S.C. 102 and 103.
Straumann USA, LLC is the petitioner. The petition, as the decision recites it, names Straumann USA, LLC and two of its affiliates as the real parties in interest. Smart Denture Conversions, LLC is the patent owner and identifies itself as the real party in interest. The patent is titled "Screw-attached pick-up dental coping system and methods." It issued on March 26, 2024, from U.S. Application 18/328,730, filed June 3, 2023.
The petition is Paper 2, filed April 30, 2025, and challenges claims 1-12. Patent owner filed a preliminary response, Paper 9, on August 29, 2025. The Board instituted trial on November 21, 2025, in Paper 12, on claims 1-12 and on each ground of challenge in the petition. Patent owner's response, Paper 26, was filed March 13, 2026. The petitioner's reply, Paper 33, was filed June 10, 2026, and patent owner's sur-reply, Paper 38, was filed July 22, 2026. A hearing was held on September 9, 2026, at which the parties presented oral argument in this proceeding and in related matter PGR2025-00054. The transcript is Paper 47.
The Board found that the '992 patent is not entitled to an effective filing date earlier than its June 3, 2023 filing date. It found that the earlier applications do not provide written description support, under 35 U.S.C. 112(a), for the genus of temporary-screw threads shaped differently from the definitive screw's threads recited in claims 1 and 9, and it applied Tronzo v. Biomet, Inc., 156 F.3d 1154 (Fed. Cir. 1998). It found that no dependent claim is accorded an earlier effective filing date. It found that U.S. Patent 11,311,354 B2 (Kofford), issued April 26, 2022, from U.S. Application 16/596,361, filed October 8, 2019, is prior art, and that Kofford discloses a specific embodiment within the scope of the claims.
- Ground 1: claims 1-6, 8, 9, 11, and 12, anticipated under 35 U.S.C. 102(a)(1) by Kofford, shown unpatentable.
- Ground 2: claims 4, 7, and 12, obvious under 35 U.S.C. 103 over Kofford and Poovey (U.S. Patent Application Publication 2016/0045290 A1), shown unpatentable.
- Ground 3: claims 7 and 10, anticipated under 35 U.S.C. 102(a)(1) by Kofford, shown unpatentable.
- Ground 4: claims 1, 3, 5-7, and 9-12, obvious under 35 U.S.C. 103 over Bernhard (U.S. Patent Application Publication 2017/0202649 A1), Poovey, and Gracco, shown unpatentable.
- Ground 5: claims 4 and 8, obvious under 35 U.S.C. 103 over Bernhard, Poovey, Gracco, and Derey (WO 2013/030839 A1), shown unpatentable.
- Ground 6: claim 2, obvious under 35 U.S.C. 103 over Bernhard, Poovey, Gracco, and Ruetschi (DE 3808238 A1, cited to a certified English translation), shown unpatentable.
The decision's summary table lists claims 1-12 as shown unpatentable in the overall outcome. The Board adopted the petitioner's definition of a person of ordinary skill and gave the claim terms their ordinary meaning, with no express construction. It gave no weight to patent owner's evidence of objective indicia of non-obviousness, which patent owner presented as long-felt need, copying, and industry praise.
The decision states that the petitioner must prove unpatentability by a preponderance of the evidence under 35 U.S.C. 316(e), and that this burden never shifts to the patent owner. A footnote to the conclusion draws patent owner's attention to the April 2019 Notice Regarding Options for Amendments by Patent Owner Through Reissue or Reexamination During a Pending AIA Trial Proceeding, 84 Fed. Reg. 16,654 (Apr. 22, 2019), should patent owner wish to pursue amendment of the challenged claims in a reissue or reexamination proceeding. It reminds patent owner that it must notify the Board of any such filing in updated mandatory notices under 37 C.F.R. 42.8(a)(3) and (b)(2).
