The two opinions

On November 19, 2026, the United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit decided three appeals in two nonprecedential opinions. Judge Stoll wrote both. The panel in each was Judges Lourie, Stoll, and Stark. Each opinion states: "NOTE: This disposition is nonprecedential." Each states that the court has jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. § 1295(a)(1).

The Apple and Amazon opinion is Touchmusic Entertainment LLC v. Apple Inc., Nos. 2025-1733 and 2025-1734, Document 66. Touchmusic Entertainment LLC is listed as plaintiff. Ziklag IP LLC is the plaintiff-appellant. Apple Inc. and Amazon Web Services, Inc. are the defendants-appellees. The appeals are from the United States District Court for the Northern District of Illinois in Nos. 1:24-cv-01786 and 1:24-cv-01787, Judge Steven C. Seeger. The Netflix opinion is Touchmusic Entertainment LLC v. Netflix, Inc., No. 2025-1960, Document 49. The Apple and Amazon opinion states that the Netflix opinion was issued concurrently. Touchmusic is listed as plaintiff. Ziklag is the plaintiff-appellant. Netflix, Inc. is the defendant-appellee. The appeal is from No. 1:24-cv-01789, Judge Mary M. Rowland.

The '128 patent

U.S. Patent No. 6,182,128 B1 is titled Real-time music distribution systems. The face states that the date of the patent is January 30, 2001, that the application number is 09/035,194, and that the application was filed on March 5, 1998. The face names Touchmusic Entertainment LLC, of Los Angeles, California, as assignee. It states that the patent has 17 claims and 3 drawing sheets. The Apple and Amazon opinion states that the '128 patent "had expired nearly six years earlier on March 5, 2018." The Netflix opinion states the same expiration date.

The complaints and the assignment

The Apple and Amazon opinion states that on March 2, 2024, Touchmusic filed two complaints in the Northern District of Illinois. One accused Apple Inc. of infringing the '128 patent. The other accused Amazon Web Services, Inc. of infringing the '128 patent. The opinion states that the district court assigned both cases to Judge Steven C. Seeger. The docket feed for No. 1:24-cv-01786 is captioned Ziklag IP LLC v. Amazon Web Services, Inc., and its complaint entry is dated March 2, 2024. The Netflix opinion states that on March 3, 2024, Touchmusic accused Netflix, Inc. of infringing the '128 patent. The Apple and Amazon opinion cites that complaint as Document 1 in No. 1:24-cv-01789, filed March 3, 2024.

Both opinions state that when Touchmusic filed these complaints, its corporate rights were suspended under California law, "thereby prohibiting it from initiating litigation." The Apple and Amazon opinion states that on April 18, 2024, Touchmusic assigned certain rights in the '128 patent to the newly incorporated Ziklag, and that Touchmusic and Ziklag thereafter filed amended complaints that substituted Ziklag for Touchmusic as the plaintiff. The Amazon docket feed shows an amended complaint entered on June 3, 2024.

The Netflix opinion quotes the district court's account of that case. Touchmusic was suspended in California when it filed the original complaint on March 3, 2024. California did not lift the suspension and restore Touchmusic's good standing until April 19, 2024. Ziklag was formed as a Tennessee limited liability company on April 18, 2024. On that same day, Touchmusic assigned the underlying patent to Ziklag. On May 17, 2024, Ziklag filed an amended complaint replacing Touchmusic as the plaintiff but otherwise making no changes to the original complaint. The district court, as quoted, concluded that the substitution "was therefore not due to an honest mistake but was done for tactical advantage to avoid the issue of Touchmusic's suspended corporate status and the impact it could have on pursuing this lawsuit." The Netflix docket feed shows that amended complaint as an entry dated May 17, 2024.

