The appeal

On November 20, 2026, the United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit decided American Honda Motor Co., Inc. v. Neo Wireless LLC, Nos. 2025-1354 and 2025-1360. American Honda Motor Co., Inc. and Tesla, Inc. are the appellants. Neo Wireless LLC is the appellee. The appeals are from the Patent Trial and Appeal Board in Nos. IPR2022-01567, IPR2023-00793, and IPR2023-00963. The opinion states: "NOTE: This disposition is nonprecedential." The panel was Chief Judge Moore and Judges Prost and Taranto. Judge Taranto wrote the opinion. The opinion is Document 55 in No. 2025-1354, and the decision line states that it was decided November 20, 2026.

The opinion states the result in its opening: "Because the meaning of 'coordinate,' as used in the '450 patent, confirms that 'a starting time-frequency coordinate' refers to a single value, we affirm." The last line of the opinion is "AFFIRMED."

The '450 patent

The opinion states that Neo Wireless LLC owns U.S. Patent No. 10,447,450. The face of the patent is titled "Method and System for Multi-Carrier Packet Communication with Reduced Overhead." It gives the date of the patent as October 15, 2019. It states that the application number is 15/676,421 and that the application was filed on August 14, 2017.

The opinion states that the '450 patent describes a system for minimizing "control overhead" in a wireless network to improve bandwidth-use efficiency. It cites column 1, lines 33-34, and column 2, lines 13-16 and 45-47. It states that control overhead is information transmitted to inform a device of what time-frequency resources it is to use, citing column 1, lines 40-55. It states that the portion of control overhead indicating where a segment begins is what the patent calls "a starting time-frequency coordinate."

Claim 1

The opinion states that the parties agree that independent claim 1 is representative of the claims on appeal. Claim 1, as the patent prints it at column 12, lines 47-67, recites: "An operating method for a wireless network comprising at least a base station and a mobile station, the wireless network employing a frame structure of multiple frames for transmission, each frame comprising a plurality of time intervals, each time interval comprising a plurality of orthogonal frequency division multiplexing (OFDM) symbols, and each OFDM symbol containing a plurality of frequency subcarriers, the method comprising: assigning an identifier to the mobile station; transmitting a signal containing information from the base station to the mobile station over a segment of time-frequency resource, the segment having a starting time-frequency coordinate and the segment comprising N time-frequency resource units within a time interval, each unit containing a set of frequency subcarriers in a group of OFDM symbols, where N=2, 4, or 8; and receiving by the mobile station the transmitted signal; and recovering by the mobile station the information from the received signal based on the starting time-frequency coordinate and N in conjunction with the identifier assigned to the mobile station."

The Board's construction

The opinion states that the claims were held not proven unpatentable in the inter partes reviews under 35 U.S.C. §§ 311-319 that were before the court. In the decision jointly resolving all three IPRs, the Board concluded that "a starting time-frequency coordinate," a requirement of all claims, does not cover separate time and frequency coordinates. The Board relied for that construction in significant part on its previous decision declining to institute an inter partes review of the same claims, in which the Board agreed with Neo's submission about that phrase's scope. The Board viewed the earlier proceeding as establishing a scope-limiting prosecution disclaimer. Based on that construction, the Board rejected the challenge to the '450 patent's claims. It found that the asserted prior-art references used separate time and frequency coordinates and so did not teach "a starting time-frequency coordinate." The opinion cites that decision as American Honda Motor Co. Inc. v. Neo Wireless LLC, IPR2022-01567, 2024 WL 4648090 (P.T.A.B. Nov. 1, 2024).

The earlier petition

The opinion states that on September 16, 2021, another company petitioned for an inter partes review of all claims of the '450 patent. That petitioner argued that the claims should be deemed unpatentable for obviousness over two prior-art references. In its preliminary response, Neo argued that the earlier petitioner's asserted references did not suggest a one-dimensional time-frequency approach to reducing control overhead.

The opinion quotes Neo's summary. Neo wrote that FIG. 6 of the '450 patent does not show using a time coordinate and an independent frequency coordinate to specify V2. Neo wrote that, consistent with the invention's objective of reducing control overhead, FIG. 6 shows that only one time-frequency coordinate, VZI2 = 1, is needed to specify where V2 starts in both time and frequency. Neo wrote that the earlier petition incorrectly proposes that the word "coordinate" allows for a combination of two coordinates, and specifically that "a starting time-frequency coordinate" can be interpreted to encompass a time coordinate plus a frequency coordinate. Neo wrote that claim 1 does not recite a time coordinate and a frequency coordinate. It recites a starting time-frequency coordinate. Neo wrote that the construction "contravenes the plain meaning." Neo wrote that, based on that construction, the earlier petitioner concludes that a prior-art disclosure of "a start symbol offset (8 bits)" plus "a start logical subchannel offset (6 bits)" satisfies the recited "starting time-frequency coordinate."