The patent and the claims
The decision states that the patent relates to a temporary alignment system and method for holding a dental coping to an implant abutment, using the same abutment threads that are used for definitive attachment. It describes temporary fasteners that orient and hold a coping, and a pick-up of the aligned coping in a closed-tray impression process without unscrewing the temporary fastener. The face of the patent, as the decision recites it, claims continuation status to Application 17/691,108, filed March 9, 2022, and to Application 16/596,361, filed October 8, 2019, now U.S. Patent 11,311,354, and claims the benefit of provisional applications 62/818,082 (March 13, 2019), 62/774,402 (December 3, 2018), and 62/742,942 (October 9, 2018).
Independent claim 1, which the decision reproduces, is a dental system with an implant abutment having threads; a definitive screw with a tool interface and distal threads that engage the abutment threads; a coping with an aperture larger than the definitive screw's distal post and smaller than its head; and a temporary screw whose proximal head is wider than the coping aperture and whose distal shaft has "threads in a pattern that is shaped differently from a pattern of the threads of the definitive screw." The temporary screw is rotatable into the abutment to a predetermined torque so that the head holds the coping in alignment, and "an axial force in a proximal direction from pick-up processing releases the coping and the temporary screw from the implant abutment."
The decision states that independent claim 9 is substantially similar to claim 1, and that its written-description finding for claim 1 also applies to claim 9's temporary screw, which has "a male threading profile that is different from the male threading profile of the shaft of the definitive screw." Claims 2-8 depend from claim 1. Claims 10-12 depend from claim 9.
Institution
Patent owner requested discretionary denial in Paper 8. On September 19, 2025, the Acting Director referred the case to the Board. That referral is Paper 11. The institution decision, Paper 12, is captioned as a decision granting institution under 35 U.S.C. 314. The panel found a reasonable likelihood that the petitioner would prevail in showing at least one challenged claim unpatentable, addressing claim 1 under Grounds 1 and 4, and it instituted review of claims 1-12 on each ground of challenge in the petition. The institution decision states that its findings are preliminary and do not reflect a final determination of any fact or on the patentability of the claims.
Ordinary skill and claim construction
The Board rejected patent owner's proposed definition of a person of ordinary skill and accepted the petitioner's. Under that definition, the person of ordinary skill would have at least a bachelor's degree in mechanical engineering, biomedical engineering, materials science engineering, or an equivalent degree, plus at least five years of experience working with dental implants and prostheses, including fasteners used to connect prostheses, implants, and related components. Less formal education with commensurately more practical experience, or the reverse, could also qualify. The Board stated that it applied the same definition at institution.
The Board construed the claims under 37 C.F.R. 42.100(b), giving terms their ordinary and customary meaning. At institution it construed no term expressly. In the response, patent owner argued that the institution decision had implicitly and incorrectly construed "a distal shaft portion with threads in a pattern that is shaped differently from a pattern of the threads of the definitive screw" and "axial force." The Board stated that patent owner proposed no definition of either phrase. It found both phrases clear on their face, including the direction of the axial force that releases the coping and the temporary screw, and it concluded that no express construction was required.
Priority and written description
The Kofford grounds depended on priority. The Board found that the differently shaped thread limitation in claims 1 and 9 is a genus. It found that the priority applications describe one temporary-screw embodiment with threads different from a definitive screw's threads: the Figure 75 screw, with asymmetrical, inclined buttress threads on a screw with a slot, which is screwed in and then pulled out axially. The Board found that neither the '992 patent nor any priority application discusses differing a temporary screw's threads from a definitive screw's threads, and that the record does not support the described thread style as sufficiently representative of the claimed genus.
The Board found Tronzo pertinent and controlling on this record. It described Tronzo as holding that a parent application which described only one shape of acetabular cup, a conical cup, did not support later claims reciting the cup generically in terms of its shape, so the later patent was not entitled to that priority. The Board noted differences, including that the priority applications here do not expressly distinguish the Figure 75 thread from other thread shapes, and it found the facts so similar that the result should be the same. It also relied on the rule, which it drew from Ariad Pharmaceuticals, Inc. v. Eli Lilly & Co., 598 F.3d 1336 (Fed. Cir. 2010), that a description that merely renders the invention obvious does not satisfy the written description requirement. The decision states that the AIA versions of sections 102, 103, and 112 apply because the '992 patent was filed after September 16, 2012, and the earliest possible effective filing date is after March 16, 2013.