The dismissals

The Apple and Amazon opinion states that Apple and Amazon moved to dismiss the amended complaints, and that Amazon argued in part that Touchmusic did not assign Ziklag the right to sue for past damages. On March 31, 2025, the district court granted Amazon's motion. The opinion states that the court agreed Ziklag did not receive the right to sue for past damages, "which was fatal because the '128 patent was long expired," citing Ziklag IP LLC v. Amazon Web Services, Inc., 776 F. Supp. 3d 745, 754-55 (N.D. Ill. 2025). The opinion states that the district court determined that, "[f]or the same reasons," Ziklag's infringement claim against Apple "fails," citing J.A. 15, and dismissed both cases with prejudice. The Amazon docket feed's March 31, 2025 entries are that memorandum opinion and order, signed by Judge Steven C. Seeger, which states that the motion to dismiss is granted and that the civil case is terminated, and a judgment.

The Netflix opinion states that Netflix moved to dismiss, arguing in part that Touchmusic did not assign Ziklag the right to sue for past damages. On March 25, 2025, the district court granted the motion, agreeing that Ziklag did not receive that right, which was fatal because the '128 patent was long expired. The opinion cites Ziklag IP LLC v. Netflix, Inc., No. 24-cv-01789, 2025 WL 904311, at *4-5 (N.D. Ill. Mar. 25, 2025). The opinion states that the district court declined to dismiss with prejudice. It set a hearing to "discuss the propriety of any attempt to file an amended complaint and further briefing on Illinois law and [Touchmusic's] ability to initiate litigation," citing J.A. 60.

The district court's June 20, 2025 opinion states that on June 3, 2025, the court heard oral argument on the application of Illinois law to the capacity issue and the propriety of allowing Ziklag to file an amended complaint. That opinion states that the court finds that Touchmusic did have capacity to initiate the lawsuit under Illinois law, and that it denies Ziklag leave to file an amended complaint. At the hearing, the Netflix opinion states, the district court said its purpose was to hear what Ziklag had "to say in light of the order about filing an amended complaint." Ziklag argued that any issues could be cured by re-substituting Touchmusic as the named plaintiff, because Touchmusic retained the right to sue for past damages and its corporate status issue had been resolved. Ziklag also represented that it need not amend its complaint under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 15(a) or Rule 17 because, under Illinois law, Ziklag could be the proper plaintiff under certain circumstances.

The opinion states that approximately two weeks after the hearing, the district court denied leave to amend to re-substitute Touchmusic. It cites Ziklag IP LLC v. Netflix, Inc., No. 24-cv-01789, 2025 WL 1725136 (N.D. Ill. June 20, 2025). The opinion states that the district court dismissed the case with prejudice. The June 20, 2025 docket entry states that the court denies leave to amend the complaint and re-substitute Touchmusic as the proper plaintiff, that any other amendments would be futile because they would not relate back to the original complaint and the statute of limitations has passed, and that the civil case is terminated and judgment is to enter. The entry cites Russell v. Zimmer, Inc., 82 F.4th 564, 572 (7th Cir. 2023), for the statement that district courts have "broad discretion to deny leave to amend a complaint where the amendment would be futile." The Apple and Amazon opinion states that the Netflix district court entered final judgment on June 24, 2025. The Netflix docket feed shows a judgment entered that day.

Collateral estoppel in the Apple and Amazon appeals

The Apple and Amazon opinion states that Ziklag raised one issue, which it quotes from Ziklag's brief: "Whether the trial court erred in holding that the assignee of an expired patent cannot sue for past infringement because the written assignment from the assignor to the assignee did not expressly state that the assignee was granted the right to sue for past infringement." The opinion states that the court first had to decide whether collateral estoppel precludes Ziklag from challenging the district court's determination. It holds that collateral estoppel applies.

The opinion states that Ziklag did not challenge, on the Netflix appeal, the determination that Touchmusic did not assign Ziklag the right to sue for past damages. The court ordered the parties to file supplemental briefs "limited to addressing whether Touchmusic and Ziklag are collaterally estopped from arguing that the district court erred in holding that Touchmusic did not assign Ziklag the right to sue for past damages." The opinion cites that order as ECF No. 41 at 2, and states that the parties filed supplemental briefs at ECF Nos. 53-55, 59, 62, and 63.