The Board declined to institute review of the challenged claims on March 16, 2022. The opinion identifies two points in that denial. The Board stated that no terms or phrases in the claims required express construction. The Board concluded that the asserted prior-art combination failed to teach the starting time-frequency limitation. It agreed with Neo that the asserted prior art taught only independent time and frequency coordinates and independent time and frequency units. It described the earlier challenge as premised on a conclusory conflation of separate starting time and frequency coordinates as the recited singular "starting time-frequency coordinate."

Volkswagen's petition and the joinder

The opinion states that on September 27, 2022, Volkswagen Group of America, Inc. petitioned for an inter partes review of all claims of the '450 patent. Volkswagen relied on prior-art references that had not been the basis of the earlier challenge. Volkswagen's petition quoted the denial's explanation that the earlier petitioner had conflated separate starting time and frequency coordinates as the recited singular "starting time-frequency coordinate." Volkswagen argued that its asserted prior art, and particularly a reference called Vijayan089, did recite a singular coordinate consisting of the ordered pair (Symbol Period, Subband Group).

The opinion states that Vijayan089 is U.S. Patent Application No. 2005/0058089. It states that Vijayan089 teaches techniques for multiplexing and transmitting multiple data streams in a multi-carrier wireless communication system. It states that the reference's system bandwidth is partitioned into multiple orthogonal subbands by multi-carrier modulation techniques, for example orthogonal frequency-division multiplexing, and that resources are allocated on a time-frequency plane.

The Board instituted the requested inter partes review on May 4, 2023. In the institution decision, the Board preliminarily found that, regardless of whether it adopted Neo's construction of "time-frequency coordinate" as a one-dimensional time-frequency coordinate, at least Vijayan089 taught such a coordinate. The opinion cites Volkswagen Group of America, Inc. v. Neo Wireless LLC, IPR No. 2022-01567, 2023 WL 5059729, at *6 (P.T.A.B. May 4, 2023). The opinion states that the Board explained, at *17, that Vijayan089's scheme maps all of the slots in a two-dimensional strip onto a one-dimensional strip and then performs two-dimensional slot assignment using one dimension, and that Vijayan089 therefore teaches a one-dimensional time-frequency coordinate.

The opinion states that, after instituting Volkswagen's IPR, the Board received a petition from American Honda Motor Co., Inc. in spring 2023, and a petition from General Motors LLC, Nissan North America, Inc., and Tesla, Inc. in summer 2023. In fall 2023 the Board joined those petitioners to the Volkswagen IPR. The opinion states that the joinder is why the caption lists three IPRs. It states that, at present, only Honda and Tesla remain as petitioners, and that they are now the appellants.

The final written decision

The opinion states that, after post-institution filings and argument, the final written decision rejected the petitioners' challenge to the '450 patent's claims. It cites the decision at *21-22. On the only issue presented on appeal, the Board agreed with Neo about the scope of "a starting time-frequency coordinate," relying in part, though not exclusively, on the denial of the earlier petition. The opinion quotes the Board. The Board wrote that its decision denying institution, finding that "a starting time-frequency coordinate" is not disclosed by separate starting time and frequency coordinates, constitutes a disclaimer which is binding on these proceedings. The Board found that the ordinary and customary meaning of "a starting time frequency coordinate" excludes separate time and frequency coordinates. The Board agreed that the specification is consistent with that construction because it discloses segments of time-frequency resource, for example V1, V2, and so on, each having a starting time-frequency coordinate, for example the index values VZ1 = 0, VZ2 = 1, and VZ3 = 9. The opinion cites that passage at *8. At *14, the Board restated that separate time and frequency coordinates have been disclaimed from the ordinary and customary meaning of "a starting time-frequency coordinate."

The opinion states that, applying that understanding, the Board found that the petitioners had not shown that Vijayan089 meets the limitation. The Board found that what the petitioners identified in Vijayan089 as meeting the limitation relied on separate time and frequency coordinates, and that the petitioners had pointed to no contrary passage in Vijayan089. The opinion cites the decision at *14. The Board also ruled that the petitioners had not timely raised an argument that a relevant artisan would modify Vijayan089 to "assign index numbers to all slots and identify the starting coordinate of a segment through the slot index number."

The opinion states that the Board entered final judgment on November 1, 2024. It states that Honda and Tesla timely appealed the Board's construction of "a starting time-frequency coordinate" on January 2, 2025. It states that the court has jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. § 1295(a)(4)(A).

How the court read the word coordinate

The opinion states the standard of review. The court resolves legal issues de novo and reviews findings of fact for substantial evidence. It cites Incept LLC v. Palette Life Sciences, Inc., 77 F.4th 1366, 1371 (Fed. Cir. 2023). It states that the ultimate construction of a patent claim term, and the proper understanding of evidence intrinsic to the patent, are legal issues. It cites Teva Pharmaceuticals USA, Inc. v. Sandoz, Inc., 574 U.S. 318, 331 (2015). The opinion states that Honda and Tesla argued that prosecution disclaimer does not apply and that the claim limitation is broad enough to cover separate time and frequency values.

