The decisions

On November 17, 2026, the Patent Trial and Appeal Board entered final written decisions in two inter partes reviews that Suzhou Mojawa Intelligent Electronic Co., Ltd. brought against Shenzhen Shokz Co., Ltd. In Suzhou Mojawa Intelligent Electronic Co., Ltd. v. Shenzhen Shokz Co., Ltd., IPR2025-00842, Paper 37, Administrative Patent Judges Thu A. Dang, Georgianna W. Braden, and Stephen E. Belisle held that Mojawa had not shown claims 1-10 and 12-20 of U.S. Patent 11,197,084 B2 unpatentable. Judge Dang wrote for the panel. In IPR2025-00843, Paper 40, the same panel held that Mojawa had not shown claims 1-12, 14, and 16-20 of U.S. Patent 11,310,582 B2 unpatentable. Judge Braden wrote for the panel. Each decision is a judgment under 35 U.S.C. 318(a), captioned "Determining No Challenged Claims Unpatentable." Each order states that, because the decision is a final written decision, parties seeking judicial review must comply with the notice and service requirements of 37 C.F.R. 90.2.

The patents and the parties

Mojawa is the petitioner. Shokz is the patent owner. In each proceeding, each party identifies itself as its sole real party in interest.

The '084 patent is titled "Loudspeaker Apparatus." The final written decision states that it issued on December 7, 2021, from an application filed on December 30, 2020, as a continuation of PCT application PCT/CN2019/102397, filed on August 24, 2019, which claims priority to Chinese application 201910009927.4, filed on January 5, 2019. The patent has 20 claims. The decision states that the disclosure relates to a loudspeaker apparatus with a waterproof function, and that the loudspeaker may include an earphone, an MP3 player, and a hearing aid.

The '582 patent is also titled "Loudspeaker Apparatus." The final written decision states that it issued on April 19, 2022, and that it is assigned to Shenzhen Shokz Co., Ltd. The face of the patent names Shenzhen Shokz Co., Ltd. as the applicant and as the assignee. It states that the application was filed on December 31, 2020, that the patent is a continuation of PCT application PCT/CN2019/102393, also filed on August 24, 2019, and that it claims priority to the same Chinese application, filed on January 5, 2019. The face states that the patent is subject to a terminal disclaimer. The petition states that the applicant filed a terminal disclaimer after a rejection of claim 1 for nonstatutory double patenting, and that 20 claims issued on April 19, 2022. The decision describes a loudspeaker apparatus with a waterproof function, which may include an earphone, an MP3 player, and a hearing aid.

What was challenged

In IPR2025-00842, the petition requests cancellation of claims 1-10 and 12-20. Claim 11 is not challenged. The final written decision states that claim 1 is independent and that claims 2-10 and 12-20 depend from it, directly or indirectly. Claim 1 recites a loudspeaker apparatus with an ear hook that has a first plug end and a second plug end and is surrounded by a protective sleeve made of an elastic waterproof material. It recites a core housing for an earphone core, "the core housing being fixed to the first plug end and elastically abutted against the protective sleeve." It recites a circuit housing for a control circuit or a battery, fixed to the second plug end, with the control circuit or the battery driving the earphone core to vibrate so that the vibration generates a driving force to drive a housing panel of the core housing to vibrate, "the driving force being not parallel to a normal line of the housing panel."

In IPR2025-00843, the petition challenges claims 1-12, 14, and 16-20. The institution decision states that claims 13 and 15 are not challenged. Claim 1 is the sole independent claim challenged. It recites an ear hook with a first plug end and a second plug end, surrounded by a protective sleeve made of an elastic waterproof material, and a core housing "fixed to the first plug end and elastically abutted against the protective sleeve." It also recites a housing panel facing the human body and a housing back panel opposite the housing panel. The vibration of the earphone core drives both panels to vibrate. As the final written decision quotes claim 1, "when the vibration frequencies of the housing panel and the housing back panel is within a range of 2000 Hz to 3000 Hz, an absolute value of a difference between the first phase and the second phase is less than 60 degrees." A circuit housing fixed to the second plug end accommodates a control circuit or a battery that drives the earphone core to vibrate to generate a sound.

Institution

On November 19, 2025, the Board instituted both reviews. In IPR2025-00842, Paper 15, Administrative Patent Judges St. John Courtenay III, Georgianna W. Braden, and Steven M. Amundson instituted review of claims 1-10 and 12-20 on all challenges included in the petition. Judge Amundson wrote that decision. Patent Owner's preliminary response in that review is Paper 10. In IPR2025-00843, Paper 15, the same institution panel instituted review of claims 1-12, 14, and 16-20 on all four unpatentability grounds in the petition. Judge Courtenay wrote that decision. Patent Owner's preliminary response in that review is Paper 11. The final written decisions were entered by the panel of Judges Dang, Braden, and Belisle.

In IPR2025-00842, Patent Owner's response is Paper 22, Petitioner's reply is Paper 28, and Patent Owner's sur-reply is Paper 29. In IPR2025-00843, Patent Owner's response is Paper 25, Petitioner's reply is Paper 31, and Patent Owner's sur-reply is Paper 32. The Board held an oral argument in each review on August 25, 2026. The transcript is Paper 36 in IPR2025-00842 and Paper 39 in IPR2025-00843.