The opinion quotes the general rule from B & B Hardware, Inc. v. Hargis Indus., Inc., 575 U.S. 138, 148 (2015): "[w]hen an issue of fact or law is actually litigated and determined by a valid and final judgment, and the determination is essential to the judgment, the determination is conclusive in a subsequent action between the parties, whether on the same or a different claim." It quotes Papst Licensing GMBH & Co. KG v. Samsung Elecs. Am., Inc., 924 F.3d 1243, 1251 n.2 (Fed. Cir. 2019), for the point that the loser in the first case may be precluded from relitigating an issue in a later action that does not involve its first-case adversary.

The opinion states that application of collateral estoppel is not a matter within the Federal Circuit's exclusive jurisdiction, so the court applies the law of the circuit in which the district court sits, here the Seventh Circuit, citing Bayer AG v. Biovail Corp., 279 F.3d 1340, 1345 (Fed. Cir. 2002). It quotes the Seventh Circuit standard from Adair v. Sherman, 230 F.3d 890, 893 (7th Cir. 2000). Collateral estoppel applies where "(1) the issue sought to be precluded is the same as that involved in a prior action; (2) the issue was actually litigated; (3) the determination of the issue was essential to the final judgment; and (4) the party against whom estoppel is invoked was represented in the prior action."

The opinion states that Apple and Amazon argue, and Ziklag does not dispute, that factors (2) through (4) are satisfied, and that the court agrees with Apple and Amazon "that each of these factors are met." A footnote addresses Ziklag's reference to the Netflix district court's March 25, 2025 dismissal opinion as an "interlocutory ruling." To the extent that reference challenges factor (3), the court disagrees. It states that the Netflix district court would not have reached the amended complaint issue if it had not first decided that Touchmusic retained the right to sue for past damages, so the ruling was essential to the Netflix final judgment. It states that, because Ziklag did not challenge that determination in the Netflix appeal, the determination will be incorporated within the Federal Circuit's mandate in the Netflix appeal. It quotes Engel Industries, Inc. v. Lockformer Co., 166 F.3d 1379, 1383 (Fed. Cir. 1999): "Unless remanded by this court, all issues within the scope of the appealed judgment are deemed incorporated within the mandate and thus are precluded from further adjudication." A further footnote states that the Netflix district court entered final judgment before Ziklag filed its opening brief in the Apple and Amazon appeals.

On the first factor, the opinion quotes Ziklag's argument that the question is whether Ziklag's failure to challenge the assignment determination in the co-pending Netflix appeal "converts that proceeding into 'prior litigation'" that precludes the court from deciding the issue in these appeals. Ziklag relied on Innovad Inc. v. Microsoft Corp., 260 F.3d 1326 (Fed. Cir. 2001), and In re Cygnus Telecommunications Technology, LLC, Patent Litigation, 536 F.3d 1343 (Fed. Cir. 2008). The opinion disagrees that those cases compel the conclusion that collateral estoppel does not apply.

The opinion describes Innovad as a case in which the court declined to apply collateral estoppel where the plaintiff did not appeal a judgment of non-infringement as to one of several co-defendants sued in the same district court case. The opinion quotes Innovad: there was "no 'first' or 'second' action for the purpose of issue preclusion." It describes Cygnus as a case in which the plaintiff did not appeal a judgment against one defendant in a consolidated multidistrict litigation, and the court declined to treat claims against the other defendants in that same consolidated action as precluded. The opinion quotes Cygnus: because the actions were consolidated in a single proceeding, "the proceeding is most logically viewed as a single, multi-defendant lawsuit."