The court began with the claim language. It cites In re NTP, Inc., 654 F.3d 1279, 1288 (Fed. Cir. 2011), which cites Phillips v. AWH Corp., 415 F.3d 1303, 1312 (Fed. Cir. 2005) (en banc). The opinion states that the language of "a starting time-frequency coordinate" supports the Board's construction. It quotes claim 1, column 12, lines 58-60: "the segment having a starting time-frequency coordinate and the segment comprising N time-frequency resource units within a time interval." The opinion states that "coordinate" is a singular noun, not a plural noun, and that it requires a single figure to identify its subject. It cites Hertz Corp. v. Friend, 559 U.S. 77, 93 (2010), which construed a statute to require a single principal place of business where the word "place" is in the singular, not the plural. The opinion states that the modifier in front of "coordinate" specifies the subject, time and frequency, and that the language on its face requires a single figure that denotes time and frequency information.

The opinion states that the specification connects the recited coordinate to a single value. The '450 patent consistently refers to the starting location of a resource segment as its "offset." It cites column 1, lines 62-64, column 6, lines 24-29, and column 7, lines 7-9. It explains that this offset, representing the starting place of a segment, is one-dimensional. It quotes column 6, lines 22-26: when the zones are further subdivided into time-frequency segments in accordance with certain rules, a mapping of packet streams to segment may be achieved using a one-dimensional offset with respect to the origin of the zone rather than the two-dimensional mapping used in the prior art. The opinion states that this description distinguishes the prior art, in which specifying the segment location calls for separate offsets in time and in frequency. It cites column 1, lines 62-66, which describes the start of a prior-art segment as identified in the time domain scale with a start symbol offset and in the frequency domain scale with a start logical subchannel offset. The opinion states that the specification exemplifies "a starting time-frequency coordinate" as each a single value, one of VZI1, VZI2, VZI3, and so on. It cites Figure 6 and column 7, lines 7-27.

The opinion states that the petitioners' view, in the opening brief at page 36, that the starting time-frequency coordinate "may also be identified as separate time and frequency coordinates," is undercut by the specification. It addresses the petitioners' assertion, at page 37, that "any location on a general x-y graph can be expressed using separate x and y coordinates." The court stated that the assertion does not establish an ordinary meaning of the singular "coordinate" as referring to a pair (x, y), as opposed to referring to each member of that pair. The opinion states that the petitioners' own phrase, "separate x and y coordinates," confirms the ordinary meaning of "coordinate" in the singular.

Prosecution disclaimer

The opinion states that the claim text and the specification are the background for Neo's statements, in the preliminary response to the 2021 petition, that the required coordinate must be a single value, not separate time and frequency values. The Board relied on that view of the limitation in denying institution in March 2022. The petitioners challenged the Board's use of prosecution disclaimer to reach its construction. The opinion states: "We reject this criticism."

The court wrote that the claim and specification evidence "points strongly in favor of the very position Neo successfully urged on the Board in the [earlier] IPR." In that context, the opinion states, Neo's statements in the earlier IPR, that "only one time-frequency coordinate," for example "VZI2 = 1," "is needed to specify where [a segment] starts in both time and frequency," provide further support for the conclusion that the claimed "coordinate" is limited to a single value. The opinion then states that, because the statements in the earlier IPR "are entirely consistent with the claim and specification intrinsic evidence," "we need not assess whether, if they were not, the statements would support a disclaimer conclusion."

The opinion states the court's agreement with the Board: the claims of the '450 patent require that the starting point of a segment of time-frequency resource be specified by a single value, "a starting time-frequency coordinate," and not by separate time and frequency values.

Vijayan089

The opinion states that, in the reply brief, the petitioners seem to present a challenge to the Board's finding that Vijayan089 fails to disclose "a starting time-frequency coordinate" even under the construction the Board adopted and the court affirms. The opinion states that this challenge is different from a challenge to the construction. It cites Mettler-Toledo, Inc. v. B-Tek Scales, LLC, 671 F.3d 1291, 1297 (Fed. Cir. 2012). It states that the challenge would call for substantial-evidence review of the Board's factual finding about what Vijayan089 teaches. It cites Sierra Wireless, ULC v. Sisvel S.p.A., 130 F.4th 1019, 1022 (Fed. Cir. 2025). It states that the petitioners had to present that challenge, separately and with developed argument, in the opening brief. It cites Communications Test Design, Inc. v. Contec, LLC, 952 F.3d 1356, 1363 n.4 (Fed. Cir. 2020), and SmithKline Beecham Corp. v. Apotex Corp., 439 F.3d 1312, 1319 (Fed. Cir. 2006).

The opinion states that the petitioners did not do so. The opening brief states a single issue, one of claim construction, in the statement of the issues. The statement of the standard of review does not refer to substantial-evidence review. The arguments that follow seek reversal of the Board's claim construction based on the Board's use of prosecution disclaimer. A final section of the opening brief discusses Vijayan089 only to contend that the Board's application of its construction to Vijayan089 makes the error of that construction evident. The opinion concludes that the petitioners have not preserved an argument that the Board reversibly erred in its reading of Vijayan089.

The judgment

The opinion states: "We have considered petitioners' remaining arguments and find them unpersuasive. For the foregoing reasons, we affirm the Board's decision." The disposition is "AFFIRMED." The opinion is nonprecedential.