The grounds

Every ground in both reviews is obviousness under 35 U.S.C. 103. In IPR2025-00842, the final written decision's table lists claim 1 over Li and Fujita; claims 2-6 over Li, Fujita, and Asaka; claims 7-10 over Li, Fujita, and Numata; claims 12-15 over Li, Fujita, and Fukuda; and claims 16-20 over Li, Fujita, Wang, Xu, and Nielsen. Li is Chinese publication CN107454492A, published December 8, 2017, titled "A Bone Conduction Earphone" (certified English translation, Ex. 1004). Fujita is international publication WO 2008/007666 A1, "Bone Conduction Receiver," published January 17, 2008 (Ex. 1022). Asaka is CN 202931524 U, published May 8, 2013 (Ex. 1006). Numata is JP P2008-294872 A, published December 4, 2008 (Ex. 1007). Wang is CN 205356672 U, published June 29, 2016 (Ex. 1008). Xu is CN 205017577 U, published February 3, 2016 (Ex. 1009). Nielsen is WO 2009/086838 A1, published July 16, 2009 (Ex. 1010). Fukuda is U.S. Patent 9,253,563 B2, issued February 2, 2016 (Ex. 1023).

In IPR2025-00843, the final written decision's table lists claims 1 and 14 over Li and Liao; claims 2-6 over Li, Liao, and Asaka; claims 7-12 over Li, Liao, and Numata; and claims 16-20 over Li, Liao, Wang, Xu, and Nielsen. The petition identifies Liao as Chinese publication CN106937222A, published July 7, 2017 (Ex. 1005). Li, Asaka, Numata, Wang, Xu, and Nielsen are the same publications identified in IPR2025-00842. Fujita and Fukuda are not among the references in IPR2025-00843.

The '084 final written decision

The Board gave "elastically abutting," as used for the core housing and the protective sleeve in claim 1, its ordinary and customary meaning, as Patent Owner proposed: "being in contact with the protective sleeve under an elastic force." It did not accept Shokz's argument that the contact must be between an end surface of the core housing and the sleeve.

On the complete record, the Board determined that Mojawa had not shown that Li and Fujita teach "a core housing for accommodating an earphone core, the core housing being fixed to the first plug end and elastically abutted against the protective sleeve." The Board also determined that Mojawa had not shown that a person of ordinary skill would have combined Li with Fujita to teach the circuit-housing limitation: a circuit housing fixed to the second plug end, with the control circuit or the battery driving the earphone core to vibrate, the vibration generating a driving force to drive a housing panel of the core housing to vibrate, the driving force not parallel to a normal line of the housing panel. The decision states that Fujita's vibrating cushion needs a gap from the surrounding casing so it can vibrate against the user, while Li places the speaker inside a housing that can include a waterproof membrane. The Board found Mojawa's statement that a skilled artisan "would, therefore, have been motivated to use Fujita's construction of the bone conduction speakers" "insufficient as evidentiary support."

The Board concluded that Li in view of Fujita does not teach or suggest all limitations of claim 1, and that Mojawa had not shown claim 1 obvious over Li and Fujita. Claims 2-6, 7-10, 12-15, and 16-20 depend from claim 1. The decision states that Mojawa's arguments on those claims rely on its arguments for claim 1 regarding the Li and Fujita combination. The Board held that claims 2-6 were not shown unpatentable over Li, Fujita, and Asaka; that claims 7-10 were not shown unpatentable over Li, Fujita, and Numata; that claims 12-15 were not shown unpatentable over Li, Fujita, and Fukuda; and that claims 16-20 were not shown unpatentable over Li, Fujita, Wang, Xu, and Nielsen. The decision's summary table places each of those claims in the column for claims not shown unpatentable. The order states that, based on the preponderance of the evidence, claims 1-10 and 12-20 have not been shown to be unpatentable.

The '582 final written decision

The Board construed "elastically abutting" to mean "a surface of the core housing being in contact with the protective sleeve under an elastic force." The decision states that this construction varies slightly from Shokz's proposal because it does not require that an end surface of the core housing be the surface in contact with the sleeve. On claim 5, Mojawa contended, and Shokz agreed, that one limitation contains a typo, and the Board construed the words "surface of the first plug end" in that limitation to mean "surface of the second plug end."

The Board treated limitation [1c] as dispositive. That limitation recites "the core housing being fixed to the first plug end and elastically abutted against the protective sleeve." The Board determined that Mojawa had not shown, by a preponderance of the evidence, that Li and Liao render that limitation obvious. It found that Li's discussion of a tight fit between a plug and a hole does not show an elastic force, and that placing a cut in Li's ear hook so that the protective sleeve would elastically abut the core housing "would take hindsight knowledge of the claims." The Board held that claim 1 was not shown obvious over Li and Liao.

Claim 14 depends from claim 1 and was challenged on the same Li and Liao ground. Claims 2-6 add Asaka, claims 7-12 add Numata, and claims 16-20 add Wang, Xu, and Nielsen. The decision states that Mojawa's arguments on each of those claims rely on its arguments for limitation [1c] of claim 1. The Board held that none of those claims was shown unpatentable. The summary table lists claims 1 and 14, claims 2-6, claims 7-12, and claims 16-20 in the column for claims not shown unpatentable. The overall outcome is claims 1-12, 14, and 16-20. The order states that those claims have not been shown to be unpatentable.

The related case the decisions name

The final written decision and the institution decision in IPR2025-00842 identify a related civil action that Shenzhen Shokz Co., Ltd. brought in the Northern District of Illinois, No. 1:24-cv-06717, in which Mojawa is a defendant. The institution decision states that the action was filed July 31, 2024. The final written decision and the institution decision in IPR2025-00843 identify the same action. The docket in that case shows a September 17, 2025 order granting Mojawa's motion to stay pending resolution of the inter partes reviews and directing a joint status report within 14 days of the PTO's ruling.

What to watch next

Watch for any request for rehearing or any notice of appeal in either review. Parties seeking judicial review of either decision must comply with the notice and service requirements of 37 C.F.R. 90.2.