The opinion gives four grounds for distinguishing those cases. First, the cases against Apple, Amazon, and Netflix are not "a single, multi-defendant lawsuit." Touchmusic filed separate complaints, and the district court did not consolidate them. The opinion cites Papst for the point that unconsolidated proceedings are distinct cases. Second, Netflix proceeded before a different judge. Third, the Netflix district court decided the assignment issue and dismissed Ziklag's complaint before the Amazon and Apple dismissals. The opinion states that the Netflix court did not enter final judgment until June 24, 2025, after those dismissals, but that the assignment determination will still be incorporated within the mandate in the Netflix appeal. Fourth, Ziklag has not asserted that it asked its adversaries to waive reliance on preclusion. The opinion states that this case is closer to a hypothetical noted in Cygnus: the result would be different if the actions had not been consolidated and one had gone to judgment before the others, with a judgment adverse to the plaintiff. The opinion states that all of the collateral estoppel factors are satisfied.

The opinion then states that if the court declined to apply collateral estoppel and reversed on the merits, there would be "an untenable inconsistency" with Netflix. In Netflix, the district court's determination that Touchmusic retained the right to sue for past damages is undisturbed. The opinion states that if the court reversed and remanded, Ziklag would necessarily have the right to sue for past damages, so that two entities would simultaneously own an undivided right to sue for past damages, "which cannot be correct and is precisely the type of inconsistency collateral estoppel is meant to prevent." It quotes Allen v. McCurry, 449 U.S. 90, 94 (1980), on the role of collateral estoppel in preventing inconsistent decisions. The opinion states that the court has considered Ziklag's remaining arguments and finds them unpersuasive. It concludes: "Because Ziklag is collaterally estopped from challenging the district court's holding that it cannot sue for past damages, we affirm." The disposition line is "AFFIRMED."

Leave to amend in the Netflix appeal

The Netflix opinion states that there is one issue: whether the district court abused its discretion in denying Ziklag leave to amend its complaint to re-substitute Touchmusic as the plaintiff. A footnote states that Ziklag does not challenge the district court's determination that Touchmusic retained the right to sue for past damages. The dismissal opinion, as the footnote cites it, dismissed the amended complaint because "Ziklag does not have the right to sue for past infringement." The Apple and Amazon opinion quotes the single issue Ziklag raised in the Netflix appeal, from Ziklag's corrected opening brief: "Whether the district court abused its discretion in denying Appellant Ziklag IP LLC the right to amend its complaint to resubstitute prior plaintiff Touchmusic Entertainment LLC as the proper plaintiff in this matter." The court holds that the district court did not abuse its discretion.

The opinion states that review of an order denying a motion to amend, "a subject which is not unique to patent law," follows the law of the regional circuit, here the Seventh Circuit, citing Kalman v. Berlyn Corp., 914 F.2d 1473, 1480 (Fed. Cir. 1990). It states that the Seventh Circuit reviews a denial of leave to amend for abuse of discretion, citing Hall v. Norfolk S. Ry. Co., 469 F.3d 590, 594 (7th Cir. 2006), and Datascope Corp. v. SMEC, Inc., 962 F.2d 1043, 1045 (Fed. Cir. 1992). It quotes Hall: the court of appeals will not reverse merely because it would have reached a different decision in the first instance. The district court's decision "must strike us as fundamentally wrong."

The opinion rejects Ziklag's argument that "the court did not allow Touchmusic to brief the issue on which the case was decided." It states that Ziklag had an opportunity to brief amendment in response to Netflix's argument, discussed in the March 25, 2025 order at *5-6, that no leave to amend should be granted at the motion-to-dismiss stage. It states that the order discussed applying Rule 17, which put Ziklag on notice that Rule 17 was at issue, and that the court set a hearing to discuss an amended complaint and further briefing on Illinois law and Touchmusic's ability to initiate litigation. It states that if Ziklag believed more briefing was necessary, Ziklag could have asked for leave to file it, and that the record indicates Ziklag did not.