The Board then considered the dependent claims and found that none can be accorded priority. For claims 2, 4, 6, 7, 8, and 12, it found that the added limitations do not further define how the temporary screw's threads differ from the definitive screw's threads and do not affect priority. For claims 3, 5, 10, and 11, which add limitations about asymmetric threads, thread contact area or volume, pitch angle, or flank angle, it was not persuaded that any earlier effective filing date should be accorded. It stated that the only support offered for an earlier date for those claims was testimony from patent owner's declarant, which the Board excluded. The Board concluded that Kofford is prior art to the challenged claims.
Anticipation by Kofford
The Board found that Kofford has the same disclosure as the '992 patent. It found that this disclosure does not describe the full genus of the different-thread limitations for purposes of 35 U.S.C. 112(a), but that it does disclose a specific embodiment within the scope of the claims, so as to anticipate them. It found no gaps in the petitioner's mapping of each challenged claim to Kofford. Patent owner's opposition was that Kofford is not prior art because the claims should be accorded priority to the earlier applications, and the Board rejected that position.
Ground 1 covers claims 1-6, 8, 9, 11, and 12. Ground 3 covers claims 7 and 10. Claim 7 adds that the temporary screw's threads deform during release from the implant abutment. Claim 10 adds that at least some threads of the temporary screw have a pitch angle different from that of the abutment's female threads and the definitive screw's threads. The Board found that the petitioner showed under Ground 1 that claims 1-6, 8, 9, 11, and 12 are anticipated by Kofford, and under Ground 3 that claims 7 and 10 are anticipated by Kofford.
Obviousness over Kofford and Poovey
Ground 2 challenges claims 4, 7, and 12 as obvious over Kofford and Poovey, U.S. Patent Application Publication 2016/0045290 A1, published February 18, 2016 (Ex. 1005). The Board treated the ground as an alternative or a supplement to the anticipation grounds. Poovey is added for a polymeric temporary screw and for threads that deform when the screw is pulled out of an abutment. The decision states that there is no dispute that Poovey is prior art. The Board found that a person of ordinary skill would have had a reason to combine the teachings, with a reasonable expectation of success, because Poovey teaches a flexible temporary screw that can be rotated into an abutment and pulled out without unscrewing, which would make Kofford's temporary screw easier to pull out. It found that patent owner did not dispute that the combination teaches the subject matter of claims 4, 7, and 12, and it found those claims obvious.
Obviousness over Bernhard, Poovey, and Gracco
Ground 4 challenges claims 1, 3, 5-7, and 9-12 as obvious over Bernhard, Poovey, and Gracco. Bernhard is U.S. Patent Application Publication 2017/0202649 A1, published July 20, 2017 (Ex. 1003). Gracco is an article, "Effects of thread shape on the pullout strength of Miniscrews," 142(2) American Journal of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics 186-90 (2012) (Ex. 1006). The combination the petitioner asserted, and that the Board addressed, modifies the threads of a Bernhard fastener by using an asymmetric buttress thread from Gracco and flexible threads from Poovey, so that a temporary screw can hold securely and still be pulled out without being unscrewed. The Board found no gaps in the petitioner's identification of each claim limitation in the combination, and it found that the petitioner identified a reason with rational underpinning to combine the references, with a reasonable expectation of success.
Ground 5 adds Derey, WO 2013/030839 A1, published March 7, 2013 (Ex. 1008), for a hollow shaft portion in claims 4 and 8. Ground 6 adds Ruetschi for claim 2's torque driver. The decision cites Ruetschi to a certified English translation (Ex. 1022) of DE 3808238 A1 (Ex. 1021). The Board concluded that the petitioner showed under Grounds 4, 5, and 6 that the challenged claims would have been obvious.
Patent owner relied on long-felt need, copying, and industry praise as objective indicia. The Board gave each no weight. It found no nexus, presumed or otherwise, between any of that evidence and the claims. On long-felt need, it found that no one articulated the asserted need before this proceeding. On copying, it found that no evidence was cited for the assertions that the parties' products compete or that the petitioner's product infringes. On industry praise, it found that "Voices" and "Product Talk" are not of record, described most of the remaining statements as the parties' own statements about their products, and found no evidence that a case report about the petitioner's product concerned a product that embodies any claim of the '992 patent.