The opinion also rejects the argument that the district court erred by deciding the case under Rule 17 "rather than considering the usual factors under Rule 15 when deciding whether to allow a party to amend a complaint." A footnote in the opinion quotes Rule 15(a)(2): "a party may amend its pleading only with the opposing party's written consent or the court's leave. The court should freely give leave when justice so requires." It quotes Rule 17(a)(3) in relevant part: "The court may not dismiss an action for failure to prosecute in the name of the real party in interest until, after an objection, a reasonable time has been allowed for the real party in interest to ratify, join, or be substituted into the action."

The opinion treats Lans v. Digital Equipment Corp., 252 F.3d 1320 (Fed. Cir. 2001), as instructive. There, the district court denied a motion to amend the complaint to substitute a company for the plaintiff under Rules 15 and 17. The Federal Circuit held that the appellant's "personal choices" occasioned the need to amend, that the trial court found the original allegations were not honest and understandable mistakes, and that denying leave was within the district court's discretion under both rules.

The opinion states that Ziklag's request to re-substitute Touchmusic likewise resulted from Ziklag's and Touchmusic's "personal choices." It quotes the 1966 advisory committee's note to Rule 17: the rule "is intended to prevent forfeiture when determination of the proper party to sue is difficult or when an understandable mistake has been made." It cites Federal Practice and Procedure § 1555 (3d ed. 2008) for the statement that when determining the right party was not difficult and no excusable mistake had been made, Rule 17(a)(3) is not applicable and the action should be dismissed. A footnote states that neither party cites binding Seventh Circuit precedent on Rule 17(a)(3), and that several district courts in the Seventh Circuit have held that the rule does not apply absent an understandable or honest mistake. Another footnote states that Ziklag does not challenge the district court's factual findings.

The opinion states that it sees no abuse of discretion in the finding that Ziklag has not made an "understandable mistake." It quotes the district court: the substitution "was . . . not due to an honest mistake but was done for tactical advantage to avoid the issue of Touchmusic's suspended corporate status and the impact it could have on pursuing this lawsuit." The opinion states that the district court did not abuse its discretion in applying Rule 17.

On Rule 15, the opinion quotes the factors Ziklag said the district court should have applied, from Foman v. Davis, 371 U.S. 178, 182 (1962): "undue delay, bad faith or dilatory motive on the part of the movant, repeated failure to cure deficiencies by amendments previously allowed, undue prejudice to the opposing party by virtue of allowance of the amendment, futility of amendment, etc." The opinion states that Ziklag never argued to the district court that the request had to be analyzed under Rule 15. It states that Ziklag instead suggested it did not "need a [Rule] 15(a) or 17 substitution" under certain circumstances, citing J.A. 34, line 25, to J.A. 35, line 1. Even considering Rule 15, the opinion states, the district court had already found that the request was not an honest mistake and was an attempt to gain a "tactical advantage." The opinion states: "In other words, Ziklag's request to amend was made in bad faith." It cites Chi. Joe's Tea Room, LLC v. Vill. of Broadview, 94 F.4th 588, 607-08 (7th Cir. 2024), and Vitrano v. United States, 643 F.3d 229, 234 (7th Cir. 2011). It quotes Vitrano: if a Rule 15(a)(2) motion "doesn't pass the sniff test, i.e., reeks of bad faith or dilatory motive, the district court is permitted to deny it and hold the plaintiff to his original complaint." The opinion concludes that, "even considering Rule 15(a), the district court did not abuse its discretion in denying Ziklag leave to amend its complaint."

The opinion states that the court has considered Ziklag's remaining arguments and finds them unpersuasive. "For the foregoing reasons, we affirm." The disposition line is "AFFIRMED."

The dockets after judgment

The Netflix district docket has four entries dated October 7, 2025, two labeled "Attorney Fees" and two labeled "Join." The Federal Circuit dockets for Nos. 2025-1733, 2025-1734, and 2025-1960 each show a judgment entered on November 19, 2026, the day of the opinions.