The motion to exclude
The motion to exclude is Paper 40. The opposition is Paper 41. The reply is Paper 43. The Board granted the motion in its entirety. Exhibits 2010 and 2021 are declarations from patent owner's declarant. The Board found that the record, including the declarant's curriculum vitae (Ex. 2019) and the declarations, shows no relevant education in or experience working with dental implants and prostheses. Applying Kyocera Senco Industrial Tools Inc. v. United States International Trade Commission, 22 F.4th 1369 (Fed. Cir. 2022), it quoted the Federal Circuit's statement that a witness offering expert testimony from the perspective of a skilled artisan, such as on claim construction, validity, or infringement, must have at least ordinary skill in the art. The decision states that patent owner indicated at the hearing that no part of the testimony could be salvaged, because it was offered through the lens of a person of ordinary skill. The Board excluded both exhibits and did not consider them.
The Board also excluded "Voices from the Bench" and "Product Talk." Patent owner cited them in its response at pages 76-77, and no related exhibits were identified or submitted. The Board rejected the argument that filing evidence is merely a better practice. It cited 37 C.F.R. 42.6(c), which requires each exhibit to be filed with the first document in which it is cited, and it excluded the two items to the extent they could be considered evidence.
Related proceedings the papers identify
Patent owner's mandatory notices, as the decision quotes them, identify PGR2025-00054 as the petitioner's petition for post-grant review of U.S. Patent 12,156,781. The same notices identify related U.S. Patent 12,156,781, issued December 3, 2024, from Application 18/424,696; U.S. Patent 12,318,266, issued June 3, 2025, from Application 18/829,490; U.S. Patent 12,318,265, issued June 3, 2025, from Application 17/691,108; U.S. Patent 11,311,354, issued April 26, 2022, from Application 16/596,361; and Application 18/827,656, filed September 6, 2024.
Paper 46 in IPR2025-00956, as the final written decision quotes it, states that the petitioner has petitioned for post-grant review of U.S. Patent 12,551,319 in PGR2026-00070, and that U.S. Patent 12,551,319 issued from Application 18/827,656, filed September 6, 2024.
The District of Delaware case
The petition, as the decision recites it, states that Smart Denture Conversions sued Straumann for alleged infringement of the '992 patent on April 23, 2024, in Smart Denture Conversions, LLC v. Straumann USA, LLC, No. 1:24-cv-00507 (D. Del.), served the complaint on June 10, 2024, and filed a supplemental complaint on February 4, 2025, alleging infringement of U.S. Patent 12,156,781, which the petition says issued from a continuation of the '992 patent.
A stipulation filed in that case on November 24, 2025, states that Straumann filed its request for inter partes review of the '992 patent on April 30, 2025, and its request for post-grant review of the '781 patent on June 4, 2025, that the Board instituted inter partes review of the '992 patent on November 21, 2025, and that the deadline for the Board to decide whether to institute post-grant review of the '781 patent was December 26, 2025. Subject to the court's approval, the parties stipulated to stay all dates in the scheduling order until the later of the Board's final decision in the inter partes review or, if instituted, its final decision in the post-grant review.
On December 4, 2025, Judge John Campbell Barker granted the stipulation to stay (D.I. 100), denied the motion to stay (D.I. 68) as moot, and administratively closed the case. The order directs the defendant to file a notice within seven days of the Board's issuance of its final decision in the inter partes review or, if instituted, its final decision in the post-grant review, so that the case may be reopened and other appropriate action may be taken.
What to watch next
Watch for any request for rehearing or notice of appeal from the November 17, 2026 decision. Parties seeking judicial review must comply with 37 C.F.R. 90.2. Watch also for any decision in PGR2025-00054, and for the notice the December 4, 2025 order calls for in the District of Delaware case. The case can end at any time, including by settlement or voluntary dismissal.